yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Presidential oversight of the bureaucracy


4m read
·Nov 11, 2024

You can view this diagram as an org chart of the government of the United States. What we have highlighted in this blue-green color is the executive branch and the things that fall under the executive branch. You can't even see everything; a lot of it falls off of the screen. When you see something like this, with roughly 2.6 million people part of that executive branch, part of the government's bureaucracy, and with the president at the top of the executive branch, you might get the idea that the president is quite powerful.

And you would be correct—the president is a powerful role. However, there are some factors about how the executive branch is structured and its size that might keep the president from being quite as powerful as you might first believe. First of all, managing 2.6 million people is no easy task. Ask anyone who even has to manage an organization of 20 or 30 people—much less 2,000 people or 200,000 people. It can get quite difficult; you have to manage through many layers of management.

The other interesting thing that makes the president's role in the executive branch different than, say, the CEO of a corporation is that yes, the president can make many appointments. In fact, the president can make several thousand appointments, and most of those appointments sit atop the various departments. But most of the bureaucracy, the federal bureaucracy—most of this 2.6 million—are not appointed by the president. Those are professionals in their field; they are part of the civil service system. So, as they make various judgments and interpret laws in certain ways and execute the machinery of the bureaucracy, they might not be completely in lockstep with the goals of the president.

Regarding that, the senior appointments—especially the cabinet secretaries—serve at the pleasure of the president. If the president becomes unhappy with them, if the president finds that they're disloyal in some way, the president can choose to have them leave—essentially fire them. Although in the news, you'll sometimes see that the president accepts their resignation. But as you get further down the bureaucracy, the president does not have that control.

The Supreme Court has ruled that for officers, the president can fire them, but as you go down into the regular rank and file, the majority of this 2.6 million people, the president can't fire them without cause. The president can't fire them just because they don't like those employees or feel that those employees don't completely agree with the president; it has to be for just cause.

This is why you'll see that some parts of the executive branch, say from the Department of Justice, might have investigations into things that the president does not want them to investigate. Oftentimes, they will investigate the president. This happened during the Nixon administration as part of the Watergate investigations. This occurred under the Clinton administration. This is happening at the time of this video as part of the Trump administration, the Mueller investigation. The president can't just willy-nilly fire folks if they say, "Hey, why are you looking into my matters?" Because of this principle that they can't fire just anyone within the executive branch.

Now, what levers does the president have to maybe exert more control than the things that I have just described? Well, of course, I've mentioned the appointments that the president can make. This could number in the several thousands of appointments. I've seen estimates as high as 4,000 appointments that the president can make. They can fire officers, so these would be the senior political appointments—things like the cabinet secretaries, the people at the head of these various departments.

However, even that could have some significant political consequences. The president could try to shift responsibilities from one part of the bureaucracy to another or shift budget from one part of the bureaucracy to another. But this is also not so easy because, once again, it's a large and complex bureaucracy. The president would have to do it through many layers of management and, at the end of the day, things like budget— which department gets how much money—this is, at the end of the day, something that Congress will decide as part of the separation of powers that we've talked about in multiple videos.

Another thing that the president can try to do—and we've talked about this in other videos—are the ideas of executive orders. Executive orders oftentimes can be a president trying to clarify how a law should be interpreted, how it should be executed upon by the bureaucracy, if the president feels that its bureaucracy is not interpreting laws in the way that meets the president's goals.

So, I will leave you there. The president is clearly the most powerful office in the United States, on top of a 2.6 million-person bureaucracy that's part of the executive branch. But the president is not a king; the president is not a chief executive officer of a for-profit company where they can have a lot more control. They're limited by just the inertia of the bureaucracy. They're limited by their ability to hire and fire people. They're limited by the complexity of the bureaucracy. But they do have some tools at their disposal where they can try to shape the direction and the goals of these 2.6 million federal employees.

More Articles

View All
The Role of Management Tools to Build an Organization's Culture
I think the most important thing is to have the right culture, right the right values. How are you dealing with yourself, and how are you dealing with others? So, in my case, I wanted meaningful work and meaningful relationships through radical truthfuln…
A Forest Garden With 500 Edible Plants Could Lead to a Sustainable Future | Short Film Showcase
[Music] If you do nothing to a piece of land in tempered climates, it will become a forest. The forces of nature are actively moving the land towards a balanced, sustainable, and resilient ecosystem. This is called succession. In southwest England, an un…
Regional climates | Weather and climate | Middle school Earth and space science | Khan Academy
What’s the weather usually like in the winter where you live? If you asked someone in Fairbanks, Alaska, they might describe below-freezing days and navigating through huge drifts of snow. If you asked someone else in Miami, Florida, they might tell you t…
Kevin O’Leary’s Rules for Avoiding Failure in Your 20s & 30s
The reason I invest in credit card companies is because I want some of those profits. Don’t let me profit from you; that’s crazy. I can’t make 21% in the market every year. Hi there! Chef Wonderful here again. I thought it’d be a great time of the year: …
Plant a Pollinator Garden | National Geographic
We all want to find ways to help our planet. This spring, start small by helping to preserve a critical element of our environment: wildflowers. Wildflowers, they do more than provide lovely scents; they’re pretty powerful. These beauties can hold the key…
Making Grilled Cheese at the Bottom of the World: A Day in the Life of a Scientist | Continent 7
My name is Paul. This is lunch in Antarctica. Everyday welcome to the kitchen, sits next to the science disc. I live on cheese toasties, so we make that’s lunch. My puppy here, three or four a day. It’s got a bit of cheese here. You can either use this or…