yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Mistakes when finding inflection points: not checking candidates | AP Calculus AB | Khan Academy


3m read
·Nov 11, 2024

Olga was asked to find where f of x is equal to x minus two to the fourth power has inflection points. This is her solution. So we look at her solution, and then they ask us: Is Olga's work correct? If not, what's her mistake?

So pause this video and see if you can figure this out.

All right, let's just follow her work. So here she's trying to take the first derivative. You would apply the chain rule: it would be four times x minus two to the third power times the derivative of x minus two, which is just one. So this checks out.

Then you take the derivative of this: it would be 3 times 4, which would be 12 times x minus 2 to the second power times the derivative of x minus 2, which is just 1. This is exactly what she has here: 12 times x minus 2 to the second power. That checks out. So step one's looking good for Olga.

Step two: the solution of the second derivative equaling zero is x equals two. That looks right. The second derivative is 12 times x minus two squared, and we want to make that equal to zero. This is only going to be true when x is equal to two. So step two is looking good.

Step three: Olga says f has an inflection point at x equals two. She's basing this just on the fact that the second derivative is 0 when x is equal to 2. Now, I have a problem with this because the fact that your second derivative is zero at x equals two makes two a nice candidate to check out. However, you can't immediately say that we have an inflection point there.

Remember, an inflection point is where we go from being concave upwards to concave downwards, or concave downwards to concave upwards. Speaking in the language of the second derivative, it means that the second derivative changes signs as we go from below x equals 2 to above x equals 2. But we have to test that, because it's not necessarily always the case.

So let's actually test it. Let's think about some intervals. Intervals? So let's think about the interval when we go from negative infinity to 2, and let's think about the interval where we go from 2 to positive infinity. If you want, you could have some test values; you could think about the sign of our second derivative, and then based on that, you could think about concavity—concavity of f.

So let's think about what's happening. You could take a test value. Let's say 1 is in this interval, and let's say 3 is in this interval. You could say 1 minus 2 squared is going to be, let's see, that's negative 1 squared, which is 1, and then you're just going to—this is just going to be 12. So this is going to be positive.

If you tried 3, 3 minus 2 squared is 1 times 12. Well, that's also going to be positive. So you're going to be concave upwards, at least at these test values. It looks like on either side of 2 that the sign of the second derivative is positive on either side of 2.

You might say, well, maybe I just need to find closer values. But if you inspect the second derivative here, you can see that this is never going to be negative. In fact, for any value other than x equals 2, this value right over here, since we're even if x minus 2 is negative, you're squaring it, which will make this entire thing positive, and then multiplying it times a positive value.

So for any value other than x equals 2, the sign of our second derivative is positive, which means that we're going to be concave upwards.

So we actually don't have an inflection point at x equals two because we are not switching signs as we go from values less than x equals two to values greater than x equals two. Our second derivative is not switching signs.

So once again, this is incorrect. We actually don't have an inflection point at x equals 2 because our second derivative does not switch signs as we cross x equals 2, which means our concavity does not change.

More Articles

View All
Acacia Ants Vs. Elephant | A Real Bug's Life | National Geographic
Up against the largest land animal, no bug is safe. The elephant is headed straight for our old-timer’s tree. She’s so shortsighted, she can’t see more than a few inches ahead. But she can feel through her feet, and she’s picking up bad vibes. Mammoth mon…
How to stop mentally escaping
So I was watching this Woody Allen film called Hannah and Her Sisters, and in the movie, there’s this scene where Michael Caine’s character, Elliot, is sitting at the dinner table with his wife, Hannah. Now, Elliot is completely emotionally detached; he i…
15 Reasons You are Behind in Life
Sometimes you’re behind in life for reasons that were initially out of your control. Sometimes you’re behind because of poor decisions you made when you had little life experience. But if you’re watching this video right now, then you’re self-aware enough…
Easy Photography Life Hack!
Okay, I just learned the greatest life hack. If you see something that you want to take a picture of, but you left your phone at home, don’t worry. Just do this: blindfold yourself for like 30 minutes, and then stare at what you want to take a picture of …
Clattering Penguins and Naughty Seals | Epic Adventures with Bertie Gregory on Disney+
Chin straps get their name from that black marking that runs under their chin. Uh, and they’re also sometimes called stone breaker penguins because of that ear-piercing screech. They’re really sociable birds that waddle ashore in these massive numbers to…
This Is How Old You Are | Brain Games
Brain games is going on vacation! We’ve come to the beach to see how your brain is primed to handle every chapter of life—your tween and teen years, adulthood, parenthood, and even your golden years. Let’s play a game that will show you just what stage o…