yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Auckland Clip 3: The Dawning of the Moral Sense


3m read
·Nov 7, 2024

It's not all that happens though when they eat the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil because it's not called the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of nakedness. It's called the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.

And I thought about that for a tremendous amount of time. It's like, what in the world? Because I assumed these old stories make sense. You know, it's a game I play. It's like they're old. They've been around a long time. I'm not sure why they're there, but there they are; they're at the basis of our culture, like many, many of the stories that we depend on.

Depend on them; our whole culture grew out of their roots, let's say, and so I assume that our ancestors, who managed to survive conditions that would have done a lot of us in very rapidly— I can tell you—were a lot smarter than we think.

And that the mysterious processes that produce these stories and compelled us to remember them are a lot more psychologically significant than we generally tend to presume. So I give them the benefit of the doubt and try to understand why it is that they might make sense instead of assuming that they don't. And that's not easy, as they are complicated stories.

And so I thought about this nakedness, knowledge of good and evil idea for a very, very long time, like about 20 years, puzzling it out. What the hell is the relationship between discovering that you're naked and discovering good and evil? And then one day, mostly because of studying totalitarianism and the atrocity that proclivity for people to commit atrocity in the service of their group belief— or maybe just because that's what they were like—clued me in, and I thought, I see.

This is one of the things that really makes people different than animals. It's like, you know, it's one thing to realize that you're naked. To realize that you're naked means that you know that you're limited in time and space, that you're mortal and that you're subject to degeneration and to social humiliation and to your own harsh judgment—all of that nakedness—to know that you're vulnerable against the world and definitely a source of shame because of that.

And a felt lack of self-sufficiency. And then, no wonder, and no wonder it's understandable. But the other thing is that this is—and this is the rub—it's like if you're out in the veldt and you're not being very careful and a hungry lion jumps on you and eats you, you don't really think of the lion as evil. I mean, you might right at that moment, but you know philosophically, it's not evil. It's just hungry.

And as soon as it's not hungry, then it goes and has a sleep, and it's not up to some malevolent trick. It's done for the day. But human beings, that's a whole different sort of creature. And because human beings are capable of doing terrible things to someone else and consciously so, you think, well, what's the connection between that and nakedness itself?

And it seems to be this—is like, here's the thing: once I realize that I can be hurt, you know, I have a self-conscious model of my own vulnerability. Then I can generalize that to other people. I can think, oh, this is interesting. Here's how I can be hurt by myself. Here's how I can be hurt by society. Here's how I can be hurt by nature and by the unknown.

And what that implies is that, well, you can be hurt with exactly the same mechanisms, and that, indeed, immediately becomes part of my—what would you say?—my repertoire of ability. And then all of a sudden the world is no longer a walled garden and a well-watered place, but it's a moral story.

Because with that ability to inflict suffering comes the knowledge of good and evil. As far as I'm concerned, those are identical propositions because now we have the choice—a deep choice—about how we're going to treat ourselves and each other.

We can inflict tremendous pain and suffering on each other in a very voluntary and conscious manner in a way that no other animal can manage. And that's the dawning of the moral sense: that capacity we now have to choose to mitigate or exaggerate suffering. And that's not all, but it's a huge part of it.

More Articles

View All
One Step at a Time | Life Below Zero
Long walk on a cold day. Thing I’ve learned about injuries is listen to your body. If your body’s hurting, it’s trying to tell you something. In this case right here, this leg’s trying to tell me not to use it. Just got to take it easy, take it one step …
New Hampshire Summer Learning Series Session 3: Master the SAT with “Khan Academy and SAT Prep”
The SAT prep are actually Mastery-enabled courses, and we’ll talk about what mastery enablement means in a second. But there are actually two different courses: there’s a reading and writing SAT prep course and a math SAT prep course. The content of both …
Vitalik: Ethereum, Part 1
All right, welcome everybody back to the podcast. We have with us Haseeb Qureshi, who’s our partner at Dragonfly. Haseeb and I used to work together back when I was more active in crypto land. Vitalik is, of course, a polymath ingenue, although he may bri…
Resonance | Molecular and ionic compound structure and properties | AP Chemistry | Khan Academy
Let’s see if we can draw the Lewis diagram for a nitrate anion. So, a nitrate anion has one nitrogen and three oxygens, and it has a negative charge. I’ll do that in another color; it has a negative charge. So, pause this video and see if you can draw th…
Kevin O'Leary Investment RuckPack featured on Bloomberg TV
There tell people first of all about Ruckpack. What is this? This company and product? Ruckpack is a peak performance nutrition shot, pure and simple. It’s good ingredients; it’s the things you need that your body needs to stay on top, to stay in peak per…
Car buying pitfalls | Car buying | Financial Literacy | Khan Academy
What we’re going to do in this video is think about some things that you should think about when you are buying a car. To help us with that, we have this fake invoice from a car dealership for a car I guess that I am buying. This looks like a used Honda O…