yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Is the Universe Discrete or Continuous?


2m read
·Nov 3, 2024

You said that we went from atoms in the time of Democritus down to nuclei, and from there to protons and neutrons, and then to quarks. It's particles all the way down. To paraphrase Feynman, we can keep going forever, but it's not quite forever. Right at some point, you run into the Planck length. There's the Planck time, there's the Planck length, there's even the Planck mass, which is actually quite a large mass.

These things don't have any physical significance. It's not like the Planck time is the shortest possible time, and it's not like the Planck length is the shortest possible length. The reason for that is because these Planck things are part of quantum theory, but length is not described by quantum theory. It's described by the general theory of relativity, and in that theory, space is infinitely divisible.

There is no smallest possible length or time. This illuminates an ancient tension between the discrete and the continuous because quantum theory seems to suggest that things are discrete. For example, there's a smallest possible particle of gold—the gold atom. There's a smallest possible particle of electricity—the electron. There's a smallest possible particle of light—the photon.

In quantum theory, we have this idea of discreteness—that there is a smallest possible thing from which everything else is built. But in general relativity, the idea is the opposite. It says things can continuously vary, and if the mathematics requires that things be continuously variable, so they can be differentiated and so on.

The idea there is that you can keep on dividing up space, and you can keep on dividing up time. So physicists understand that there is this contradiction at the deepest level of our most foundational explanations in physics. It's one of the reasons why there are these attempts to try and unify quantum theory and general relativity.

Because what is the fundamental nature of reality? Is it that things can be infinitely divisible? Or is it that we must stop somewhere or other? Because if it's infinitely divisible, then quantum theory might have to be subservient to general relativity. But we just don't know.

More Articles

View All
Dangerous Mission | No Man Left Behind
It was an enormous honor to be chosen as a stealth fighter pilot. It was considered a special duty, black world. I felt extremely comfortable in that environment; absolutely loved it. I felt like this is where I belong. There were eight of us that night,…
Reshma Shetty, Founder of Ginkgo Bioworks at the Female Founders Conference
Thank you all for being here today. It’s a real honor to be around such an amazing group of women. I’d like to thank Sharon and Kat for inviting me to come talk to you all. It’s a real honor. As Jessica said, I’m a co-founder of a company called Topeka Bi…
Beginnings of Islam part 2
Where we left off in the last video, we saw Muhammad being born into a tribal Arabia. He’s born into a powerful tribe, the Quraish, who are in control of Mecca. But his early life is difficult. His mother dies when he’s six; his grandfather, who’s taken c…
This Is Not Yellow
Using GPS, these trails represent pizza delivery in Manhattan on a typical Friday night. And is this a frog or a horse? It’s episode 52 of IMG! This lemon looks yellow to me, and it probably looks yellow to you as well, but not in the same way. You see, …
Methods for subracting 3 digit numbers
Hello! In this video, we’re going to think about techniques for subtracting three-digit numbers. So, let’s say we wanted to figure out what 357 minus 156 is. Pause this video and see if you can somehow figure this out. You don’t have to be able to, becaus…
David Friedman. Private Rights Enforcement.
I imagine a society where there is no government. Where each individual is the customer of a firm that sells him the service of protecting his rights and settling his disputes. And this raises an obvious problem, which is if I have a dispute with you and …