yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Is the Universe Discrete or Continuous?


2m read
·Nov 3, 2024

You said that we went from atoms in the time of Democritus down to nuclei, and from there to protons and neutrons, and then to quarks. It's particles all the way down. To paraphrase Feynman, we can keep going forever, but it's not quite forever. Right at some point, you run into the Planck length. There's the Planck time, there's the Planck length, there's even the Planck mass, which is actually quite a large mass.

These things don't have any physical significance. It's not like the Planck time is the shortest possible time, and it's not like the Planck length is the shortest possible length. The reason for that is because these Planck things are part of quantum theory, but length is not described by quantum theory. It's described by the general theory of relativity, and in that theory, space is infinitely divisible.

There is no smallest possible length or time. This illuminates an ancient tension between the discrete and the continuous because quantum theory seems to suggest that things are discrete. For example, there's a smallest possible particle of gold—the gold atom. There's a smallest possible particle of electricity—the electron. There's a smallest possible particle of light—the photon.

In quantum theory, we have this idea of discreteness—that there is a smallest possible thing from which everything else is built. But in general relativity, the idea is the opposite. It says things can continuously vary, and if the mathematics requires that things be continuously variable, so they can be differentiated and so on.

The idea there is that you can keep on dividing up space, and you can keep on dividing up time. So physicists understand that there is this contradiction at the deepest level of our most foundational explanations in physics. It's one of the reasons why there are these attempts to try and unify quantum theory and general relativity.

Because what is the fundamental nature of reality? Is it that things can be infinitely divisible? Or is it that we must stop somewhere or other? Because if it's infinitely divisible, then quantum theory might have to be subservient to general relativity. But we just don't know.

More Articles

View All
Wolves vs. Bison: On Location | Hostile Planet
The stars of “Hostile Planet” are obviously the animals. But the unsung heroes are the crew that work so hard to bring you that footage. [wolves howling] PETE MCGOWAN: So my name’s Pete McGowan. I’m here in the Canadian Arctic, trying to film wolves hun…
How can an atheist call Hitler evil?
Andrew made a video, uh, in which he asks the question to atheists, was Hitler evil? Um, I think the gist of his question is the idea—uh, the idea behind it is that, uh, because atheists don’t have a universal sense of right and wrong, can they condemn Hi…
Unchaining Captive Elephants in Nepal | National Geographic
I think the most memorable release that I was ever present at is when we put five elephants into a brand new 4-acre Corral. The elephants moved forward by a few feet, all tight together, with the babies underneath them. Then the babies started squealing, …
Introduction to sampling distributions
So let’s say I have a bag of colored balls here, and we know that 40 of the balls are orange. Now imagine defining a random variable X, and X is based on a trial where we stick our hand in this bag, we don’t look around, and we randomly pick a ball, look …
The Danger and Excitement of Underwater Cave Diving | Short Film Showcase
We come here every winter, bringing tons of dive stuff, going into the mountains. During this expedition, Darrell, we get to explore this cave system that we have found here. This is the longest underwater cave in Sweden, and we know there’s going to be s…
Beer Bath !!! -- Best Images of the Week, IMG! #30
The great monitor arc and an iPad typewriter. It’s episode 30 of IMG. Here’s the world’s largest Lego tower, and here’s an egg fried into a duck face. You know you’re patriotic when you resort to kittens, although I prefer driving a horse in my car. Oh ye…