yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Is Light a Particle or a Wave?


3m read
·Nov 3, 2024

There is a video on YouTube which has Deutsch explain the famous quantum double slit experiment, which is about particle-wave duality. Is light a particle, or a wave? You pass it through a slit depending on whether there's an observer and interference or not. It ends up in a wave pattern, ends up as individual photons, and this is the famous experiment which has baffled people for a long time and caused them to revise their world view.

The one that led Einstein to say, "God does not play dice with the universe." Correct, Einstein was a realist at the time when the founders of quantum theory were trying to develop a good explanation of what precisely was going on with these experiments in quantum theory. Einstein rejected all of them on the basis that they weren't realistic, and he was right to do so because none of them made any sense. To this day, none of the other alternatives make any sense.

Now, Einstein didn't know about the multiverse. We had to wait until Hugh Everett in the 1950s was able to devise a simple, realistic way of understanding quantum theory. But if I go back to this idea of the double slit experiment, it is often claimed that particles have a duality to them. Sometimes they're particles, and sometimes they're waves. The electron, for example, given certain experiments, will behave like a particle, and in other experiments, it behaves like a wave.

People who hear this think, "Well, okay, that kind of explains what's going on." For example, in the photoelectric effect, you shine a light at electrons, which literally means you're firing a photon, a particle of light, at an electron, and you can knock the electron out of the atom. This is supposed to be proof positive that light in the form of photons and electricity in the form of electrons are both particles because they're bouncing off one another, and this is what particles do.

Waves don't do that. You watch water waves at the beach; you'll see they pass through each other; they don't bounce off one another. Waves will bounce off particles, but they won't bounce off each other. Prior to Young's twin slit experiment, we actually relied upon Newton's ideas of light, and Newton's idea was that light was corpuscular, as he said, which means made of particles.

Then Young came along, and he shone a light through two slits cut into a piece of paper. What you find when you project that light onto another sheet of paper is not just two beams of light; you find what's called an interference pattern where the light has interfered with itself, in the same way that when waves pass through small apertures or natural geological gaps, they will interfere with one another. They produce crests in some places and troughs in others; they can cancel each other out. This was supposed to be proof to some of the early physicists that light, in fact, was a wave.

Now we get to quantum theory, and we find that things we thought were certainly particles, like electrons, when we do the same experiment with them, they interfere with one another. So it appears as though we've got particles acting like waves and waves acting like particles. The resolution to this is not to admit nonsense. This is what is often explained in quantum theory lectures at the undergraduate level: that you have to accept that something like a photon is born as a particle, it lives as a wave, and then it dies again as a particle, which is nonsense.

The reason it's nonsense is because the photon doesn't know that it's alive and it's dead. It doesn't know what experiment it's participating in.

More Articles

View All
The rise of industrial capitalism | AP US History | Khan Academy
[Instructor] The period from the end of the Civil War to the start of the 20th Century was one of incredible economic transformation in the United States. In 1865, the United States was the 4th largest industrial economy in the world. By the 1890s, it had…
The Rescue | Official Trailer | National Geographic Documentary Films
Breaking News. Right now, out of Thailand. Rescue teams are working through the night to save 12 boys and their coach, trapped inside a cave. The monsoon had come early. The conditions in the cave were impossible. There was a very strong feeling that the …
Khan Academy Ed Talk with Nicholas Ferroni
Hello and welcome to Ed Talks with Khan Academy! Thank you for joining us today. I’m Kristen Decervo, the Chief Learning Officer at Khan Academy, and I’m excited today to talk with Nick Ferroni, who’s going to talk about what it would look like if we real…
El Niño and La Niña| Earth systems and resources| AP Environmental science| Khan Academy
Every few years, you might hear about El Niño in the news, and this also might come with powerful images of flooding and rainfall. But El Niño is not just a storm; it’s actually a climate pattern that takes place in the Pacific Ocean, and we’ll get a litt…
15 Predictions for 2024
If you could see slightly into the future, what would you do with that information? Every successful person tries to peek into the future to figure out how to use it to their advantage. Those who are able to do it to see how the world will eventually look…
Ridiculously Easy DIY Light Strips! (no soldering)
I want to change my bathroom from this to this. The problem is I want it to not cost a lot, be high quality, and be easy. I mean, is that even possible? Well, after trying out many different options and almost failing multiple times, I finally found a gre…