yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Hey Bill Nye, 'Can We Desalinate Water for Human Consumption on a Massive Scale?' #TuesdaysWithBill


3m read
·Nov 4, 2024

Hey Bill. This is Amy from Minnesota. I was wondering if — when I was five years old, I did this science experiment where we stuck a stick in salt water, and it made a crystal. I was wondering if there was, in terms of desalinating water for human consumption, if there is a chemical compound that could work as a catalyst for some sort of reaction and if we could do this on a massive scale?

Amy, that is a fabulous question. Desalinization of water could be the key to the future for so many of us humans. I'm fascinated with this question. So you use the word catalyst; this would be a chemical that would enable another chemical reaction, and in general, it doesn't affect the catalyst, so you could reuse the catalyst.

Right now, as far as I know, there is no such thing. But two aspects of this are really important right now. The first one is not real, and I cannot help but hearken to a book by Kurt Vonnegut in which the characters create something called Ice-nine, where you get water molecules to rearrange themselves. And the chemist who does this is fascinated with the way cannonballs are stacked in statues or in memorials to people who fought wars with cannons. That's fictional, but it is kind of a cool idea. I won't tell you what happens at the end of the book; it's big fun.

The real thing that's going on right now is people are able to take the salt out of salt water by forcing the water backwards through a very fine filter, which generally is called a membrane, and right now we call it osmosis. And osmosis is an old Greek word that means it kind of happens on its own. And so the classic example is to take an egg, take the shell off with vinegar, and then put the membrane-contained egg in salt water, and the water will go into the egg, and the egg will swell if it's in salt water. If you put that same type of egg, a naked egg, in distilled water, the egg embryo is slightly salty, so the water will work its way out, and that egg will shrink.

Anyway, people have found ways to make synthetic membranes with things like Teflon and polyester and so on, and you can pump, force the salt water backwards through the membrane and leave the salt behind. And this is done all the time. It's done in Australia at several industrial scale citywide installations; San Diego, Carlsbad, California has one. And cruise ships and I guess the U.S. Navy exploit this technology all the time.

But Amy, people are trying this new material, which has come to become graphene. And it's just like graphite; it's just like the thing that makes coal black or pencil lead gray, except this material now is one molecular layer thick, and it has these amazing properties. It's fantastically strong when stretched longitudinally or in the same direction, in the plane of the graphene. It's crazy strong.

And so people believe that the slip length, as it's called, of the salt water is longer than the thickness of this one molecule or one atom thick graphene. So there's hardly any pressure needed to get the water to flow through the graphene, leaving the salt behind and having fresh water come out on the other side.

Now the key to any of these processes is you have to filter the water first to take out regular old particulates, regular old dust and sand, I exaggerate trash. You've got to take that out before you run it through your reverse osmosis membrane or this new being experimented with graphene.

But you are living at a time where this breakthrough may be made on an industrial scale. And if we can do that, Amy, it would change the world. We could have all the clean water we wanted for everybody all over the world, and we would power the pumps with solar power, regular old photovoltaic solar cells. And when the sun is not shining, you don't pump the water. So you pump the water when the sun is shining, and you fill up reservoirs all over the world.

And so humankind could, if this stuff works out, it could have access to clean water for the billions of us that need it. It's an exciting time, Amy. Go get them. Become a chemical engineer or material scientist and solve this problem.

More Articles

View All
Hunting for Emeralds | Mine Hunters
Next morning, the teams start early on their first day’s work at Player Verie. “Oh look, here’s all the Timbers!” First up, Fred and Zach do an inventory of equipment at the site. “Hey, what’s this? It’s a blower! We can use this to ventilate the mine, …
Ex Machina's Scientific Advisor - Murray Shanahan
So I think that I think the first question I wanted to ask you is like given the popularity of AI or at least the interest in AI right now, what was it like when you’re doing your PhD thesis in the 80s around AI? Yeah, well, very different. I mean, it is…
2015 AP Calculus BC 2c | AP Calculus BC solved exams | AP Calculus BC | Khan Academy
Part C: Find the time at which the speed of the particle is three. So let’s just remind ourselves what speed is. It’s the magnitude of velocity. If you have the x, actually let me draw it this way. If you have the x dimension of, or the x component of a …
Khan Stories: Shrey
It was amazing! I don’t think I’ll ever forget in my life. “Mom, I made it to Harvard!” I mean, it was like a Bollywood Hollywood kind of a sentence. I’m Srey. Um, I’m a freshman at Harvard, class of 2022, and I’m from New Delhi, India. I’ve been using …
Buoyancy Quiz
We are doing a buoyancy experiment today. If you drop a golf ball into some dishwashing liquid, it sinks very slowly. So why does it sink in the detergent? Because the golf ball is more heavy than the liquid that’s in the container— then the detergent. W…
Food Fight! The Big Genetically Modified Food Debate
Genetically modified foods are one of the most controversial concepts of today’s modern world. Genetically modified foods have had specific changes introduced into their DNA. Crops undergo this process to have desirable traits, like a brighter color, a sm…