yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Checks on the judicial branch | US government and civics | Khan Academy


2m read
·Nov 11, 2024

In other videos, we have talked about how the other branches of government can limit Supreme Court powers. We're going to continue that conversation in this video by discussing how the amendment process can also limit or overrule a Supreme Court decision.

So let's go to 1875. Just for some context, the 14th Amendment to the United States had already been ratified. In particular, you have the privileges or immunities clause of the 14th Amendment that says no state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States.

Well, you could imagine a lot of women at the time who were citizens of the United States said that, "Look, voting is a privilege of being a citizen, but I am not allowed to vote." And so you have Virginia Minor, who was a citizen in Missouri, decides to register to vote. She is denied and eventually takes the registrar to court. It eventually gets appealed all the way to the United States Supreme Court in Minor versus Happersett, where Happersett is the registrar in Missouri.

The Supreme Court in this case rules that voting is not a privilege of citizenship for women. It seems absurd to us right now that voting seems to be one of the main privileges of being a citizen, but that's the way the Supreme Court ruled in 1875.

Now, the folks who were fighting for a women's right to vote weren't just women; they were also men. Eventually, they started to have victories in the early 1900s at various states, especially states in the West, which started to allow women to vote.

But as we go into the teens of the 1900s, the movement gets enough steam to get Congress and the state legislators to propose and ratify the 19th Amendment, which says the right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of sex. Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.

So what we have here is the legislative branch—both the U.S. Congress and the state legislatures—because it needs to be voted for by two-thirds of both houses of Congress and then ratified by three-fourths of the states. They essentially overruled the Minor versus Happersett decision. They said, "All right, Supreme Court, you might see some ambiguity in the 14th Amendment."

Although today it's hard to say that voting isn't a privilege of citizenship, to make it very clear, they proposed and ratified the 19th Amendment.

So not only is this an interesting time in American history—not that long ago, less than a hundred years before this video that I'm making was made—women did not have the full right to vote in most of the United States. We eventually get the 19th Amendment, but above and beyond that, this is an example of how other branches of government can exercise some checks on the United States Supreme Court.

More Articles

View All
Batten Down | Life Below Zero
Like we’re stuck at home late. Red-flag! I know for three days I should go get firewood, and we should go get a couple days’ worth of something to eat here: caribou or a few ducks. The Hailstone family spends their summer living in Kowalik, away from the…
Vlog: The Ponzi Factor book update (Oct 2020)
Hello everyone, this is Ton again. I want to do a quick vlog about updates for the book. I know that a lot has happened this year, and I will address some of that in the update, but not everything because a lot of it’s still developing. But I do want you…
Space Probe Cemetery | Exomars: The Hunt For Life
The first successful Mars mission was in 1964. Along the way, Mars would become the space probe cemetery. Bogalusa, a lot of space probes have been lost along the way; some of them we lost track of upon their arrival. Others flew past the planet without s…
James Manyika on how the pandemic has accelerated the future of work | Homeroom with Sal
Hi everyone! Welcome to our daily homeroom. I’m very excited about the guest we have today. Before we jump into that conversation, I will give my standard announcement. I want to remind everyone that Khan Academy is a not-for-profit organization that can…
Gordon Ramsay Goes Cast Net Fishing in Laos | Gordon Ramsay: Uncharted
First of all, an absolute pleasure because you’ve helped put Lao cuisine on the map. I’m dying to get to understand Lao cuisine. Food not too sweet, but we use lots of stuff that we get from the forest or swimming river. We also use more herbs. Wow, that…
Can You Build a House With Hemp? | National Geographic
[Music] Some of the most practical uses of industrial hemp in the modern day, of course, are the same as they ever were: building materials, paper, textiles, seed oil, nutrition. Hempcrete, of all the 50,000 known products that we can make with industrial…