yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Vote or STFU?


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

Um, beware the lizards. Uh, your video urged people to vote or shut the up. It made sense if you were addressing only those who already see democracy as a positive thing, and of course, not everyone does. Um, if there are three people on an island, it doesn't strike me as legitimate that two of them get to command the third and threaten him with force if he disobeys.

And if this tiny island democracy is illegitimate, then it's not obvious what the ethically relevant difference is when considering, uh, a large modern democracy. Butler Shaer said when we vote in an election, we are declaring by our actions our support for the process of some people ruling others by coercive means. You talked about casting a vote to try to keep the worst guys out of power, like the BNP, and I can understand that there's a practical value to strategic voting.

But at the moment you oppose majoritarianism, the, uh, the calculation concerning whether or not to vote against the BNP becomes more complicated. On the one hand, your vote reduces the risk that a party of racists gets into power by some small amount. On the other hand, by voting, even if your vote is a spoiled one, uh, you are seen to be consenting to and thereby lending support to, uh, a system that you think is unjust.

The possible pragmatic benefits of voting then, uh, balanced against the prospect of acting in opposition to your ethical principles. I think that can be a difficult choice to make. Added to this, there's the extra complicating factor that politicians frequently lie or change their minds once in power, so the already flimsy causal link between your vote and the actual condition in the place you live becomes even more threadbare.

I don't support the process of some people ruling others by coercive means. It doesn't matter whether the rulers have the support of the majority or not. But your video tells me that by not participating in democracy, I have to shut the up.

On the hypothetical desert island, a vote is taken about whether to seize Bob's possessions and redistribute them among the other two Islanders. Bob doesn't vote because he thinks the whole idea is absurd. The votes are cast, and Bob's things get stolen. If the vote or shut the up logic makes sense, then Bob shouldn't vocally oppose the injustice of what just happened because he didn't participate in the contest to wield the coercive power of the state. I hope you don't really believe that.

More Articles

View All
Why Charlie Munger Continues to Buy Alibaba Stock
The Daily Journal recently bought a large position in Alibaba after founder Jack Ma had been reprimanded by the Chinese Communist Party, and Ma’s other company, Ant, was not allowed to proceed with its IPO. What are your current thoughts on China and whet…
Hiking Table Mountain, Alberta - 360 | National Geographic
Table Mountain gets its name from this really cool large flat tablelike plateau which exists just below the summit. When I’m setting out on a trail, I’m always really excited to see what I’ll discover along the way. I’m looking out for small details that…
Don't Worry, Everything is Out of Control | Stoic Antidotes to Worry
Even though we can’t control the future, we’re worrying ourselves sick because of it. This could be because we don’t control the future. And this lack of control is the reason it frightens us. Or, we think we can control it by ‘thinking about it’ or perha…
Differentiating rational functions | Derivative rules | AP Calculus AB | Khan Academy
Let’s say that Y is equal to five minus three X over x squared plus three X, and we want to figure out what is the derivative of Y with respect to X. Now, it might immediately jump out at you that look-look, Y is being defined as a rational expression her…
What Is the 'Gray Zone' Border Between the U.S. and Canada? | National Geographic
The United States and Canada share the longest undefended border in the world. Most of the time, it’s as peaceful as it sounds, but not always. Since the 1700s, a tiny turf war has been smoldering between the two countries. The grand prize: an uninhabited…
Dogs: (Prehistoric) Man's Best Friend | National Geographic
There are more dog burials in prehistory than there are burials of any other animals, including cats, for example, or horses. Dogs seem to have a very special place in human communities in the past. As soon as we see in the archaeological record skeletal …