yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Perverted Analogy Fallacy: look out for it.


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

So a person might make a claim like, "Uh, taxation is just because those being taxed have given, uh, implicit consent by continuing to live in a territory which is subject to the tax."

Um, and you'd like to get them to examine whether or not this idea of implicit consent really holds water.

And so you might ask them, "So, if I'm living in a village and the mafia come in and demand that I pay them, uh, protection money, uh, is that demand justified? Is the implicit consent I'm apparently granting by not leaving the territory, uh, in play here too? And if not, why not?"

Um, so I think it's obvious then that this kind of reply is, uh, designed to, uh, invite examination of the validity of, um, the notion of implicit consent in this case.

Um, but what might happen is that the reply that follows, um, sounds something like, um, something like this: "That's ridiculous! It's a completely fake analogy or false analogy to compare a de a democratically elected government to the mafia. Uh, they're two worlds apart."

So, did you see what, uh, what happened there?

Um, person A makes an analogy that's relevant to the subject in a limited way, like the scope of the analogy is limited, uh. But person B then complains that the analogy is not, uh, perfectly equivalent to, to the subject being discussed.

So I've come across this quite often in online discussions, and I've come across it often enough to think that this must be a fallacy that has earned, um, its own name.

In the end, I found a blog, uh, which I'll link to in the sidebar, uh, which dubs this, uh, this problem as the perverted analogy fallacy.

The perverted analogy fallacy is a form of, uh, straw man. Your opponent misconstrues your analogy as being far broader in scope than was intended, and the result is often that the person committing the fallacy avoids having to address, uh, the implications of the analogy or what the analogy demonstrates.

In the example I've used in this video, the analogy demonstrates that if we deny the legitimacy of a mafia extracting protection money, then we also deny, in fact, the legitimacy of the idea of the implicit contract as consented to by a person's continued, uh, residence in a particular territory.

So the name is the perverted analogy fallacy, and it might be useful to, uh, to keep that term in mind because it's a, a handy way to cut short these tiresome distractions, basically.

More Articles

View All
Bill Belichick & Ray Dalio on Bill's Most Important Principles: Part 2
Yeah, and that’s that. Of course, it is harder to do in today’s society with social media, and so there’s a lot of feedback from social media. People who don’t know the players, the team, have an opinion—like, dislike, whatever it is—but they don’t reall…
Voltage divider | Circuit analysis | Electrical engineering | Khan Academy
Now I’m going to show you a circuit that’s called a voltage divider. This is a name we give to a simple circuit of two series resistors. So I’m just going to draw two series resistors here, and it’s a nickname in the sense of it’s just a pattern that we s…
The First Militaristic Drug Cartel | Narco Wars
My name is Arturo Fontes. I was an FBI agent for approximately 28 years. People laugh at me because I left sunny San Diego with beaches and everything, and a nice big house to be in a small town, in Laredo. They call it “the armpit” of Texas. [honking] It…
The Stock Market Is Broken
What’s up, you guys? It’s Graham here. So, we got to take a moment and talk about something serious—something that no investor wants to think about, something that’s happened in the past but many people feel is going to happen again in the future. And no,…
Definite integral of radical function | AP Calculus AB | Khan Academy
So we want to evaluate the definite integral from -1 to 8 of 12 * the cube root of x dx. Let’s see, this is going to be the same thing as the definite integral from -1 to 8 of 12 * the cube root is the same thing as saying x to the 1⁄3 power dx. And so n…
The Future of Cyberwarfare | Origins: The Journey of Humankind
NARRATOR: September 11, 2001, terror strikes set the tone for warfare in the 21st century. But the 21st century has also seen the rise of another kind of warfare— warfare that lets nations and loners do battle without guns or bombs. These days, the bigges…