How can an atheist call Hitler evil?

2m read

·Nov 8, 2024

Andrew made a video, uh, in which he asks the question to atheists, was Hitler evil? Um, I think the gist of his question is the idea—uh, the idea behind it is that, uh, because atheists don't have a universal sense of right and wrong, can they condemn Hitler?

And, uh, the main thing to mention here is that atheism doesn't imply moral relativism. Atheists can and do believe that actions can be objectively right or wrong. So, the question was: was Hitler evil? Um, for me, the answer depends on the sense in which you're using the word evil.

Um, if a person who carries out morally wrong actions is evil, then yes, I think Hitler was evil. Uh, but on the other hand, if you're asking whether Hitler was under the influence of some false nature, uh, that gives rise to wickedness and sin, uh, then I don't think Hitler was evil and I don't think anyone else is.

Um, so you say atheists do not have a concept of good and evil; they do not believe in a universal concept of right and wrong? Um, that's not necessarily true. Um, so here are some ethical frameworks: utilitarianism, ideal observer theory, uh, egoism.

So, subscribers to these frameworks don't believe in gods, but they do believe that a particular action can be objectively right or wrong. So, the actions of Hitler, uh, would be condemned by subscribers to each of these theories.

Uh, there are some differences in—well, there are differences in, uh, the way subscribers to these theories would reach the conclusion that Hitler's actions were wrong, but they would all conclude that they were, in fact, wrong.

Um, I hope that answers your question. [Music]

Time: The History & Future of Everything – Remastered

Valuation Modeling: Excel as a tool

View All

What Happens After You Uncover Buried History? | Podcast | Overheard at National Geographic

Foreign. They say our people were born on the water, like nothing had existed before. We were told by virtue of our bondage we could never be American, but it was by virtue of our bondage that we became the most American of all. That’s a clip from a docum…

How adding your phone number and 2-factor authentication helps protect your account

All right, Guemmy, so sometimes sites ask for, like, a phone number for security purposes, and I’m always actually afraid to give my phone number. One, I just don’t want random people calling me all the time. But how do you think about that? When is it va…

Calculating a z statistic in a test about a proportion | AP Statistics | Khan Academy

The mayor of a town saw an article that claimed the national unemployment rate is eight percent. They wondered if this held true in their own town, so they took a sample of 200 residents to test the null hypothesis. The null hypothesis is that the unemplo…

Remy’s Paris | Epcot Becoming Episode 2 | National Geographic

The projects that we design, we build in steel and concrete. They’re going to be there a while. So, we do our homework. World Showcase has always been a reflection of the real countries around the world. A celebration of the architecture, of the music, of…

Pronoun number | The parts of speech | Grammar | Khan Academy

So here’s something weird and cool about English and languages in general: they have a sense of number kind of encoded into them. We call this grammatical number. The way this plays out is in the difference between singular and plural in English; the idea…

Ride Along With a Team of Lion Protectors | Expedition Raw

Right now, we’re looking for a group of lions that we heard were in the area. When we locate them, we want to pass this information on to the lion anti-snaring team so that they can come to the area, check it for snares, and prevent any lions from getting…

How can an atheist call Hitler evil?

More Articles