yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

How can an atheist call Hitler evil?


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

Andrew made a video, uh, in which he asks the question to atheists, was Hitler evil? Um, I think the gist of his question is the idea—uh, the idea behind it is that, uh, because atheists don't have a universal sense of right and wrong, can they condemn Hitler?

And, uh, the main thing to mention here is that atheism doesn't imply moral relativism. Atheists can and do believe that actions can be objectively right or wrong. So, the question was: was Hitler evil? Um, for me, the answer depends on the sense in which you're using the word evil.

Um, if a person who carries out morally wrong actions is evil, then yes, I think Hitler was evil. Uh, but on the other hand, if you're asking whether Hitler was under the influence of some false nature, uh, that gives rise to wickedness and sin, uh, then I don't think Hitler was evil and I don't think anyone else is.

Um, so you say atheists do not have a concept of good and evil; they do not believe in a universal concept of right and wrong? Um, that's not necessarily true. Um, so here are some ethical frameworks: utilitarianism, ideal observer theory, uh, egoism.

So, subscribers to these frameworks don't believe in gods, but they do believe that a particular action can be objectively right or wrong. So, the actions of Hitler, uh, would be condemned by subscribers to each of these theories.

Uh, there are some differences in—well, there are differences in, uh, the way subscribers to these theories would reach the conclusion that Hitler's actions were wrong, but they would all conclude that they were, in fact, wrong.

Um, I hope that answers your question. [Music]

More Articles

View All
Can We Use Bacteria to Treat Diseases? | Nat Geo Live
( Intro music ) My laboratory gets in and explores, and we really explore a world that’s invisible to the naked eye. And so, if we take a look at these scanning electron microscopy images, you’ll get a closer view. So, we are looking in now, at over 3000…
Howard Marks: The BIGGEST Investment Opportunity in 40 Years
53 years in your investing career, there have been three sea changes, and we are in one of them. What does that mean? Howard Marks, he is a billionaire and one of the most highly respected investors in the world. Marks has been investing for over 50 years…
My Life As an Adventure Filmmaker and Photographer (Part 2) | Nat Geo Live
Like any budding photographer, you know I was, of course, I got National Geographic magazine. That’s sort of the standard in photography. I remember when this issue came in the mail; it was called “Storming the Tower.” I read the story, and it was about f…
Aliens Would Visit for Knowledge, Not Resources
I think Stephen Hawking himself said that it was a mistake to broadcast radio waves out into the universe because the aliens are going to be out there, and they’re going to be like conquistadors, and they’re going to want to take over our planet for their…
Watch: Inside the World's Longest Sea Caves | Expedition Raw
Okay, let’s go for it. I actually went to New Zealand to study the other side of the island. But to satisfy my curiosity, I started exploring this coastline, and that turned out to be the day that I actually discovered the longest sea cave in the world. …
20 Questions with Neil deGrasse Tyson | StarTalk
[Music] I think I’d be a condor definitely. Pie, uh, with ice cream definitely! Beach, Ocean Beach, I I’d have to take both, both at their best. There’s nothing like it; picking one or the other is like picking one of your children. Son, my gosh, what kin…