yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Chris Dixon at Startup School 2013


3m read
·Nov 3, 2024

Processing might take a few minutes. Refresh later.

So today I'm going to talk about good ideas that look like bad ideas.

There's a great, my clicker is not working, sorry, technical problems there. Okay, thanks, oops. So there's a great PG blog post where he talks about Peter Thiel came to talk and said basically there's two kinds of ideas: the, sorry, that there are good ideas and there are things that seem like bad ideas. Most startups are in the sweet spot in the middle, which are good ideas that seem like bad ideas.

So today I'm going to basically expound on this idea a little bit. So why good ideas look like bad ideas? The kind of intuition is that good ideas that look like good ideas are already being worked on by, you know, academics, governments, and most of all, kind of large companies.

So for example, I, you know, I want a smartphone that has 10x the battery life and a better screen and more apps and everything else. And Apple and Samsung and everyone else are hard at work on that. So sort of by definition, you know, we investors and entrepreneurs are kind of in the business of the leftovers, or the things that everyone else thinks are bad ideas. But we think our, you know, we discover are actually good ideas.

And I'm gonna give somebody, start with some sort of high-profile historical example. So it's hard to to sort of imagine this now, but back in, I think it was '98, when Google first launched, they were actually very late to the search engine world. At the time, the search was dominated by large portals like Yahoo and Lycos and Excite. And they actually thought of search as kind of a lost leader; their real business was being a portal and putting display ads everywhere.

In fact, if you go back and look at all of the literature at the time, people, the sort of the, you know, the press reports and things like this, everyone was talking about stickiness. Stickiness was kind of the key, and it was like, sort of today would be like morality or whatever, some of the sort of things everyone's trying to have.

You wanted stickiness, maybe people stuck on your website so that you could show them more ads. Google was the opposite of it. It was so incredibly good at finding the right search results that people would immediately leave the website. In fact, there's a famous anecdote where the Google guys were trying to, when they first started off, trying to sell their technology for like a million dollars to one of the large portals.

And the CEO of a large portal tried it out; he's like, "This works too well. The problem is people are gonna leave my site. Can you make it work less well and like actually give me bad results?" It's a true story.

And so the point is that Google came in—I mean, obviously Google had an amazing technology—but in some ways their insight was actually this very contrary business idea of getting people off the website and that no one had any idea how they'd make money.

I know one VC who went to visit the house of the Google founders—they were staying there working at, they were working in the garage—and actually snuck out the back so he wouldn't have to meet somebody who's working on a search engine because it seemed like such an obviously bad idea.

Another good example here is Airbnb, which, you know, we all know now is one of the great successes of our sort of the modern startup era. And of course, came from YC. Airbnb, when it first started off, seemed to most people like this kind of weird niche, you know, kind of hipster activity, something that maybe see them like the mission or, you know, Brooklyn or something like this.

You know, like who's gonna stay on someone else's couch? You know, you know, and lots of great people, investors who've, you know, and sort of industry observers who've been very smart about things all thought this is sort of this weird niche behavior.

And, you know, it's jury still out, but it seems as if it's on its way to being kind of almost a replacement to the hotel industry. eBay is another one, which maybe this crowd is a little bit going back in time. But it's sort of hard to imagine now, but when eBay first came out, the, you know, this the Internet had just started. It just...

More Articles

View All
Influence of political events on ideology | AP US Government & Politics | Khan Academy
In discussing political socialization, we’ve talked a lot about factors that go into how people develop their opinions on government and politics. Your family, your friends, your demographic characteristics like your race or gender, they all contribute to…
Dangling modifiers | Syntax | Khan Academy
Hello Garans, hello Rosie, hi Paige. So in this video, we’re going to talk about something called a dangling modifier. So before we get into what a dangling modifier is, we can sort of talk about just what a modifier is. Rosie, do you want to tell us wha…
The Poverty of Compromise
This idea of questioning things that he, the two you thought were unassailable in a particular domain, for millennia people were wondering about the best way to conceive of what democracy is. Even Plato had this idea of what is democracy, and he had the …
Why I built a private jet in my showroom!
14 years ago, I had to come up with the idea of how to build the best showroom in the world. But the biggest issue was, what the hell do I put inside the window of this showroom? So, I came up with the idea: first of all, how do I get an eye-catching gian…
How One Orphaned Gorilla Inspired Her to Save Hundreds More | National Geographic
Hunters are going in and killing large family groups. The young orphans are left because they’re too small to be sold as meat. So I’d only been here a month, and I was given the opportunity to look after an infant gorilla. The reason my whole life turned …
The Second Great Awakening - part 1
The Second Great Awakening was one of the most important social, religious, and cultural aspects of the early 19th century in the United States. In fact, I might even make the argument that it’s impossible to understand the early 19th century without unde…