yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

No Truth Can Be Justified


2m read
·Nov 3, 2024

The initial guesses at what knowledge was all about amounted to what is known as the justified true belief vision of knowledge, and it's still the most prevalent idea today. Anyone who calls themselves a Bayesian is a justified true believer, and that's the misconception that knowledge is about trying to justify as true your beliefs. And if you've done so, then you can say, "I know that thing."

So if I can justify as true my theory of gravity, then I should believe that theory of gravity, and only then can I say that it's known. The problem with this is that there is no method of showing as true any piece of knowledge.

So the improvement Deutsch promotes in his books is this vision that Popper gave us, that all we have are guesses about reality, conjectures. People think, "Oh, that sounds a bit wishy-washy; it's just a guess." Well, it's not a random guess. It's not just anyone decides to have a guess and therefore that stands on equal footing to every other.

No, it's a guess that has stood up against trials, against attempts to show that it's false. And when people are unable to show that it's false via this method of refutation, then we accept it as a piece of knowledge. This allows us to thereby accept the fact that we're going to be able to make progress in the future because all of our knowledge is conjectural.

All of it is our best guess at the time, and therefore there's this elasticity within the knowledge that allows us to say there's going to be errors. We're going to correct them and thereby be able to make progress off into the infinite future.

This is unlike the previous conception of knowledge which says once you've justified something as true, well, it's true. If it's true, that means there is nothing false about it, and therefore it can't possibly be refuted. It's a very religious notion.

The modern incantation of this is Bayesianism. Bayesianism says you have a theory, you collect more evidence, and you become more and more confident over time that your theory is correct. And it gets a little bit worse than that because then it says this Bayesian reasoning enables you to generate new theories, which you can't.

The best that it can hope to do is to show you that you are more confident in this theory than what you are in that theory. The Popperian view says if you can show that there's a flaw in a particular theory, you can discard that theory.

More Articles

View All
Don't Worry, Everything is Out of Control | Stoic Antidotes to Worry
Even though we can’t control the future, we’re worrying ourselves sick because of it. This could be because we don’t control the future. And this lack of control is the reason it frightens us. Or, we think we can control it by ‘thinking about it’ or perha…
2015 AP Chemistry free response 7 | Thermodynamics | Chemistry | Khan Academy
Aluminum metal can be recycled from scrap metal by melting the metal to evaporate impurities. Calculate the amount of heat needed to purify one mole of aluminum originally at 298 Kelvin by melting it. The melting point of aluminum is 933 Kelvin. The molar…
Dealing cards with functions | Intro to CS - Python | Khan Academy
Let’s design a program with functions and nested function calls. We want to build a program that lets the user play several different car games. That means every game is going to need to share functionality for dealing a deck of playing cards. The first …
Warren Buffett: Read These 10 Books if You Want to be Rich
I read every book in the Omaha Public Library in business by the time I was 11. We moved back here, and as soon as I got back here and my dad was in Congress, I said, “Get everything in the Library of Congress. I want to read it!” But I still spend five o…
TAOISM | How to Get Drunk on Life
The habit of drinking is deeply ingrained in Western culture. Being drunk is often seen as a blissful state in which our sorrows are washed away, and exchanged for courage and an extraordinary ability to be merry and happy. Yes, alcohol loosens the inhibi…
The Ancient City That Mastered Water
It’s a cold, rainy night in the walled city of Cordoba, medieval Spain. Watchmen guard the city, unaware that an entire army of Christian soldiers are about to launch a surprise attack. In a single night, they conquer the entire city, bringing the Muslim …