yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Can causality be established from this study? | Study design | AP Statistics | Khan Academy


3m read
·Nov 11, 2024

A gym that specializes in weight loss offers its members an optional dietary program for an extra fee. To study the effectiveness of the dietary program, a manager at the gym takes a random sample of 50 members who participate in the dietary program and 50 members who don't. The manager finds that those who participated in the dietary program, on average, lost significantly more weight than those who didn't participate in the program in the past three months. The manager concludes that the dietary program caused the increased weight loss for the gym's members during that time period.

So pause this video and see and think about whether you think the manager is making a valid conclusion based on this study. All right, so let's first just make sure we understand what the manager is concluding. The manager is saying that there's a causal relationship between the dietary program; that being on the dietary program causes increased weight loss. They would be able to make this conclusion if it's a well-designed experimental study.

You might say, "Well, what does an experimental study look like?" Well, in an experimental study, you have a control group that wouldn't have the dietary program, and then you would have a treatment or experimental group that does have the dietary program. Then you would see, "Hey, if these folks are actually seeing more weight loss, and if it's statistically significant, then maybe you can conclude the causal relationship that the dietary program is causing the weight loss."

This kind of looks like that until you think about how folks were assigned to either of these groups. It would be a well-designed experimental study if you took random samples from the broader population. So, you took a random sample from the broader population, and then from this group, you randomly assign folks to either the control or the treatment.

So you're randomly assigning, and then the people who happened to be in the treatment group—not the people who chose to be in it—well, those people you'd say, "You need to be on this diet," and you make sure that they are on that diet. If you see a statistically significant increased weight loss, then you might be able to make this conclusion. But that's not what happened over here.

In this situation, we didn't randomly select from the broader population and then randomly assign folks to these groups. What happened is people self-selected into either being in the dietary program or not being in the dietary program—I'll say not the dietary program. Then what they did is that they randomly sampled from the dietary program to put them in, I guess you could say, the treatment group, and then they randomly sampled from this control group.

So in this situation, you have a significant confounding variable. People essentially self-selected themselves into the dietary program group, and that you could view as a confounding variable. It doesn't allow you to make this causal connection because people who selected themselves into the dietary program maybe are more motivated to lose weight. Maybe they could afford the money, and that wealth association is associated with being able to eat better and maybe being able to lose more weight.

Now a conclusion that the manager might be able to make based on this study is that there is an association between participating in the dietary program and weight loss. But once again, you can't establish the causality.

More Articles

View All
Worked example: Calculating the amount of product formed from a limiting reactant | Khan Academy
So right here we have a reaction where you can take some carbon monoxide gas and some hydrogen gas, and when they react, you’re going to produce methanol. This is actually pretty interesting; methanol has many applications. One of them, it’s actually race…
Play in a City That Is Both Urban and Wild | National Geographic
[Music] Even the oldest of places can be seen through new eyes. Quebec City brings to mind European vibe, history, and old architecture. This city is all about 400 years old, actually. So just wandering each neighborhood is an experience in itself. After…
See How Life Has Changed in the Middle East Over 58 Years | Short Film Showcase
That’s right across the Lebanese Syrian border. I stopped, pulled out my camera because I had resolved that the entire time I was in the Middle East, that I was going to keep a detailed photographic record of all my landscapes and have a real collection o…
Warren Buffett: How Long Can This Stock Bubble Last? (2021)
It’s no secret that stock prices have continued to hit all-time highs. All three major American stock market indices, the S&P 500, the Dow Jones Industrial Average, and the Nasdaq, all are at record highs. That has led to some very prominent and highl…
15 Ways to Stop Procrastinating
Procrastination is a common habit, right? And many of us find ourselves struggling with this tendency to postpone what needs to be done, whether it’s a task from work, doing your laundry, that pan that needs to be washed, or a blanket you have to move fro…
Photographing the Beauty of Life in the Shadow of War | Nat Geo Live
I was working in New York City as a photo editor sitting at my computer all day looking at stories coming in. And I always dreamed of becoming a foreign correspondent. And I got the courage to quit my job and move to the Czech Republic, where I got a job …