yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Bandit bakers and the social contract


3m read
·Nov 8, 2024

A YouTube user made a two-part video in which he gave replies to claims that he associates with libertarianism. I was quickly asked to give a response. I'm busy working on the follow-up to George Ought to Help at the moment, so I'm gonna keep this brief and I'll only address what I think was his strongest argument, his strongest claim.

He tries to defend the idea of the social contract and he's talking about explicit contracts. So he has in mind the contracts where a person signs. They signed this contract at some point in their life, and the contract includes clauses that say the person will abide by the laws of the government. The position of this YouTube user was that taxation, for instance, is made legitimate when an explicit contract of this kind is signed. Although I don't believe that such contracts are legitimate, in this video I'm gonna argue a more modest position or a weak claim: that the existence of a contract signed by a person is not necessarily binding on them.

If I'm successful in doing that, then the validity of the social contract that this YouTube user assumes to exist needs to be established. So here's a hypothetical. Imagine that together with a group of bandits, I invade a remote settlement. When I get there, I kill all the bakers, and then I set up my own bakery. I make it known that anyone who dares to make bread on their own will be killed. Next, I offer the surviving residents a deal. If they sign a contract stating that they will obey any of my commands, I will agree to sell bread to them. Included in the contract is a clause that says the resident can opt to leave the settlement at any time, which absolves them from having to follow my commands.

So one day, I issue the command that all residents who sign the contract must build a temple in my honor. Does the existence of the contract mean that my command is legitimate and must be obeyed by all those wishing to stay? I don't think so. In the hypothetical situation, I was using aggression to limit the choices of the people I was offering my deal to. In other words, my aggression had put the people who signed it under duress, and in my view, the contracts that were signed under this situation are void.

They are not binding. The way a state behaves and this gang of bandits in the thought experiment, both entities used threats of violence to prevent people from producing certain goods and services. They then established themselves as monopolists regarding providing these things. They then offer people a deal: abide by our rules and enjoy our goods and services, or leave.

So I hope you agree that the bread contracts offered by the bandits do not represent legitimate and binding agreements. This means that the background presence of aggression by one of the parties to a contract is important in determining whether the contract is valid. The presence of aggression can mean that such an agreement isn't binding.

I've shown how the state behaves in an analogous way to the bandits with regards to the use of threats of force to maintain a monopoly position. It remains to be demonstrated how the social contract between states and its subjects is meaningfully ethically distinct from the bandits' bread contracts. While this hasn't been established, the case for a social contract isn't persuasive.

More Articles

View All
An Infinite Dilemma of Bliss and Suffering
Imagine a universe filled with an infinite number of immortal people living in Bliss. They love it; it is awesome. But each day, one of them is removed and sent away to a separate Universe of suffering forever. Now, imagine a different Universe filled wi…
Introduction to residuals and least squares regression
So I’m interested in finding the relationship between people’s height in inches and their weight in pounds. I’m randomly sampling a bunch of people, measuring their height, measuring their weight, and then for each person, I’m plotting a point that repres…
Clearing the Yard | Life Below Zero
Jesse Holmes devotes all of his time, money, and resources to his team of sled dogs. Winner racing season will begin soon, and getting his dog lot in working order is a priority. This is going to be one clean open area with everything in rows. It’s time t…
Enzyme reaction velocity and pH | Cellular energetics | AP Biology | Khan Academy
In this video, we’re going to talk about enzymes. In particular, we’re going to talk about the effect of pH on enzymes—how acidic or basic the environment is and how that affects enzyme activity. So just as a bit of review, enzymes are molecules that hel…
Are Real Estate Prices about to Collapse?
What’s up guys, it’s Graham here. So for anyone who’s seen my previous videos, you know there’s very few things I love more than iced coffee, homemade avocado toast, and telling everyone to smash that like button if you haven’t done that already for the Y…
Andding decimals with hundredths
Let’s get some practice adding numbers that involve hundreds. So, pause this video and see if you can add these two numbers. See what you get. Alright, now let’s work through this together. Now, there’s many different ways to add decimals, and you’ll lea…