yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Moral realism doesn't help you (much)


3m read
·Nov 8, 2024

Moral nihilism, uh, the belief that moral facts don't exist, or at least that's how I'm going to define it here. Lord Hawkeye gives the impression that he does believe the moral facts exist. I'm not certain that he really does. A couple of his remarks about the utility or merits of morality have me wondering whether he's actually a moral realist or not. But I'm going to operate on the assumption that he really believes that moral facts exist, for now at least.

Here's my understanding of what Lord Hawkeye said in, uh, over the course of a couple of recent videos. I think this is his position. He believes that when moral nihilists argue against him about the existence of moral facts, there's something inconsistent about them doing so. On his view, moral nihilism holds that there's no such thing as objectively preferable human behavior or human beliefs. And this being the case, the nihilist has no grounds from which to oppose Hawkeye's mistaken belief that moral facts do exist. Uh, why should they care? Why should the nihilist care?

So, the mistake I believe Hawkeye is making is that he's neglecting the role of subjective value or of subjective preferences. He's right that moral nihilists can't appeal to objectively preferable behavior or beliefs; there's no such thing. But moral nihilists can be and are motivated by their subjective values. For instance, I value truth. I enjoy the challenge of persuading others about what I take to be the truth. I value the way that my own knowledge increases through these efforts and that my own false beliefs are highlighted and can be discarded. This, on its own, is reason enough to try to correct you about your mistaken view—uh, mistaken in my opinion, of course—about the existence of moral facts.

But there are plenty of other reasons I'd be interested in trying to correct your error, as well as valuing the truth. Uh, valuing truth, personally, I believe that you also value truth. Okay, if I can provide you with what you value while pursuing my own project towards knowledge, then that's a bonus because I value helping people out. So, I hope you can see how no assumption of moral facts, uh, or of universally preferable human behavior or beliefs, uh, is necessary for me to have reason to try to convince you that you're mistaken about the existence of moral facts. There's no inconsistency in me trying to do so.

Moral realism, I think, seems to promise a firm ground for moral feelings. In a way, this does provide one thing that moral nihilism doesn't. I suppose it can be a comfort to believe that your opinions reflect universal truths. But when it comes to persuading others or challenging behavior that you don't like, moral realism is useless. When we discuss moral questions, the best we can do in any situation is try to demonstrate that our intelligence's position on the situation in question is not consistent with some more foundational moral stance that they have.

For instance, doing x may be in conflict with a person's preference to minimize suffering. Notice that it's not necessary to assume that moral facts exist in order to have a discussion of this sort. That assumption doesn't strengthen our position in the slightest. So, uh, to summarize: moral facts, there's no good reason to suppose they exist. And while it can be comforting for some to believe that they do, uh, moral realism doesn't help you persuade people whose behavior you'd like to change.

More Articles

View All
Daily Homeroom: Congratulations Class of 2020!
Hi everyone! Welcome to Khan Academy’s daily homeroom live stream. For those of you all who do not know what this is, this is something that we thought of when we started seeing mass school closures. We know that people are going to be at home, socially d…
Example diving a unit fraction by a whole number
So let’s see if we can figure out what one-third divided by five is. And I’ll give you a hint: try to draw out one-third of a whole and then divide it into five equal sections. Pause this video and try to do that. All right, now let’s try to work through…
How To Use The 2023 Market Crash To Get Rich
What’s up guys? It’s Graham here. So today, we have to answer the age-old question that philosophers and economists have pondered since the beginning of time, and that would be: Am I wearing pants? And the answer is no. Just kidding! Instead, it’s whether…
This Duck Has a Foot Growing On Its Head - Smarter Every Day 25
Hey, it’s me Destin. This week I’ve been in the lab, or my garage, working on my thesis. So, I’m trying to finish it, so I can’t give you an awesome video this week. To hold you over, I’ll give you some video of when me and my daughter went to the fair an…
What Can We Learn From History? - Little Kids, Big Questions | America Inside Out
It is important to learn the history of the United States because you can learn new things about what happened then and how it is now, and how you can change the world. We learn about history so we do not repeat the mistakes that people have made in histo…
I read 100 Philosophical Books. Here's the best one.
I remember feeling completely aimless in high school. None of my classes felt particularly meaningful to me. I would sit in class, stare straight ahead, and my mind would often just wander. At home, I would try to avoid thinking too much by playing video …