yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Why policy decisions may not reflect perceived public opinion


3m read
·Nov 11, 2024

What we're going to do in this video is describe how our perceptions of public opinion may or may not affect policy decisions. So, what I have here is an excerpt from an article on Politico that was published at the end of February, shortly after the shootings in Florida.

It says support for stricter gun laws has spiked in polls conducted after the fatal South Florida school shooting, hitting its highest level in at least a quarter century. Roughly two in three Americans now say gun control laws should be made more strict in the wake of the murder of 17 people at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School, according to a number of polls, including a new Politico Morning Consult poll that shows support for stricter gun laws among registered voters at 68 percent, compared with just 25 percent who oppose stricter gun laws.

So, if there was just a direct connection between what we're seeing in the polls and policy, well, then you might expect stricter gun laws. You could imagine there are many policymakers who are already in support of stricter gun laws who would use this data to further their argument why, say, Congress should pass more legislation to make stricter gun laws.

But an interesting question is why this still might be an uphill battle in terms of making stricter gun laws. Well, you could imagine there are other policymakers, members of Congress, who—one, they may or may not trust the poll data here; maybe they don't view it as a truly representative sample. Others might say, "Hey, this is a temporary trend that's driven by the graphic nature of the news surrounding these polls." Others might say, "Hey, look, this might be the national numbers. I believe this poll, and it might not even be a temporary trend." But they say this is representative of the entire country; the polling numbers in my district might be different.

Now, another reason why a policymaker, despite this type of national poll, may not want to vote in favor of stricter gun laws is that their political calculus might not favor it. For example, even if their constituents support stricter gun laws, most of their constituents might not be so activated about that. They might care more about things like the economy, and they might have a smaller subset, say the 25 percent who oppose stricter gun laws, who are willing to vote on that issue. It might do more harm to your political chances to upset that group on this issue than to try to appeal to the majority on the issue.

And the last reason why a policymaker may not be in support of it, even though public opinion seems to be, is that they view the issue as being more subtle and more nuanced than maybe they think that the broader public might appreciate. That yes, when you see something horrific like this, you want to regulate it more; you want to pass laws. But there could be policymakers who believe that those laws won't be effective or they might not have the intended consequences.

But it's an interesting question when public opinion affects policy decisions and when it doesn't.

More Articles

View All
Ichthyosaurs 101 | National Geographic
[Narrator] While dinosaurs roamed the Earth and pterosaurs ruled the sky, sea monsters called ichthyosaurs dominated the world’s oceans. Ichthyosaurs were ancient reptilian predators. They first appeared about 251 million years ago during the Triassic Per…
The Origins of Disgust
Being impressed by the cognitive abilities of a chimpanzee isn’t just good for them; it is good for us, because it helps us learn about our own evolutionary history. Comparing the psychology of humans to the psychology of other primates is a great way to …
Slope from equation | Mathematics I | High School Math | Khan Academy
We’ve got the equation ( y + 2 = -2 \cdot x - 3 ), and what I want to do is figure out what is the slope of the line that this equation describes. There’s a couple of ways that you can approach it. What my brain wants to do is, well, I know a few forms w…
Justinian and the Byzantine Empire | World History | Khan Academy
In previous videos, we talked about how, as we exit the 4th Century in the 390s, the emperor Theodosius actually splits the Roman Empire. We already had the city of Constantinople being established as a capital of the Empire; that was done by Constantine …
The Closer You Are to the Truth, the More Silent You Become Inside
One of the tweets that I put out a while back was: “The closer you get to the truth, the more silent you are inside.” We intuitively know this. When someone is blabbing too much, that person talks too much at the party—the court jester. You know they’re n…
The Launch of ExoMars | MARS
I’ve been thinking about exom for more than 16 years. So, that’s it over there, right? Serious, guys. What we’re doing is really rather difficult. A lot of things have to go right. One minute, one minute, one minute. Building the instruments is hard, and…