yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Exploitation: A problematic pejorative


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

When people use the word "exploitation" in the context of sweatshops, I think they want the word to express a negative judgment. I think that most of the people using the word in this way haven't thought things through clearly.

The greedy capitalist makes the poor person an offer: "Work for me, and I'll pay you $2 an hour." The poor person accepts the offer, glad that he'll still be able to feed his family next week. Meanwhile, an activist is leading a boycott of companies who use sweatshop work. He thinks it's disgusting that anyone should work in such terrible conditions for such a low wage.

If the activist is successful, the capitalist and the poor person won't be able to make the exchange that they both wanted, and the poor person will be back to where he was, with one less option and not knowing where next week's food was going to come from. The activist, to the extent that he's successful in closing down sweatshops, is hurting the interests of the poor person by denying them the option of working in a sweatshop.

The greedy capitalist, by following self-interest, is actually increasing the options of the poor person and improving his situation. If the complaint against the capitalist is that he should be doing more to help, uh, that's surely no reason to prevent him from helping the poor person a little bit. Surely, a little help is better than none at all.

Also, if the complaint against the capitalist is that he should be doing more to help the poor person, then surely that complaint must apply even more strongly to the activist. Whatever their intentions, the activist leading the boycott is actively making the situation of the poor person worse to the extent that his campaign is successful.

So please think twice before you use the term "exploitation" to describe sweatshop work. What do you mean by exploitation? Why do you believe it's negative? If the outcome of what you call exploitation is an improvement over how the situation would otherwise have worked out, does it still make sense to use this term in a negative way?

If exploiters are helping the poor, even just a little bit, while the opponents of exploitation are harming the poor, does it still make sense to use the term "exploitation" as a pejorative? I don't think it does.

More Articles

View All
Portraits of Afghanistan Before the Fall | Podcast | Overheard at National Geographic
[Music] 20 years after the United States went into Afghanistan to pursue Osama bin Laden, U.S. forces have finally withdrawn and the hard-line Islamist Taliban regime has once again seized control of the country. Several months ago, National Geographic se…
Two-sample t test for difference of means | AP Statistics | Khan Academy
Kaito grows tomatoes in two separate fields. When the tomatoes are ready to be picked, he is curious as to whether the sizes of his tomato plants differ between the two fields. He takes a random sample of plants from each field and measures the heights of…
Taoism & The Underestimated Power of Softness
The rigid and stiff will be broken. The soft and yielding will overcome. Lao Tzu. Generally, people admire strength and look down on weakness. We associate strength with being firm and energetic. Strength allows us to accomplish things, fight back agains…
MARCUS AURELIUS PHILOSOPHY FOR BREAKUPS | STOICISM INSIGHTS
Did you know that the toughest experiences can be our greatest teachers? Today we are discussing something that, believe it or not, every single one of us will face at some point: the heart-wrenching turmoil of a breakup. Now you might be thinking, why fo…
Dividing a whole number by a decimal on a number line
[Instructor] What we want to do in this video is figure out what two divided by 0.4 is, or two divided by 4⁄10. So why don’t you pause this video and try to figure out what it is. And as a little bit of a hint, think about two on the number line and thi…
15 Things You Didn't Know About CARTIER
Fifteen things you didn’t know about Cartier. Welcome to a Lux Calm, the place where future billionaires come to get inspired. Hello in Luxor, and welcome to another exciting original video presented by Alex Calm. Today, we’re revealing some interesting …