yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Exploitation: A problematic pejorative


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

When people use the word "exploitation" in the context of sweatshops, I think they want the word to express a negative judgment. I think that most of the people using the word in this way haven't thought things through clearly.

The greedy capitalist makes the poor person an offer: "Work for me, and I'll pay you $2 an hour." The poor person accepts the offer, glad that he'll still be able to feed his family next week. Meanwhile, an activist is leading a boycott of companies who use sweatshop work. He thinks it's disgusting that anyone should work in such terrible conditions for such a low wage.

If the activist is successful, the capitalist and the poor person won't be able to make the exchange that they both wanted, and the poor person will be back to where he was, with one less option and not knowing where next week's food was going to come from. The activist, to the extent that he's successful in closing down sweatshops, is hurting the interests of the poor person by denying them the option of working in a sweatshop.

The greedy capitalist, by following self-interest, is actually increasing the options of the poor person and improving his situation. If the complaint against the capitalist is that he should be doing more to help, uh, that's surely no reason to prevent him from helping the poor person a little bit. Surely, a little help is better than none at all.

Also, if the complaint against the capitalist is that he should be doing more to help the poor person, then surely that complaint must apply even more strongly to the activist. Whatever their intentions, the activist leading the boycott is actively making the situation of the poor person worse to the extent that his campaign is successful.

So please think twice before you use the term "exploitation" to describe sweatshop work. What do you mean by exploitation? Why do you believe it's negative? If the outcome of what you call exploitation is an improvement over how the situation would otherwise have worked out, does it still make sense to use this term in a negative way?

If exploiters are helping the poor, even just a little bit, while the opponents of exploitation are harming the poor, does it still make sense to use the term "exploitation" as a pejorative? I don't think it does.

More Articles

View All
Weaving Tradition: How Tweed Keeps a Community’s Heritage Alive | Short Film Showcase
[Music] I’m Rebecca Hutton, and I’m a single Harris Tweed Weaver. My granny used to weave back in the day, and my great granny. Everybody used to weave; there was a weaving tradition at practically every household when I was growing up. The Harris Tweed …
Saving Lions: How I’m Protecting Wildlife in My Homeland | Nat Geo Live
THANDIWE MWEETWA: Our beautiful wilderness is in trouble. It’s being hammered on all sides by human encroachment, poaching, and habitat degradation. And our mission is to save these large cats, wild dogs, and all these other species in our beautiful ecosy…
Milking the WORLD'S MOST VENOMOUS FISH! - Smarter Every Day 117
Hey it’s me Destin, welcome back to Smarter Every Day. Sometimes I like to walk around in my yard barefooted, which is awesome until I hit a little sticky weed, which hurts. I’m about to ruin the beach for you. There’s an animal called the stonefish that …
Taking a break from stocks
What’s up, Graham? It’s guys here. So, I think it’s really important that we talk about a concerning new trend that’s just started to surface in the stock market over the last few weeks. And listen, I get it. These last few months have been rather eventf…
Mean Tweets with Neil deGrasse Tyson - Movies Edition | StarTalk
And now for another edition of Neil deGrasse Tyson reads mean tweets. Josh from school, that’s his Twitter handle: “Josh from school, Neil Tyson is such a dweeb. Nobody watches science fiction movies for the science.” I wouldn’t say nobody watches the s…
Michael Seibel - Building Product
Without any further delay, I will introduce to you Michael Seibel, the CEO of Y Combinator, the founder of companies like justin.tv and Twitch, and Socialcam, to begin what is going to be a deep dive into product over the next several lectures. Michael: …