yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Supervenience


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

One of the questions was, "Um, how is it that logic supervenes on our brains?"

And I think it's a good question.

Um, I think it's a question that we're not currently in a position to give a full answer to.

Um, for that, our understanding of how the brain and the mind are interrelated needs to be, uh, much more advanced than it currently is.

Um, but I think by way of analogy, I can give you an idea of how, uh, a materialist conception of the mind—how it, how it can, how it approaches this question.

Anyway, so to take the example of a computer, um, we know exactly, uh, the parts that make up a computer, and we know exactly what happens in those parts in order for the computer to do the things it's expected to do.

Ultimately, what happens inside a computer is electrons move around.

That's all it is at a basic level, and yet we're happy to say things like the computer calculates, uh, a sum, an equation, or the computer displays a web page.

And yet we don't feel the need to posit some kind of immaterial entity or immaterial knowledge or symbol or something from another realm that somehow is injected into the computer that enables it to do these things.

We know exactly what's in a computer, what happens in a computer, and we also know that in a manner of speaking, the result is greater than the sum of its parts.

The ability to calculate or to display a web page supervenes on the fundamental activity of electrons in a computer.

And what the materialist worldview says, or at least the version that I'm familiar with, is that in a similar way, the electrical and chemical activity inside the brain gives rise to Consciousness, thought, abstract Concepts, etc.

So logic, as in our internal representation of the most general features of the reality in which we find ourselves, logic in that sense supervenes on the physical.

I hope that makes it a bit clearer.

More Articles

View All
What Will Happen If the Rivers Disappear? | Short Film Showcase
[Music] It would make a huge difference, folks. We’re making the decisions; we’d get out and see just how special Texas rivers are and Texas bays are. I have to believe it would change the way they approach decisions, really understand what’s at stake. S…
Roman Empire and Christianity | World History | Khan Academy
As we’ve talked about in multiple videos, Christianity is a religion that grew out of the fringes of the Roman Empire. It starts as a Jewish sect in Judea and Galilee with the teachings of Jesus and his early ministry. But it’s important to keep in mind t…
Iron triangles and issue networks | US government and civics | Khan Academy
Now, a related idea to just what a bureaucracy is in our federal government: another question is how do they get influenced? Now, one idea that you might see in many American government courses is the idea of an iron triangle. So, an iron triangle describ…
Decomposing shapes to find area (subtract) | Math | 3rd grade | Khan Academy
What is the area of the shaded figure? So down here we have this green shaded figure, and it looks like a rectangle, except it has this square cut out in the middle. So when we find its area, we can think of it exactly like that. We want to know how much…
HACK YOUTUBE COMMENTS ... and other pranks! -- Up All Knight #4
Vsauce! On Wednesday, a lot of you guys were asking for a new episode of Up All Night, our technical pranks and curiosities show. Unfortunately, these guys are still on vacation, but I’m going to try to do this alone. Let’s go to begin. You can break int…
Street Fighter PUPPET SHOW: BLANKA!
No, you shut up. Oh, hello! I’m Adam Mlin from Wacky Gamer. I’m going to be sick! Did you know that I have an online puppet show called Animal Trash that you can watch on YouTube? It’s true! We even made a video for Vuce, but don’t take my word for it—ch…