yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Supervenience


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

One of the questions was, "Um, how is it that logic supervenes on our brains?"

And I think it's a good question.

Um, I think it's a question that we're not currently in a position to give a full answer to.

Um, for that, our understanding of how the brain and the mind are interrelated needs to be, uh, much more advanced than it currently is.

Um, but I think by way of analogy, I can give you an idea of how, uh, a materialist conception of the mind—how it, how it can, how it approaches this question.

Anyway, so to take the example of a computer, um, we know exactly, uh, the parts that make up a computer, and we know exactly what happens in those parts in order for the computer to do the things it's expected to do.

Ultimately, what happens inside a computer is electrons move around.

That's all it is at a basic level, and yet we're happy to say things like the computer calculates, uh, a sum, an equation, or the computer displays a web page.

And yet we don't feel the need to posit some kind of immaterial entity or immaterial knowledge or symbol or something from another realm that somehow is injected into the computer that enables it to do these things.

We know exactly what's in a computer, what happens in a computer, and we also know that in a manner of speaking, the result is greater than the sum of its parts.

The ability to calculate or to display a web page supervenes on the fundamental activity of electrons in a computer.

And what the materialist worldview says, or at least the version that I'm familiar with, is that in a similar way, the electrical and chemical activity inside the brain gives rise to Consciousness, thought, abstract Concepts, etc.

So logic, as in our internal representation of the most general features of the reality in which we find ourselves, logic in that sense supervenes on the physical.

I hope that makes it a bit clearer.

More Articles

View All
How to sell a $20,000,000 private jet.
You have a budget in mind, probably 10 to 20 million. That would be a number that’s not really an issue. What is the Gulf Stream G450? I guess you have two T450s on here; they’re going. One of them was also sold. We have another one that’s 95 million. The…
Drowning in Grain: A Look at the Hidden Dangers of Farming | Short Film Showcase
So we’ve got a situation here with a farmer or child who’s trapped in a grain bin. We’ve got plastic coffers here, and we’ll be placing these on each side of the victim. These are actually going to protect the victim from the corn, to get the corn from co…
Bankrupt by 28: Why Dave Ramsey lost MILLIONS in Real Estate
What’s up you guys? It’s Graham here. So here’s a very familiar sounding story about someone who got his real estate license at the age of eighteen, began investing in real estate in his early 20s, amassed a four million dollar real estate portfolio with …
Light Painting With a Frisbee - Pre-Smarter Every Day
Hey, it’s me, Destin. We like to do a lot of weird things with our cameras. So, one thing I was going to show you is how to do some real neat things with open-shutter photography. Basically, you open the shutter for an extended period of time, and then yo…
The upcoming economic crisis? | Stagflation explained
There is a really ugly word that is beginning to be thrown around for the first time in nearly 50 years. The last time the US economy experienced the devastating impacts of this word was way back in the 1970s, a period of time when inflation had a stagger…
Seasons | The Earth-sun-moon system | Middle school Earth and space science | Khan Academy
In this video, we’re gonna think about why we have seasons on Earth like summer and fall and winter and spring. Now, one theory that some folks might have is maybe it’s due to the distance between the Earth and the Sun. We know that the Earth orbits the S…