yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Supervenience


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

One of the questions was, "Um, how is it that logic supervenes on our brains?"

And I think it's a good question.

Um, I think it's a question that we're not currently in a position to give a full answer to.

Um, for that, our understanding of how the brain and the mind are interrelated needs to be, uh, much more advanced than it currently is.

Um, but I think by way of analogy, I can give you an idea of how, uh, a materialist conception of the mind—how it, how it can, how it approaches this question.

Anyway, so to take the example of a computer, um, we know exactly, uh, the parts that make up a computer, and we know exactly what happens in those parts in order for the computer to do the things it's expected to do.

Ultimately, what happens inside a computer is electrons move around.

That's all it is at a basic level, and yet we're happy to say things like the computer calculates, uh, a sum, an equation, or the computer displays a web page.

And yet we don't feel the need to posit some kind of immaterial entity or immaterial knowledge or symbol or something from another realm that somehow is injected into the computer that enables it to do these things.

We know exactly what's in a computer, what happens in a computer, and we also know that in a manner of speaking, the result is greater than the sum of its parts.

The ability to calculate or to display a web page supervenes on the fundamental activity of electrons in a computer.

And what the materialist worldview says, or at least the version that I'm familiar with, is that in a similar way, the electrical and chemical activity inside the brain gives rise to Consciousness, thought, abstract Concepts, etc.

So logic, as in our internal representation of the most general features of the reality in which we find ourselves, logic in that sense supervenes on the physical.

I hope that makes it a bit clearer.

More Articles

View All
Top 5 Most Valuable Principles #1
Embrace reality and deal with it. There is nothing more important than understanding how reality works and how to deal with it. The state of mind you bring to this process makes all the difference. I found it helpful to think of my life as if it were a g…
The Best Aperture Videos of 2023
You wake up to the sound of the alarm on your iPhone, and annoyed that you couldn’t get more sleep, you grudgingly unlock your phone to see what’s going on in the world. There’s an email from Amazon telling you that your package has been delivered, so you…
My Water Is Not Safe to Drink | From The Ashes
WOMAN: Here’s my first letter. It tells me I got to have re-sampling. A month later, a little over a month later, again, my well water is not safe to drink. Then the third letter I get says my water is safe to drink, almost 11 months later. [inaudible] ar…
Sounds That Make You Go Barf | Brain Games
I would love for you to give me your honest opinion about our new headphones. Would you like to try them out? Bring it! Let’s go try this one on. Throw them on, check it out. Pick it up, it’s so clear. Excellent! Oh, I’ll be jamming on the subway with th…
Building The World's Best Image Diffusion Model
I think we thought the product was going to be one way, and then we literally ripped it all up in a month and a half or so before release. We were sort of like lost in the jungle for a moment, like a bit of a panic. There’s a lot of unsolved problems basi…
Diadochi and the Hellenistic Period | World History | Khan Academy
Where we left off in the last video, Alexander dies in 323 BCE at the young age of 32. Even though he conquered all of this territory, it was a very short-lived Empire. What happens next is a period known as the wars of the Diodi. Let me write down this …