yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Free Markets Provide the Best Feedback


3m read
·Nov 3, 2024

Mark Andreessen summarizes this nicely as "strong opinions loosely held."

So, as a society, if you're truth-seeking, you want to have strong opinions but very loosely held. You want to try them, see if they work, and then error-correct if they don't. But instead, what we get is either strong opinion strongly held, which is the intolerant minority, or we get weak opinions loosely held, which is the compromise model where no one really takes blame, no one gets credit, no one gets to try the way that they want to, and everybody can then fall back on "real communism hasn't been tried."

Although, in that case, real communism has been tried; it just hasn't worked out well. As a digression, one of the common critiques that I hear people say is, "We need to move to a post-capitalist world; capitalism isn't working." Okay, well, what is your alternative?

Usually, this is where people start fumbling because there aren't a lot of choices when you're trying to figure out how to divvy up credit, divvy up resources, and reward people for their work. You essentially have two choices: feedback from free markets in reality, and the best model for that is money; or you have feedback from people, which is where communism ends up.

In communism, a group of people decides that you did the best work. Now, who decides you did the best work? Someone has to be in charge of doing that. Invariably, that ends up being the biggest thug. So, I don't think it's an accident that every communist country degenerates into a dictatorship. North Korea is obviously run by the Kim Jong-il family; China, Paul; Fidel Castro.

Communism never seems to actually be run by a distributed majority of the people. It always ends up being run by a bunch of people who are taking charge. Because it's just human nature that if I get to decide who gets the gold, it's going to go to my friend's family and the people that I like. That's invariably what ends up happening.

Either you need an objective function to carve it up, and money is the known objective function, or it becomes all subjective. If it's subjective, then who's to say you're carving it up instead of me? We're just going to decide based on who has more physical force, who has more guns.

What we say on the side of free markets is that what we've extracted out of that decision-making process is the coercion. No one is forced into purchasing a service or undertaking an agreement. The only time force is applied is when the government gets involved.

The people at the top then say this is the best decision, and you will all have to agree with it. Otherwise, there's going to be a man with a badge and a gun turn up at your door. All that we're saying when it comes to free market is that the individual gets to decide without being coerced what might work for them.

Now, they could be wrong, but why shouldn't they try and make mistakes? It's the only way to make progress. The only way to error-correct is to actually try something else. Perhaps fail.

More Articles

View All
Safari Live - Day 376 | National Geographic
[Music] This program features live coverage of an African safari and may include animal kills and carcasses. Viewer discretion is advised. Good afternoon everyone! Well, no better way to start an afternoon game Drive than with the little prince, who’s po…
Adjectives and commas | Adjectives | Khan Academy
Hey Garans, hey Paige, hi David. Hey, so Paige, I went to the grocery store yesterday and I got this apple. Okay? I put it in the fridge, uh, and this morning when I opened the fridge, the apple was all like gross and sticky and mushy. I really want to w…
Widowmaker Waves | Wicked Tuna: Outer Banks
The commercial fishing boat, Risky Business, was on his way across the ocean bar. But it was struck by two freak waves. Lion Bridge was nearly ripped away from the hull. That just gave me anxiety! I wish you know, welcome back to the OBX. Yes, they both h…
Face-to-Face with a Bear - Meet the Expert | National Geographic
Welcome! It is so lovely to see you all here today. I’m your host, Lizzy Daly, and I am thrilled to be bringing you all on an epic journey to meet some of the world’s best scientists, wildlife experts, and National Geographic explorers from around the wor…
Nature is dying.
Have you ever stood on a mountaintop or gazed up from the bottom of a roaring waterfall? Or sat in a field staring at the stars above? Did it inspire you in a feeling of insignificance? Where do you go to seek out those humble yet peaceful moments when yo…
Weekend Wednesday
The way the work week works is the worst. Waking up on Monday, you’ve got five days in a row of work or school. It’s too much. For, by Wednesday, withered is your soul with two more days, nay three more days, until the weekend. But, alas. The weekend is a…