yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Is That My Real Hand? | Breakthrough


2m read
·Nov 11, 2024

Well, there's a lot of interest in the robotics community. How can we extend the human body, not only with advanced prosthetic limbs for amps, but maybe for exoskeletons? And then, of course, the question is at what point do these external devices become part of your own body representation?

At one point, do you start to feel that this is really me? Sitting in the lab with Henrik and Andreas, one of Henrik's postdocs, I'm about to be put through the rubber hand experiment. "Put your arm here onto the table and inside this little box here. Okay, cover your right side here now."

"Okay, so what I would do now is I will touch your index finger with the brush here, and please look to the index finger of the hand here." Okay, with my hand hidden from view, Andrea starts to stroke my index finger and the index finger of the rubber hand in almost perfect synchrony.

What you experience, I think, is genuinely beginning to become hard to tell whether—yeah, I mean, it's beginning to feel like—yeah, yeah, I'm buying it, that you're rubbing, that you're swiping. That part of my brain is telling me that it's not possible that that's happening, you know? And then when you're not touching it, I go, "No, not happening." Then you touch it, and I'm like, "Yeah, I'm feeling it there." It's totally—now, just, there’s no question that that's my hand, that that's what you're touching.

All that's the—that's the first experiment. That's crazy! That's super crazy! When they connect my finger with the rubber hand's finger and introduce movement to the experiment—well, now the illusion gets totally surreal. "Oh my God, that's my—that's crazy! That's really weird! Oh man, that's nuts!"

There was a real moment where it suddenly switched. I was like, "Now this isn't working," and then suddenly, now it's just—again, the more I'm doing it. But that's the thing, now I'm not doing anything—now you do! That's crazy! I'm doing this—that's crazy! And it only gets more so as it goes on.

"You have a new hand, artificial hand—that's amazing! Can touch it wow!" If they can add a rubber hand to my body that easily, I can only imagine what they could do with a little more effort in planning.

More Articles

View All
How To Work On A Long Term Plan (Without Having One)
There are many people who want to work toward a long-term goal, but they just don’t have one. They don’t know what they’ll be doing in the next five or ten years. They don’t know what life has in store for them. Maybe they’ll be in a different town with a…
Leah Culver of Breaker and Tom Sparks of YC Answer Your Questions About Security and Podcasting
All right, so how about we start with some questions from Twitter. I actually think this one might have been on Facebook, so Brady Simpson asked, “How do we deal with the ever-increasing pressure from governments trying to get into devices?” Tom, do you …
How the comfort zone is ruining your life
[Music] There’s a weird phenomenon I’ve noticed all throughout my life where the more I subject myself to discomfort, the happier I am. I think this phenomenon became increasingly apparent to me in first year of university where I wanted to make the best …
Proportional relationships example
[Instructor] We’re told that Mael mixes 15 milliliters of bleach with 3.75 liters of water to make a sanitizing solution for a daycare. The amounts of bleach and water always have to be proportional when he makes the sanitizing solution. Which of the fo…
Strasbourg Euro Rant HDQT
Kevin: Oy, your roaming investor in the middle of Strasburg, France. Why do you care? Because this is the center of the EU. This is where the Parliament is. This is the epicenter of where all the decisions are made for the European Union. Now, let’s talk…
My Water Is Not Safe to Drink | From The Ashes
WOMAN: Here’s my first letter. It tells me I got to have re-sampling. A month later, a little over a month later, again, my well water is not safe to drink. Then the third letter I get says my water is safe to drink, almost 11 months later. [inaudible] ar…