yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Categorical grants, mandates, and the Commerce Clause | US government and civics | Khan Academy


4m read
·Nov 11, 2024

In a previous video, we've introduced ourselves to the idea of federalism in the United States. At a high level, you could view it as a contract between a national government and the states of which it is made. But you could also view it as a layered form of government, where you have your local government, and then layered on top of that, your state government, and then layered on top of that, your national government, often referred to as the federal government.

We looked at the example of a layered cake but have said that over the course of American history, the layers have gotten more and more mixed, more like a marbled cake. It's been mixed more in the favor of the national or the federal government, even though certain powers were historically more associated with the states. As we will see, there are several levers that the federal government has used in order to extend its power into the domain of what used to be associated with primarily the states.

So one is the notion of categorical grants. These are grants for a specific purpose where the federal government says, "Hey states, we're going to give you some money, but you've got to use this money in exactly the way that we're telling you." Now to be clear, not all grants are categorical grants. You have things like block grants, where the federal government can give a grant to a state and say, "Hey use this to generally improve the safety of your citizens." That would still give a lot of leeway to states, but in categorical grants, it's very specific in terms of how the states are to use that money, even if historically it was something where the states had the powers.

An example of this would be the federal program, the Special Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program for Women, Infants, and Children, or WIC. To get an idea of how prescriptive it is, here is an outline of the program on the USDA website, a federal government agency. If we go down here, you can even see things like income requirements, and there'll be income eligibility guidelines. These are set by the federal government, not by the states.

Along those lines, you also have mandates. A mandate is the federal government tying funding to one thing based on state compliance with another thing. For example, the National Minimum Drinking Age Act, which was passed in 1984, ties federal highway funds to states raising their minimum drinking age to 21. I had direct experience with this act when I was growing up in Louisiana. Louisiana decided not to comply with the National Minimum Drinking Age Act, so the drinking age was 18. But because they didn't comply, they weren't getting as much federal funding for highways, and the highways weren't as good as in other states.

So, even though the drinking age is something that might be considered a state power, the federal government was able to exercise a lot of influence on most states by tying what the federal government wanted to highway funds.

Now, outside of these examples of the federal government tying state funds to the states doing what the federal government wants, the federal government has also made use of the U.S. Constitution in order to broaden its powers. In particular, the commerce clause, Article 1, Section 8, you might remember that's the part where they say, "The Congress shall have power," and then they list a bunch of powers. But one of them, the commerce clause, is to regulate commerce with foreign nations and among the several states and with the Indian tribes.

The key part of the commerce clause is "among the several states." Over the course of American history, this ability to regulate interstate commerce, commerce between states, the federal government has used that to justify regulations and laws that focus on issues that may at first be perceived as a state power but use the argument that it affects interstate commerce in order to regulate it.

As you can imagine, when you have free-flowing commerce between states, you have the same currency, you don't have tariffs between states. Many things that you would traditionally view as the power of the state, one could argue, would have some influence on interstate commerce. One notable example of this would be federal drug laws, where a state could decide to say legalize marijuana, but the federal government can make it pretty difficult by regulating how is that marijuana transported or where does the cash for that marijuana get deposited. Does it get deposited in a bank that has associations with the Federal Reserve that needs to transfer that money across state lines?

So, the interstate commerce clause has more influence on state affairs than you might initially think.

More Articles

View All
How to take AI from vision to practice. Part 3
This conversation forward. Please ask questions, comment in the chat. Uh, we’d love to hear from you. So let, um, yes, we are sharing. We are recording this webinar, and we will be sharing the webinar after it is done, so absolutely you’ll be able to acce…
Multiplying 10s | Math | 4th grade | Khan Academy
Let’s multiply 40 times 70. So, 40 times we have the number 70. So, we could actually list that out, the number 70, 40 different times and add it up, but that’s clearly a lot of computation to do, and there’s got to be a faster way. So, another way is …
Colonizing Mars | StarTalk
So let’s go piece by piece. One-way mission with people who would just agree to go one way, and he sends supplies in advance. There’s going to set up Hab modules. I’ve got an image of what his Hab modules would look like on Mars. I think we can put it up …
Identifying hundredths on a number line | Math | 4th grade | Khan Academy
Where is the point on the number line? Here we have a number line that starts at 1.5, or 1 and 5⁄10, and goes to 1 and 7⁄10. The distance between these larger blue tick marks is 1/10th because we go from 1 and 5⁄10 to 1 and 6⁄10, so that went up a tenth,…
What’s It Like to Photograph the Pope? | Exposure
I’ve never had an assignment that was so frightening in that I had no idea what I was going to shoot. The biggest challenge to photographing the Vatican that I found was simply getting in there. It’s like a gigantic curtain. Just to get behind this curtai…
Axe Ghost devlog - The bug that ruined the run
My name is Thomas K. I’m working on a game called Axe Ghost. It’s currently in development. There’s a demo on Steam, and my good friend Rishad Buser, he plays the beta version of Axe Ghost, and when he’s able, he streams his daily runs. Richard, by the wa…