yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Answering Presuppositionalism: Basic


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

Theists who subscribe to the presuppositionalist school of thought say that atheists can't account for inductive reasoning. They claim that, in fact, whenever an atheist uses inductive reasoning, she is borrowing from the Christian worldview, because according to them, it's the only worldview that can account for the uniformity of nature, which is needed for inductive reasoning to work.

But even if the Christian is correct in his claim that an atheist can't account for a given facet of nature that she nevertheless depends upon, this is not that urgent deal-breaking problem that the presuppositionalist tends to paint for us.

Imagine a primitive society where most people believe that spirit ancestors reward the ritual act of watering a plant by causing that plant to grow. A person in this society who didn't believe in the existence of spirit ancestors would still go ahead and water his plants, because otherwise they would die.

The skeptics' peers might ask him, "How can you account for the fact that applying water causes the plant to grow in your worldview?" The skeptic, ignorant of plant biology, would have no answer. His peers might then say, "Every time you water your plants, you're borrowing from our worldview, because ours is the only system that can account for the connection between applying water to a plant and that plant's growth."

I hope the points I wanted to illustrate with this analogy are already clear, but I'll spell them out:

One, having an explanation does not make your position superior to that of those who may lack one.

Two, not being able to explain a phenomenon doesn't preclude you from legitimately assuming the reliability of that phenomenon.

Three, assuming the reliability of a phenomenon without being able to account for it does not mean that you implicitly accept the worldview of people claiming that theirs is the only explanation of that phenomenon.

Four, the failure of a person to explain a phenomenon doesn't invalidate their worldview or render it inconsistent.

Five, acknowledging that you don't have an answer is better than making things up.

More Articles

View All
How To Make Your Life Insanely Simple (In 6 Months)
I used to feel overwhelmed every day, trying to do too much, try to be everywhere, try to be everything to everyone. And then I realized something: life wasn’t supposed to be this complicated. The truth was I was choosing complexity. It took me 6 months t…
Why Fundraising Is Different In Silicon Valley - Michael Seibel
Neither day I did office hours with the YC company, and they were very concerned about fundraising because they had tried really hard to fundraise in their local community. They grew up in North Carolina, and it was impossible for them to raise any money.…
12 SIGNS THAT YOU SHOULD CUT ALL CONTACT WITH SOMEONE | MARCUS AURELIUS | STOICISM INSIGHTS
We often think of our relationships as mere extensions of our daily routines, rarely stopping to consider their profound impact on our well-being. Yet, what if I told you that the quality of your relationships could be the single most crucial factor in yo…
Do We Have Free Will? | Robert Sapolsky & Andrew Huberman
Speaker A: - Along the lines of choice, I’d like to shift gears slightly and talk about free will, about our ability to make choices at all. Speaker B: - Well, my personal way out in left field inflammatory stance is I don’t think we have a shred of free…
Why and how to save | Budgeting & saving | Financial Literacy | Khan Academy
So I’m guessing that you already have a sense that saving money is a good idea. It’s good for a rainy day; that’s why we have an emergency fund. There might be unexpected interruptions to your income or unexpected costs that happen from your car breaking …
Are Psychedelics Microdosing The NEXT BIG Investment? - Why I'm Investing...| Kevin O'Leary
Hi everybody. As you know, I’ve been talking about microdosing psychedelics as a medicine for about a year now. I’ve been intrigued by this new development because it has the potential to become groundbreaking medicine. We don’t know that yet. So many com…