yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Incentives for DROs not to go 'rogue'


3m read
·Nov 8, 2024

There are two dispute resolution organizations or Dr. Alto and Tenna. Tenna and Alto have both been in business for a while. They're both well-respected firms. Both have similar amounts of capital and similarly sized customer bases. They have mutual agreements for procedures for efficiently resolving disputes between clients with the other firm. So, reciprocity agreements basically they have agreements not to impede each other in their work unless the defense of their clients demand it. They have an agreement that disputes between themselves will be resolved using a third-party arbitration organization, Alpha ARB. All these agreements have been useful in gaining trust from customers and suppliers so far.

One day, an evil consultant arrives at the Tenna headquarters and sketches a plan that Tenna could use to get ahead of Alto. Tenna could charge customers a large fee but, in exchange, enable them to profit by defaulting on prisoners' dilemma situations. Tenna would achieve this by using force to block the victim's DRRO, which is Alto, from enforcing the contract. The defaulting Tenna customers would gain more from defaulting on the prisoners' dilemmas than they would have to pay to Tenna in fees. So, on paper, Tenna and its customers would profit at the expense of Alto and their customers.

But the chief of Tenna isn't at all impressed with the plan, and he explains to the evil consultant why it wouldn't work. First of all, Tenna doesn't yet have the extra capital that the plan would deliver, so its means are similar to the means of Alto. Having many units on constant standby ready to mobilize against Alto at any time would increase the cost of running Tenna considerably. Also, if Alto retaliates against Tenna's attempted blocking, there's a high risk that Tenna's forces will suffer the loss of agents and equipment, which is even more expensive.

More importantly, Tenna will be breaking multiple critical contractual agreements. The first time it blocked Alto from enforcing a contract, Alto would immediately open a dispute with the two firms' previously agreed-upon arbitrator, Alpha AB. Alpha AB's motivation to protect its reputation as a fair arbitrator would lead it to rule in favor of Alto. If Tenna refused to pay the hefty penalty issued by Alpha AB, it would find itself with an irreparably damaged trust rating and in virtual economic isolation. It would effectively be an outlaw organization.

Tenna's customers, acting in self-interest, would cancel their Tenna subscriptions and flock to Alto because other organizations on whom they depend, like insurance companies, banks, etc., all stipulate that their clients must be subscribed to a WH list DRRO, and Tenna is now on the blacklist. Tenna would quickly end up with no customers and no supply of money to fund a battle against Alto.

The point of this story is to illustrate that an analysis of the incentives for a DRRO to aggress against another in order to profit shouldn't ignore the indirect knock-on effects of that aggression on a network of cooperation agreements. Of course, with enough capital, maybe Tenna could still seize power, but in the kind of society I've sketched, I don't think it will be nearly as easy or as likely as Randy's analysis suggests.

More Articles

View All
Safari Live - Day 288 | National Geographic
Fricken Safari and may include animal kills and caucuses. Viewer discretion is advised. Look at the beautiful kudus! At the moment, they are all just trying to investigate what is happening in the surrounding. What a lovely afternoon! Most of all, welcome…
These Giant Manta Rays Just Want to Hang Out | Expedition Raw
We are at the Ravi Hio Island, 300 miles from shore off of Mexico, and we’re putting Critter cams on giant mantas for the first time. Mantas are so friendly that they just hang out with the divers, so we wouldn’t get any interesting footage because we’d …
Worked example: Derivatives of sin(x) and cos(x) | Derivative rules | AP Calculus AB | Khan Academy
What we want to do is find the derivative of this G of X. At first, it could look intimidating. We have a s of X here, we have a cosine of X, we have this crazy expression here, we have a pi over cube root of x. We’re squaring the whole thing, and at firs…
watch this if you think life is UNFAIR
This video is brought to you by Squarespace. From websites and online stores to marketing tools and analytics, Squarespace is the all-in-one platform to build a beautiful online presence and run your business. Do you think that life is fair? Compare your…
Animal Survival Technique - Smarter Every Day (T-5)
Hey, it’s me, Destin. We got a lot of rain here in Alabama over the last couple of weeks, and I wanted to show you an interesting survival technique I’ve found in one of the local species. Anyway, you can see all the area behind me used to be a wide ope…
Meet Six Rescued Rhinos That Survived Poaching | Short Film Showcase
Dingle, darlin’, lion’s den. They both lost their horns to poaching. They hit Worden family one day. Nice. How could the other panic? In his voice he said, “Are you, are you nuts? Press!” I said, “I said game drivers has come in, reported they were raided…