yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Re: The Trouble With The Electoral College – Cities, Metro Areas, Elections and The United States


3m read
·Nov 7, 2024

Hello, internet. Let's talk about this map, this argument, and the Electoral College in general. In my “Trouble With The Electoral College” video from 2011, I was wrong to use the city limits for that part of the argument, rather than the more expansive metro area. The lawyerish nerd inside of me still wants to argue “technically correct” on that one.

I used the city boundaries because the metro areas are often vague and absurdly large: the New York City metro area is 6700+ mi² over four states, and from where I partly grew up, it seemed that a lot of that area had nothing to do with New York City proper. So, at the time, I disregarded the metro boundaries. But using the strict city boundaries in that video was the wrong decision in retrospect.

In addition to being a bad argument to make, it also doesn't address the concerns this map expresses. And this is correct! Half the population does live in the grey counties. And more than that, the map gets at a fundamental division in the United States and other countries that leads partly to the politics we see: the difference between the rural and the urban. If trends continue, a higher and higher percentage of the country will live in urban areas.

In another eight or sixteen years, this map will be even more extreme: the metro areas even denser. Which, if you're in favour of the Electoral College, will seem like even more of a reason to keep it. Now this is where we must discuss the idea that the Electoral College ensures the president is elected by the states. It doesn't. A candidate can win the Electoral College with just the eleven biggest states. This collection may seem unlikely, but as urbanization and the politics it creates continues, it becomes increasingly likely.

The Electoral College doesn't ensure the president wins with a lot of states, or even geographically diverse states. Now, "Should the president represent the people, or should the president represent the states?" is a question without an answer. This is about preference in style of governance. One moves power up to the federal level, and the other moves power down to the states.

And given the vastness of the country and the difference in her geographies, it's reasonable to believe that states with greater power is the better, less divisive solution to the problem of governance. But the Electoral College does nothing to help that. It happens to be that recent wins have been geographically spread, but the Electoral College doesn't ensure that outcome.

Cram everyone into California, leaving one person in each state, and the Electoral College says: “California alone, she decides.” We could have a system where the president must win a majority of the states, which is what some think the Electoral College is... but it isn't. The election only happens to make it look that way. The protection of the Electoral College is only an illusion.

Even if you still like the Electoral College, though it doesn't actually protect the small states, the Electoral College still comes with the most bitter of anti-republic pills. For even if you win the election in November, your victory can be taken away from you in December. The Electoral College votes your state gets aren't really votes, but are individual members of the political parties, who perform the real vote for president in December.

No citizen voted for these electors to cast a vote on their behalf, and many of the electors are free to vote for whoever they want. Their election in December is the real election. The Electoral College was designed to be able to overwrite the will of the people, or its own election process, any time enough of a small number of unknown, unelected political party insiders don't like the result they got.

If you're in favor of the Electoral College, you have to accept that, by its own rules, it can take away your victory, under the guise of protecting you from yourself. This has never happened in American history, nor should it. But it is crazy to leave in place for future elections a system that benefits no citizens and protects no states. It's time to get rid of the Electoral College and have a real discussion about what a modern government and election system should look like.

More Articles

View All
Matter and energy in food webs | Middle school biology | Khan Academy
In this video, we’re going to talk about food webs, which is really just a way of picturing how all of the matter and how all of the energy flows inside of an ecosystem. Now, when I talk about matter, I’m talking about the atoms in an ecosystem, the molec…
STRAPPED INTO A SINKING HELICOPTER (with U.S. Marines) - Smarter Every Day 201
(helicopter flying) (alarm systems beeping) [Instructor] Ditching, ditching, ditching. (water rushing) So, I’m alive. (laughs) All right, here’s the deal. My last mission as a U.S. government civil servant was in a helicopter off the coast of Hawaii. W…
The 2023 Recession Just Started | DO THIS NOW
What’s up guys, it’s Graham here. So, as it turns out, we might very well be seeing the beginnings of a 2023 bear market. In fact, the slowing inflation was just reported: more than a third of small businesses couldn’t afford to pay all of the rent in Oc…
Where Is This Video?
Hey, Vsauce. Michael here. Steve Seitz and Chuck Dyer used view morphing to digitally reveal a side of the Mona Lisa we’ve never seen before. What it would look like if she stared directly at us. That’s her, but it seems a bit unfamiliar. I mean, there is…
Don't Make These Hiring Mistakes
I’ve been trying to hire our first engineer for a year, and like, I can’t like find anyone. And it’s not because there’s literally no one with the word engineer on their resume that they can hire, right? [Music] Hello, this is Michael with Harj and Brad…
Ray Dalio & Deepak Chopra on Life and Death
[Music] I’m Deepak Chopra, and I trained as an internist, medical doctor, endocrinologist, and neuroendocrinologist. My current journey is exploring consciousness and what we call reality. If you don’t know who Ray Dalio is, then you’re probably asleep. …