yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

There Is No End of Science


2m read
·Nov 3, 2024

That's an excellent example of what's called a crucial test, which is sort of the pinnacle of what science is all about. If we do a test and it doesn't agree with a particular theory that we have, that's problematic. But that doesn't mean that it refutes the theory because if you were to refute the only theory that you have, where do you jump to? You don't have any alternative.

If we were to do a scientific test tomorrow and it was inconsistent with the theory of general relativity, then what? There is no alternative to general relativity. In fact, when there have been experiments over the years that seem to have been inconsistent with general relativity, guess what? They've all turned out to be faulty. If you had to choose between whether or not general relativity has been refuted by your test or your test is flawed, go with the fact that your test is being flawed.

In the case of Eddington's experiment, we had two viable theories for what gravity was. We had Newton's theory of universal gravitation on the one hand, and we had Einstein's general theory of relativity on the other. This experiment that you described of how much the light was bent during a solar eclipse, the correct way of describing what happened is not that we showed that general relativity was correct in some final sense, but rather we refuted Newton's theory of gravitation.

Newton's theory was ruled out because it was inconsistent with the test, while general relativity was consistent with the test. This doesn't mean that general relativity is the final word in science; it means that it's the best theory we have for now. There are a whole bunch of reasons that we might think general relativity ultimately has to turn out false. We never have the final word, and that's a good thing.

That's a really positive, optimistic thing because it means we can keep on improving, we can keep on making progress, and we keep on discovering new things. There is no end of science. The long thought-about idea that so many have feared—that one day progress will come to a halt, that science will end—in fact, we are at the beginning of infinity, and we will always be at the beginning of infinity precisely because we can improve our ideas.

Because we're fallible human beings, none of our theories are perfect, because we aren't, and our process by which we create knowledge isn't perfect either; it's error-prone.

More Articles

View All
Inside the Kurdish Ground War on ISIS | Explorer
[Music] I began covering War for National Geographic in 2006, and I never got to Kurdistan during that part of the war. In fact, I really didn’t have any idea who the Kurds were back then. I happened to meet some wounded Kurdish soldiers in Baghdad, and I…
Last Wild Places: Gorongosa | National Geographic
(Mysterious music) - The war took a lot from this place. We all started from this wilderness, and it has to remain on us; otherwise, we lost our identity, we lost part of us. (Intense music) I am part of the next generation of women that has to make sure …
Solo Escape from Iraq | No Man Left Behind
I was a 28-year-old guy loving life and everything else. And uh, I was in the Special Air Service. I can remember flying in; the first thing that came over the headset was the pilot saying, “Welcome to Iraq.” From that point, a new game was on. The 8-man …
Simplifying quotient of powers (rational exponents) | Algebra I | High School Math | Khan Academy
So we have an interesting equation here, and let’s see if we can solve for K. We’re going to assume that m is greater than zero, like always. Pause the video, try it out on your own, and then I will do it with you. All right, let’s work on this a little …
Beautiful and Elusive: This Bird Is Losing Its Home | National Geographic
[Music] My name is Roger Factor. I’m a conservationist working for the Wildlife Conservation Society. Most of my weekend, actually, when I’m not busy doing some other thing on conservation, I’m out bird-watching. We are inside the Colloforus today, just…
Shower Thoughts To Keep You Up All Night #Marathon
So here are shower thoughts that everyone asked or… right? Well, at least some people asked for it. But you know what? No one has probably ever asked, “Where are you?” in sign language before. Actually, the phrase “Where are you?” was probably rarely used…