yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Re: Which Planet is the Closest?


3m read
·Nov 7, 2024

Hello Internet. While working on a future video, I offhandedly wrote, “Venus, the closest planet to Earth.” But later, while editing, I thought, “You know, let me check that.” Which led to me to this video by Dr. Stockman explaining how, no, Venus is not the closest. This blew my mind, and I contacted the author to adapt his video into the one you probably just watched. It blew my mind, not just because it was surprising, but also because I taught physics for years and probably said “Venus is the closest planet” dozens of times without ever thinking about it.

How does that happen? First, asking the precisely right question is vital. "Which planet is closest?" is not the precisely right question. Because it’s really made of four parts: Which planet ever gets the closest? Which planet is the closest for the longest time? Which planet has the shortest average distance to Earth? Which planet takes the least amount of time to travel to? The answer to the first one is Venus. The second two? Mercury. The last? It's complicated; get a physics degree.

Literal rocket scientists think mostly about that last question and the rest of us are probably vaguely asking about the first when we say "Which is the closest?" because we're not thinking about the planets in motion. If we were, we'd ask something closer to questions two and three, which is what the main video is about. Mercury, on average, has the shortest distance to all the other planets, and for the inner planets, it’s also the closest planet most of the time. But to get an answer that precise requires a precise question.

Unlike the way things are done in school, where questions yield knowledge, it's knowledge that yields questions, which yield knowledge. Now, it's hard to think about the raw knowledge of everything all at once, so we condense down part of what we know into a model to help us think, like with the line of the planets.

But, as with fuzzy questions, models can trick us too: “Which planet is the closest?” looks like a simple and easy question when the solar system is shown this way. Like even when you know that isn't really how the Solar System looks. Can't possibly be. In my old video about Pluto (where I sound like a completely different person), I covered this exact point as I've often done in class:

(past Grey) "If we take this diagram and adjust for the correct sizes of the planets, it looks like this. Think about it. If Jupiter was this close to Earth, it wouldn’t look like a dot in the night sky, but would be rather overwhelming. So it must be really far away."

(present-day Grey) Still, the model gets into your head in ways you don't notice and lets you ask imprecise questions, easily, but insufficiently answered. The result is something that's retroactively obvious can hide for a long time. The fact about Mercury being the closest on average feels like something Newton could have noticed. But it wasn't published until this year. Which is crazy. It's a property of concentric circles.

(Something Pythagoras, were he not so obsessed with triangles, might have noticed.) So, I love this fact about Mercury being the closest planet (depending on exactly what you mean by closest) because it’s a fantastic example of how if you can get rid of old or incorrect models from your head and think clearly in a way to ask a precise question, the universe awaits with new knowledge for you to find. Isn't that great?

[soft ambient music]

More Articles

View All
Chromosome pairs | Inheritance and variation | Middle school biology | Khan Academy
[Instructor] - Hi, everyone. Today, we’re gonna talk about chromosome pairs. But first, I’ve got a question for you. Between a black mulberry plant, a Guinea pig, and a human being, which organism do you think has the most chromosomes? The mulberry plan…
Warren Buffett: 90 Years of Wisdom Summed up in 16 Minutes
And yeah, Ben Franklin did this and my old boss Ben Graham did this at early ages in their young teens. They just—Ben Graham looked around and he said, “Who do I admire?” You know, and he wanted to be admired himself. He said, “You know, why do I admire t…
Mild and medium tension | Forces and Newton's laws of motion | Physics | Khan Academy
You bought a huge canister aluminum can of super hot red peppers, 3 Kg worth, and you hung them from two strings from the ceiling ‘cause you don’t want anyone to get your super hot red peppers. You wanted to know what’s the tension in both of these string…
50 Very Short Rules to Achieve Your Biggest Goals
In this Sunday motivational video, we’re going through 50 very short rules that are mandatory to know if you are to ever going to achieve your biggest goals. Let’s get started: Know what your goals are. Unless you have a clear idea of where you’re going,…
Our Fight Against Death | Origins: The Journey of Humankind
Humanity’s struggle against death has been our most enduring fight. History has given us one weapon in this existential battle: we fight back with medicine. Tens of thousands of years ago, our ancestors scavenged the natural world for remedies. Imagine th…
The Race to Save Big Cats | National Geographic
Cheetah are in a race for survival. There are maybe just 7,000 adult cheetah left in the wild. I’ve covered the illegal trafficking networks draining the Horn of Africa of their cheetah. They also face massive habitat loss and retaliatory killings by herd…