yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

The Poverty of Compromise


3m read
·Nov 3, 2024

This idea of questioning things that he, the two you thought were unassailable in a particular domain, for millennia people were wondering about the best way to conceive of what democracy is.

Even Plato had this idea of what is democracy, and he had the question about who should rule. That's the whole idea of democracy; supposedly, we'd have to figure out who should rule. Should it be the philosophy kings who should rule? Should it be the population of citizens? He decided that a mob would readily vote away the rights of a minority; that's what he thought democracy was.

But Papa questioned this whole idea of looking at what democracy was. He went even deeper and said democracy has got nothing to do with who should rule. Democracy is the system which allows you to remove policies and rulers most efficiently, without violence. That's how you judge different democratic systems.

So you can actually make a judgment on France, England, the United States, Canada. These places have better or worse kinds of democracy. We might all call them democracy, but to the extent that we're actually able to get rid of the people that we don't like from the democratic system quickly, efficiently, easily, without violence, that's the measure of a good democratic system.

Rather than trying to figure out which system's going to give us the best rulers, that's the same mistake as saying what method of science is going to give us the true theory. No method of science is going to give us the true theory; science is an error-correcting mechanism. All we can hope for is to get rid of the bad ideas, and by doing that, we've corrected some of our errors, and then we can move forward to find something that's a better theory than what we had before.

This actually raises the idea of how to make good decisions when you're at loggerheads with someone else. This idea that compromise is supposed to be a virtue of some kind, and it's not. It's preferable to having a violent confrontation if you've got two people who otherwise can't possibly reach an agreement, and they're going to get into a battle of some sort.

But if you're in a situation where person A has idea X and person B has idea Y, the common understanding of what a compromise is, is it's somewhere between X and Y. Person A won't get everything they want, and person B won't get everything they want, so let's come up with a compromise; this is theory Z.

When that policy proves not to work, we shouldn't be surprised because neither person A or person B actually ever thought it was the best idea in the first place at all. They thought that X or Y was the correct idea. So when they implement Z, what happens when it fails is that no one learns anything.

Person A goes back to saying, "I always told you that X was the correct idea," and person B goes back to saying, "I always told you that idea Y was the best idea." So they haven't made any progress whatsoever. They've shown that Z is wrong, but no one ever thought that Z was correct in the first place.

So this is the poverty of compromise, and this is what you get in science at certain times. It's everywhere in politics as well.

More Articles

View All
How Many Things Are There?
Hey, Vsauce. Michael here. If you threw every single human alive today into the Grand Canyon, we would not fill it up. We could make a pile about this big. That’s it. That’s all of us. All 7.159 billion of us in one place. A species portrait. It kinda put…
Is a US Recession Really Coming Soon?
This video is sponsored by Seeking Alpha. Sign up to Seeking Alpha Premium using my link to score a 7-Day free trial and $25 off your annual subscription. Is the US really headed for a recession? A week ago, you probably saw the stock market take a decen…
why i stopped drinking alcohol
What’s up, Graham? It’s guys here. So I’ve recently noticed a growing trend among entrepreneurs, business owners, and even people here on YouTube who’ve started becoming more and more vocal about why they’ve stopped drinking alcohol. At first, I kind of j…
Beat frequency | Physics | Khan Academy
What’s up, everybody? I want to talk to you about beat frequency, and to do so, let me talk to you about this air displacement versus time graph. So this is going to give you the displacement of the air molecules for any time at a particular location. So…
Why your plans are failing and methods to schedule your day/week/month✏️🗓
If your plans are failing and if you’re always feeling like you’re behind of your schedule, your plans, whatever, and if you’re feeling like you don’t have enough time in a day, then this video might be for you. Hi guys, it’s me, Judy, your favorite, you…
Worked example: Measuring the energy content of foods using soda-can calorimetry | Khan Academy
Calorimetry refers to the measurement of heat flow, and in this worked example, we’re going to burn a marshmallow and find the energy content of the marshmallow. First, let’s look at this setup for our soda can calorimeter. So, our soda can has some wate…