yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

George Ought to Help


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

Imagine you have a friend called George. You've been friends since childhood. Although you're not as close as you were back then, you still see each other once in a while and get along very well. One day, you and George are approached by an old mutual friend, Oliver.

Oliver explains that he's had a run of bad luck and is raising money to cover tuition fees for his kids. You want to help Oliver out, so you give him some money. To your surprise, George doesn't offer Oliver any help. You try to persuade him, but it's no use.

Imagining yourself in this situation, do you think it's okay to threaten to use physical force against George to get him to do the right thing?

Now, imagine a slightly different situation. This time, a group of your friends take a vote. Six out of ten are in favor of threatening George to get him to help Oliver. Does this democratic process make it okay to threaten George?

One large change to the situation: This time, imagine that many thousands of people have democratically agreed that a group, who we'll call the agents, should do whatever is necessary to take money from George and give it to Oliver's family. The agents don't explicitly threaten George at first; all they do is send him a bill like everyone else.

Though George knows what will happen if he doesn't pay the bill. First, he'll get more letters demanding payment, and the bill will get bigger. Eventually, if he still doesn't pay, agents with guns will break into his house and take him away against his will. Almost everyone pays the bills without protest. They know the agents are prepared to use as much force as necessary to overpower him if he resists.

Do you think it's acceptable for the agents to threaten violence against George if he doesn't give his money towards helping Oliver's family? If we approve of state programs that redistribute wealth, we must also approve of threats of violence made against peaceful individuals, because this is how the funds are collected.

On the other hand, most of us feel uncomfortable about threatening peaceful people when we imagine having to make the threats ourselves. If we feel negatively towards the idea of threatening George personally, can we really be comfortable with the threats made against him by agents of the state?

Some people believe that voluntary interaction and spontaneous order are realistic and preferable alternatives to state coercion as a way of organizing society. Do a web search for some of these terms if you're interested in learning more.

More Articles

View All
Charlie Munger Explains Why Most Jobs Are A Waste Of Time
Well, if you got 30 people at headquarters and half of those are internal auditors, that is not the normal way of running a big company in America. And I what’s interesting about it is obviously we lose some advantages from big size, but we also lose cert…
A Fun, Animated History of the Reformation and the Man Who Started It All | Short Film Showcase
[Music] A most precise and nuanced look into the life of the man, legend, and visionary Martin Luther. One day, when Luther is 21 years old, he experiences something which will affect him for the rest of his life. Suddenly, a thunderstorm—a wild, violent…
A Fish Called Obama | Sea of Hope: America's Underwater Treasures
We were up at Cure, which is at the, uh, farthest island out in the chain. We were down at 300 feet in an area where we’ve documented every single fish. On this reef is a species known only from the Hawaiian Islands. It’s truly the most unique set of fish…
Divergent Minds
[ambient music playing] [Michael] Derek, have you ever watched Mind Field on YouTube? No, but I would like to watch it, Michael. [Michael] Okay. So Mind Field has a theme song that I’d love for you to listen to to see if you can play it for me on the p…
Shaping American national identity from 1890 to 1945 | AP US History | Khan Academy
[Instructor] In 1890, the United States was not exactly a major player on the world stage. It was an industrial behemoth, attracting immigrants from all over the world, but it was focused on its own internal growth, not foreign affairs. There was little i…
15 Things to Prioritize in Life
Your life sucks because you don’t understand what makes life suck less. Because of evolutionary pressures, humans are designed to deal with the most imminent threats. But not everything urgent is important. If you get trapped in the pursuit of the urgent,…