yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

What is effective altruism? Philosopher Peter Singer explains.


3m read
·Nov 3, 2024

Processing might take a few minutes. Refresh later.

Back in the 1970s, I wrote an article called "Famine, Affluence, and Morality," which was encouraging us to be altruistic and suggested that if we were affluent, then morality required that we help people to some degree.

So, I used the story of rescuing a drowning child in a shallow pond. I said that if you saw such a child, and you were the only person there to stop the child drowning, but you didn't do it because you were wearing expensive clothes you didn't want to ruin, that would be a horrible thing to do. But if you agree that that's a horrible thing to do when the child is in front of you, then what about when the child isn't in front of you? If it is in a different country, but you can still be very confident that your donation will help them?

The article got widely reprinted in a lot of philosophy anthologies, so it got used in a lot of classrooms. Among those philosophy students were Toby Ord and Will McCaskill. They both read the article, and they were interested in altruism. From very small beginnings, they built up this effective altruism movement, which is now a global movement. It has followers in many, many countries and has been responsible for moving billions of dollars into more effective causes.

Effective altruism suggests that if you are going to be altruistic, then you should try to be as effective as you can with what you're doing.

Our species evolved in circumstances when hard times were unpredictable. There might be droughts and famines, so it was good to increase our order of food if we wanted to survive. Somehow, the genes for doing that remain in us. I'm not against people putting things away in case things get economically tougher, but we can do that with some of our wealth, and we can be quite confident that we'll have enough. We may still have more even beyond what we need to prepare for the future.

Zelkovinsky was an interesting man who had an ability to make money from real estate investments, but he didn't really want the money. He was quite comfortable living with his family in a suburban home near Philadelphia, so he decided that he would give almost all of it away. Zel decided to start looking at the possibility of donating a kidney. He went to a hospital in Philadelphia and told them that he wanted to donate a kidney to a stranger, and they looked at him as if he was a bit crazy.

Eventually, he did persuade them that he would like to donate the kidney to just the next person in line who was compatible. On his estimate, it was only a one in four thousand chance that donating a kidney would lead to his premature death. His kidney saved a life, and he thinks that if he hadn't done that, he would have been valuing his own life at four thousand times that of a stranger.

The term effective altruism actually is something that developed after Zelkovinsky had donated both his money and his kidney. Although he certainly is way out there as an outlier, it does describe what he did.

So whatever your resources are, they might be money, they might be time, they might even be one of your kidneys. But if you are going to donate something like that, make sure it does the most good that it can. Don't waste it.

We all have this attitude to everyday purchases. If your phone has died and you need a new phone, you're going to ask around or go online. If you came home and showed your phone to a friend, and your friend said, "How much did you pay for that?" and you tell them, they say, "What? I could have got that for you for half the price!" You'd feel pretty stupid.

But strangely, that attitude doesn't apply to charities. If you go and give your money to a charity, let's say it's a charity that's raising guide dogs for blind people, and you don't do research before you do that, you don't ask, "Is there some other way I could help blind people that would help more people for less money?" If you did ask that, you would find that giving money for guide dogs is not the best value for your money because it costs a lot of money to raise a guide dog. It costs about forty thousand dollars in the US. It's a good thing to do, but you can restore sight in someone who has...

More Articles

View All
Constructing scatterplots | Representing data | Grade 5 (TX TEKS) | Khan Academy
We’re told that Kendrick drinks juice while he drives to work each day. He recorded the amount of juice he drinks in milliliters and how long, in minutes, his drive took. For his drive this week, he recorded this for five days. So, they give us a little …
Organism growth and the environment | Middle school biology | Khan Academy
Hey, have you ever seen this kind of plant before? It’s called a dandelion. If you live in a tropical climate, it might be unfamiliar, but if you live in a more temperate zone, you’ll probably recognize it, as it’s a very common plant. Dandelions make yel…
5 Good Philosophies To Live By
Pay attention to what we’re about to tell you now because this is really important. There are many ways in which you can experience life, but not all of them will bring the same amount of joy, peace, and fulfillment when the game is finally over. In fact,…
John Gotti Sr.'s Rise to Power | Narco Wars: The Mob
[music playing] - It’s snowing out, a little snowing, white Christmas. - I know it’s going to happen any day now. So the plan that they came up with was rather ingenious. They decided to take Paul Castellano out by luring him to one of his favorite resta…
The 5 MOST PROFITABLE Savings Accounts of 2019
What’s the guys, it’s Graham here. So I made this video about six months ago where I went over the most profitable savings accounts that you can get. Since then, in the last few months, I’ve received non-stop messages that the information is now outdated.…
The Fastest Maze-Solving Competition On Earth
[Derek] This tiny robot mouse can finish this maze in just six seconds. (dramatic music) Every year, around the world, people compete in the oldest robotics race. The goal is simple: get to the end of the maze as fast as possible. The person who came sec…