yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

The Real Moral Dilemma of Self-Driving Cars


3m read
·Nov 10, 2024

Push this button. It's driving itself. It feels good. So, BMW brought me to the Consumer Electronics Show here in Las Vegas. I'm going to check out the future of driving. Did I get it? Am I near? [unintelligible] Oh! I felt it! That really felt like pushing a button.

In this concept car, there's a holographic menu screen. It works by projecting an image above this panel. And then it uses this camera in the steering column to determine where your finger is. And when it detects your fingers in the right spot, it uses ultrasound from these speakers to provide haptic feedback - you can actually feel it in your fingers. It's like a little buzzing.

But what I really want to try is NOT driving. I can actually talk to the camera. Are you sure that this is a good idea? So here's a question: How much should you trust an autonomous car? This car is now driving itself. But I need to be able to take over at any time. I'm still legally responsible if something happens to the car, right?

But, in the coming years, cars are going to take over more and more of the responsibility for driving safely. And that has led a lot of people to consider the moral dilemmas faced when programming self-driving cars. The question is what sort of ethical framework should we program in through autonomous vehicles. So it needs to make a decision. Swerve left into an SUV or swerve right into a motorcycle.

Okay, so we can imagine a lot of weird situations where an autonomous car has to make a tough choice. But the real moral dilemma is accidents are happening right now. More than 30,000 people are killed each year in the U.S. alone. And more than 2 million are injured. And the problem in 94% of collisions is driver error.

In 2015, half of all traffic fatalities occurred on highways. So even this level of technology we've demonstrated today - autonomous driving on a highway - could save a lot of lives. We are already shirking our responsibility for driving cars. We are using our phones. In 2014, distracted driving resulted in at least 3,000 killed and 430,000 injured.

So, if we're not driving, we better hope that the tech gets to a level where the cars can drive for us. My view: this problem is only going to get worse. You know, when elevators became autonomous, a lot of people were uncomfortable with that. They were used to there being a driver in the elevator, so compromises had to be made, like big red stop buttons just to make people comfortable.

And a nice soothing voice to say, "Which floor would you like to go to?" Now, I know that elevators have many fewer degrees of freedom than a car, but even if you look at something like airplanes, airplanes flying in full autonomous mode are actually safer - studies show - than when pilots can take control.

I think the moral dilemmas over exactly how cars should react in a tiny percentage of cases where tough choices need to be made is a distraction from the main problem. The longer we wait to get autonomous vehicles on the road, the more people will die. And that is the real moral question of autonomous cars. Why aren't we getting them on the road faster?

I hope you enjoyed the ride. That was cool. Now let's head back for the CES. Perfect.

More Articles

View All
MMOs in the Instagram Era: Highrise (S18) - YC Gaming Tech Talks 2020
Um, hi everybody! I’m Jimmy, I’m the co-founder and CTO of Pocket Worlds. We’re High-Rise, and we built High-Rise, the app which is available on iOS and Android. I think to date, it has over 5 million downloads, and we’re grossing over a million a month i…
How to build a relationship with your buyers.
Right now, you have the two ADXs, two ox, one’s matte and one’s shiny inside. How much you think you’re flying each of them? 350 each? That’s a pretty good usage on those airplanes as they’re mostly flying around. I have a brother who lives in it, goes t…
Impose | Vocabulary | Khan Academy
Hey there wordsmiths! This video is about the word impose. Impose, it’s a verb, and it means to force something onto others, kind of like how I impose my taste in music on you in these videos. You didn’t ask for this; I just put it on to you, which is in…
Chimú 101 | National Geographic
(Gentle music) [Narrator] Before the Spanish conquest and before the Inca empire, one group created the most important South American civilization at the time, the Chimu. The Chimu civilization lasted almost half a millennium, from the year 1000 to aroun…
Fireside Chat with Ivana Djuretic of Asher Bio
Welcome back! Next, we have a fireside chat with YC’s Jared Friedman and Ivana Dreadich. Yeah, let’s give them both a big round of applause! Ivana is the founder and founding CEO of Asher Bio. Uh, before we get started, go ahead and take a seat. But befo…
Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) | Biomolecules | MCAT | Khan Academy
I’m here with Emily, our biology content fellow, to talk about PCR or polymerase chain reaction, which you’ve actually done a lot of. Why have you done PCR? PCR was kind of the mainstay of my graduate project, where I built all sorts of different recomb…