yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

The Real Moral Dilemma of Self-Driving Cars


3m read
·Nov 10, 2024

Push this button. It's driving itself. It feels good. So, BMW brought me to the Consumer Electronics Show here in Las Vegas. I'm going to check out the future of driving. Did I get it? Am I near? [unintelligible] Oh! I felt it! That really felt like pushing a button.

In this concept car, there's a holographic menu screen. It works by projecting an image above this panel. And then it uses this camera in the steering column to determine where your finger is. And when it detects your fingers in the right spot, it uses ultrasound from these speakers to provide haptic feedback - you can actually feel it in your fingers. It's like a little buzzing.

But what I really want to try is NOT driving. I can actually talk to the camera. Are you sure that this is a good idea? So here's a question: How much should you trust an autonomous car? This car is now driving itself. But I need to be able to take over at any time. I'm still legally responsible if something happens to the car, right?

But, in the coming years, cars are going to take over more and more of the responsibility for driving safely. And that has led a lot of people to consider the moral dilemmas faced when programming self-driving cars. The question is what sort of ethical framework should we program in through autonomous vehicles. So it needs to make a decision. Swerve left into an SUV or swerve right into a motorcycle.

Okay, so we can imagine a lot of weird situations where an autonomous car has to make a tough choice. But the real moral dilemma is accidents are happening right now. More than 30,000 people are killed each year in the U.S. alone. And more than 2 million are injured. And the problem in 94% of collisions is driver error.

In 2015, half of all traffic fatalities occurred on highways. So even this level of technology we've demonstrated today - autonomous driving on a highway - could save a lot of lives. We are already shirking our responsibility for driving cars. We are using our phones. In 2014, distracted driving resulted in at least 3,000 killed and 430,000 injured.

So, if we're not driving, we better hope that the tech gets to a level where the cars can drive for us. My view: this problem is only going to get worse. You know, when elevators became autonomous, a lot of people were uncomfortable with that. They were used to there being a driver in the elevator, so compromises had to be made, like big red stop buttons just to make people comfortable.

And a nice soothing voice to say, "Which floor would you like to go to?" Now, I know that elevators have many fewer degrees of freedom than a car, but even if you look at something like airplanes, airplanes flying in full autonomous mode are actually safer - studies show - than when pilots can take control.

I think the moral dilemmas over exactly how cars should react in a tiny percentage of cases where tough choices need to be made is a distraction from the main problem. The longer we wait to get autonomous vehicles on the road, the more people will die. And that is the real moral question of autonomous cars. Why aren't we getting them on the road faster?

I hope you enjoyed the ride. That was cool. Now let's head back for the CES. Perfect.

More Articles

View All
Do We Have Free Will? | Robert Sapolsky & Andrew Huberman
Speaker A: - Along the lines of choice, I’d like to shift gears slightly and talk about free will, about our ability to make choices at all. Speaker B: - Well, my personal way out in left field inflammatory stance is I don’t think we have a shred of free…
Underwater Snow Mobile | The Boonies
Any luck over there? Nope, no snowmobile yet. Maybe a rock and a log, 18 miles from the mainland, far outside the grid. Dan Burton is attempting to salvage a sunken snowmobile from the bottom of Lake Michigan. “I’m sure it’s here! I don’t see anybody bea…
How to recognize relative and absolute maxima and minima | Functions | Algebra I | Khan Academy
We’re asked to mark all the relative extremum points in the graph below. So pause the video and see if you can have a go at that. Just try to maybe look at the screen and in your head see if you can identify the relative extrema. So now let’s do this tog…
Michael Burry: The 'Greatest Bubble of All Time' Just Burst (recent tweets explained)
The quote “greatest bubble of all time has started to burst, and it’s not done yet,” according to Michael Burry. Burry made his name correctly predicting the crash of the US housing market during the lead-up to the global financial crisis. This crash was …
The Car Market Bubble Just Popped
What’s up you guys, it’s Graham here. So first of all, I got to say I am shocked that more people aren’t talking about this because we’re facing a huge problem in the used car market, and honestly, it’s a disaster waiting to happen. Like, we all know tha…
What Exactly is the Present?
At the 1939 world’s fair in New York, the exciting new tech was the live television broadcast. Roosevelt became the first president to address the nation live on TV. But for years leading up to this event, engineers have been working on one particular tec…