yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Pessimism Appears to Be the Intellectually Serious Position


2m read
·Nov 3, 2024

If you're an academic of some kind, then being able to explain all of the problems that are out there and how dangerous these problems are, and why you need funding in order to look at these problems in more depth, that appears to be the intellectually serious position. Someone who claims that we can solve this sounds a little bit kumbaya. Even though it's quite right that, in fact, collaboration, cooperation, and resource exploitation will actually be the thing that's going to drive this knowledge economy forward so that we can solve these problems.

It always seems more intellectually serious if you can stand up there with a frown on your face in front of a TED Talk audience and say, "These are all the ways in which we're going to fail and which we're going to come to ruin." I'm guilty of having recorded one of these doomsayer podcasts about enders blowing up the earth, but that was the one podcast that I regretted the most. We had a great conversation, but I don't fundamentally agree with any of the conclusions that might come out of that, which say the world is going to end, so we should slow down. The only way out is through progress.

Subsequently, I haven't promoted it as much as I promoted my other podcast, and upon reading Deutsch, I realize why. It's because it's easy to be a pessimist; it's an easy trap to fall into, but it implies that humans are not creative. It doesn't acknowledge all the ways that we have innovated our way out of previous traps. Fundamentally, entrepreneurs are inherently optimistic because they get rewarded for being optimistic. As you're saying, intellectuals get rewarded for being pessimistic.

So, there is always a lot of incentive bias here. As an academic, you may be incented to be pessimistic; as an entrepreneur, you may be incented to be optimistic. If you're a pessimist, you get your feedback from other people. It's a social act; you're convincing other people of your pessimism. So far, most of their pessimistic predictions have turned out to be false. If you look at any timelines on which the world was supposed to end or environmental catastrophes were supposed to happen, they've been quite wrong.

But if you look at the optimistic entrepreneurs, they are rated by feedback from nature and free markets, which I believe are much more realistic feedback mechanisms.

More Articles

View All
Congruent shapes and transformations
We’re told Cassandra was curious if triangle ABC and triangle GFE were congruent, so he tried to map one figure onto the other using a rotation. So, let’s see. This is triangle ABC, and it looks like at first he rotates triangle ABC about point C to get i…
The Bermuda Triangle: Shrouded in Mystery
What began as a regular training session on the afternoon of the 5th of December 1945 would soon become one of the greatest mysteries of the human world: Flight 19. A group of five U.S. Navy torpedo bombers set out from their base off the coast of Florida…
Graphing a shifted and stretched absolute value function
So we’re asked to graph ( f(x) = 2 \times |x + 3| + 2 ). And what they’ve already graphed for us, this right over here, is the graph of ( y = |x| ). Let’s do this through a series of transformations. So the next thing I want to graph, let’s see if we ca…
DoorDash at YC Summer 2013 Demo Day
Hi, we’re DoorDash, and we enable every restaurant to deliver for customers. We offer restaurant food delivery in under 45 minutes, and for restaurant owners, we provide our own drivers and manage the logistics of delivery. Now, you might think that food…
Hiroshima Photo Walk | National Geographic
My name is David Gutenfelder, and I’m a photographer with National Geographic magazine. I’m here on assignment with Mazda in Hiroshima, Japan. I’m a true believer in the power of photography. I want people to see my photographs, and I want them to be tran…
Interactive Innovations | Epcot Becoming Episode 3 | National Geographic
We’re pushing technology within our ride systems, showing that we can create amazing things together. Frozen Ever After was really the first attraction to use all electric motor audio animatronics figures. Traditionally, all of the audio animatronics figu…