yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Abolishing sweatshops would hurt the poor


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

So I've been banned from Hensley's channel, so I have to conduct this conversation here.

If I can, Shoot 06 said, "What's wrong with prostitution in the industrialized world?"

Hemsley replied, "It's fed by women from the poorest parts of the world because women with more options don't do it."

I said, "And you're advocating removing one of the few options open to desperate women? Exactly how do you believe that helps them?"

Hemsley said, "Yeah, we should let sweatshops be legal too because they help desperate people."

I think he was being sarcastic. I said, "Correct, yes, they do, and despite our distaste for them, removing that option hurts people rather than helps them."

M Hensley said, "Oh, off you fascist! You're getting cheap shit by using slave labor; does not help them. You ask, um..."

And then he blocked me.

So, just a definitional point to start with: a sweatshop is a place of work, usually in the developing world. According to current Western standards, working conditions in sweatshops are bad, and the wage of sweatshop workers is low.

Slavery is the claim to ownership of a person; it's enforced by using force to prevent the person from leaving. So, sweatshops are not examples of slavery since people choose to work in them. They can choose to stop working in them, and force will not be used to prevent them from leaving.

M Hensley believes that actions should be evaluated solely on the basis of their effect on society as a whole. Hensley apparently believes that eliminating sweatshops would somehow help society. I think the portion of society that M Hensley would particularly like to help are workers.

Yet, abolishing sweatshops would actually hurt workers, and we can demonstrate this very simply.

So, what jobs are currently staffed? That is, we know that people have demonstrated a preference to work in sweatshops over the alternative futures they saw for themselves. From this, we can infer that of the choices open to any sweatshop worker, they judged working in a sweatshop to be the option that helped them the most—the option that was least objectionable. They preferred working in a sweatshop to the alternatives.

And since we don't like the idea of working in a sweatshop ourselves, we can get a sense of just how undesirable the rejected alternatives must have been.

By eliminating sweatshops, you remove one of the options available to the world's poorest people. You effectively say, "Because I don't think people should work in sweatshops, you must now choose an even less desirable cost for your future."

This is inexcusably arrogant paternalism that hurts exactly those people who it professes to want to help.

More Articles

View All
Encryption and public keys | Internet 101 | Computer Science | Khan Academy
[Music] Hi, my name is Mia Gilner. I’m majoring in computer science at UC Berkeley, and I work for the Department of Defense where I try to keep information safe. The internet is an open and public system. We all send and receive information over shared …
Answering Google's Most Asked Questions of 2023
We can learn a lot about ourselves and the state of the world through our Google searches. What we ask the internet is not only a reflection of what we want to know, but also what we desire and fear. In 2023, people search for everything from deep questi…
Worked example finding area under density curves | AP Statistics | Khan Academy
Consider the density curve below. This density curve doesn’t look like the ones we typically see that are a little bit curvier, but this is a little easier for us to work with and figure out areas. They ask us to find the percent of the area under the de…
3 Ways the World Order is Changing
I’m desperately trying to pass along, uh, my thoughts to help you to understand how the world order is changing. Um, and it’s changing in three very important ways. It’s changing financially and economically in important ways that you could see. It’s chan…
Differentiating polynomials example | Derivative rules | AP Calculus AB | Khan Academy
So I have the function f of X here, and we’re defining it using a polynomial expression. What I would like to do here is take the derivative of our function, which is essentially going to make us take a derivative of this polynomial expression, and we’re …
Crossing the Creek - Deleted Scene | Life Below Zero
So I came down, I’m crossing the valley, and I want to go up on this mountain here next. This is another mountain I’m thinking about hunting on, and I want to see if there are any sheep up there today. I’m just going to have to cross this little creek her…