yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

There is no axiomatic proof of property rights


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

Uh, to avoid confusion, I'll preface this by saying that, um, I'm personally strongly in favor of property rights and their enforcement. So if you're new to my channel, please bear that in mind.

Uh, Stefan Molyneux made a video a while back attempting to offer an axiomatic proof of the existence of property rights. Recently, I made a video where I explained why the phrase "property is theft" is an example of the stolen concept fallacy. A couple of comments made to that video referenced Stefan Molyneux's arguments that a denial of property rights is, in his words, a self-detonating claim.

So the idea is that there is a performative inconsistency involved in expressing the claim "property rights don't exist." Um, so in Molyneux's video, a proof of property rights, Stefan lays out the steps involved in his argument. At one point, uh, he considers the claim "self-ownership is invalid," and his argument depends on rejecting this claim.

So he rejects the claim for the following reason. Um, talking about the person making a claim, he says he is exercising control over his own body to argue that it is impossible to exercise control over his body.

Now, this is a very, there's a very peculiar assumption behind this. Um, for that phrase to be a fair unpacking of the claim "self-ownership is invalid," we need to be defining legitimate ownership of thing X as the ability to exercise control over thing X. Um, and this is a very unusual way of defining property.

Nowhere that I've seen in libertarian writing, or in any other writing for that matter, have I seen property defined this way. If we were to define property in this way, it would have implications that I don't think Molyneux would accept. It would mean, for instance, that if a torturer, um, was able to induce a particular kind of movement in the arm of his victim, it would mean that the torturer was the legitimate owner of the arm.

After all, he would be controlling the arm. It would also mean that if a state official were to seize your laptop and look through your files against your will, then the official would be the legitimate owner of the laptop, uh, since he would be exercising control over it, while you, who had bought the laptop, were not. And the list goes on.

So the definition of property that Molyneux is implicitly depending on, or maybe even explicitly depending on, uh, makes no distinction between legitimate ownership and possession, which is a big blunder in my view. So I think Molyneux fails to demonstrate that the claim property rights exist is a claim that is schematically true. Uh, there's no performative inconsistency involved in the denial of property rights.

More Articles

View All
Understand Where YOU are in the Life Cycle
There’s a life cycle of an individual, so I want to just touch on that for a bit. To me, the life cycle of a typical individual looks like this: In the first phase, you learn, and you’re dependent on others who guide you, most importantly your parents an…
How to Improve Your Life in 24 HOURS
[Music] If you’ve ever browsed self-improvement forums like on Reddit, then you’ll often come across some pretty good advice, some pretty questionable stuff—no doubt. But every once in a while, there’s a little nugget of wisdom that sticks with you, and …
Biased and unbiased estimators from sampling distributions examples
Alejandro was curious if sample median was an unbiased estimator of population median. He placed ping-pong balls numbered from zero to 32 in a drum and mixed them well. Note that the median of the population is 16. He then took a random sample of five bal…
Road Trip to the Sawtooth Mountains | National Geographic
[Sofia] Nature and family have always existed within the same worlds for me. My name is Sofia Jaramillo. I’m a National Geographic photographer. I’m going on a road trip with my brother Lucas. Good to see you! [Sofia] To a place that was really importan…
The Most Important Personality Trait You Need to Build
Pay attention! Okay, because this fact will blow your mind. Did you know that 99.9% of all the species that have ever lived on Earth are now extinct? So, how about the 0.01% that survived? Well, a key factor that determined their survival was their abilit…
The Moon
When you look at the Moon in the night sky, it might seem reasonably close, but it’s actually incredibly far away. Right over here is a scaled picture of the distance between the Earth and the Moon. Earth has a diameter of approximately 8,000 miles, while…