yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

There is no axiomatic proof of property rights


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

Uh, to avoid confusion, I'll preface this by saying that, um, I'm personally strongly in favor of property rights and their enforcement. So if you're new to my channel, please bear that in mind.

Uh, Stefan Molyneux made a video a while back attempting to offer an axiomatic proof of the existence of property rights. Recently, I made a video where I explained why the phrase "property is theft" is an example of the stolen concept fallacy. A couple of comments made to that video referenced Stefan Molyneux's arguments that a denial of property rights is, in his words, a self-detonating claim.

So the idea is that there is a performative inconsistency involved in expressing the claim "property rights don't exist." Um, so in Molyneux's video, a proof of property rights, Stefan lays out the steps involved in his argument. At one point, uh, he considers the claim "self-ownership is invalid," and his argument depends on rejecting this claim.

So he rejects the claim for the following reason. Um, talking about the person making a claim, he says he is exercising control over his own body to argue that it is impossible to exercise control over his body.

Now, this is a very, there's a very peculiar assumption behind this. Um, for that phrase to be a fair unpacking of the claim "self-ownership is invalid," we need to be defining legitimate ownership of thing X as the ability to exercise control over thing X. Um, and this is a very unusual way of defining property.

Nowhere that I've seen in libertarian writing, or in any other writing for that matter, have I seen property defined this way. If we were to define property in this way, it would have implications that I don't think Molyneux would accept. It would mean, for instance, that if a torturer, um, was able to induce a particular kind of movement in the arm of his victim, it would mean that the torturer was the legitimate owner of the arm.

After all, he would be controlling the arm. It would also mean that if a state official were to seize your laptop and look through your files against your will, then the official would be the legitimate owner of the laptop, uh, since he would be exercising control over it, while you, who had bought the laptop, were not. And the list goes on.

So the definition of property that Molyneux is implicitly depending on, or maybe even explicitly depending on, uh, makes no distinction between legitimate ownership and possession, which is a big blunder in my view. So I think Molyneux fails to demonstrate that the claim property rights exist is a claim that is schematically true. Uh, there's no performative inconsistency involved in the denial of property rights.

More Articles

View All
Ridiculously Easy DIY Light Strips! (no soldering)
I want to change my bathroom from this to this. The problem is I want it to not cost a lot, be high quality, and be easy. I mean, is that even possible? Well, after trying out many different options and almost failing multiple times, I finally found a gre…
Bloodwood: Rosewood Trafficking Is Destroying This National Park | National Geographic
Cambodia was once cloaked with forests. This is what it looks like today: more than half of the country’s trees have been clear-cut. Foreign appetites for red timbers are driving the destruction, and none is prized more than this Siamese rosewood. In Chin…
Innovative | Vocabulary | Khan Academy
Ah, hello wordsmiths! You found me in my workshop, coining new words— a little soldering, a little welding, and there you are, a brand new word! Let’s take it out of the forge and see what I’ve made. Oh, well, this word already exists—it’s Innovative. In…
Sal Discusses the Safety of Reopening Schools on the Situation Room With Wolf Blitzer
Doctor, when the CDC Director, Robert Redfield, says these new guidelines are meant to facilitate the opening of schools around the country, not keep them closed. Based on your reading of these new guidelines, do you think they accomplish that goal? Well…
How Wildlife Overcame South Georgia's Haunting Past — Ep. 5 | Wildlife: Resurrection Island
When this place was in full swing, a cloud of smoke covered the skies. 300 men toiled as thousands of whales lost their lives in Salieri. But who started this, and how did we get to the point of nearly exterminating the wildlife from this island? How is i…
Blacksmith for Barter | Live Free or Die
Gonna be a hot one today in the mountains of Colorado. Primitive blacksmith Derik fires up his forge to nearly 2500 degrees, the ideal temperature to mold iron. Today I’m gonna continue working on my camp set, try to finish that out—four more pieces beca…