yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

How Government Solved the Health Care Crisis - Animation


4m read
·Nov 8, 2024

Today, the United States faces a health care crisis. Medical costs are too high, and health insurance is out of reach for the poor. The cure is obvious to nearly everybody: government must step in to solve the problem.

Eighty years ago, Americans were also told that their nation was facing a health care crisis. Back then, the complaint was that medical costs were too low, and that health insurance was too accessible. But in that era, too, government stepped forward to solve the problem. And boy, did they solve it!

In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, one of the primary sources of health care and health insurance for the working poor in Britain, Australia, and the United States, was the fraternal society. Fraternal societies (or "friendly societies" in Britain and Australia) were voluntary mutual-aid associations. Over one-quarter of all American adults were members of fraternal societies in 1920. Fraternal societies were particularly popular among blacks and immigrants.

A fraternal society was a group of working-class people who formed an association and paid monthly fees into the association's fund; individual members would then be able to draw on the pooled resources in times of need. There were a great many societies to choose from. Their most commonly offered services were life insurance, disability insurance, and lodge practice. Lodge practice meant that the lodge would retain a doctor to provide medical care to its members.

Members would pay a yearly fee and then call on the doctor's services as needed. If members were unhappy with the doctor, the contract might not be renewed. Most remarkable was the low cost at which these medical services were provided. At the turn of the century, an average worker’s daily wage would pay for a year's worth of medical care, much cheaper than on the regular market.

Yet licensed physicians competed vigorously for lodge contracts, perhaps because of the security they offered. This competition kept members’ costs low. The response of the medical establishment, both in America and in Britain, was one of outrage; many saw it as a blow to the dignity of the profession that trained physicians should be eagerly bidding for the chance to serve lower-class tradesmen.

Such low fees, many doctors complained, were bankrupting the medical profession. Socially inferior people were setting physicians' fees and sitting in judgment to determine whether their services had been satisfactory! They demanded that the government must do something. And so it did.

In Britain, state-financed medical care crowded out lodge practice; a working-class person, now being forced to pay taxes for "free" health care, was very unlikely to also pay for health care through the fraternal societies. In America, a similar process unfolded. Medical associations like the AMA had been granted the political privilege of control over the medical licensure procedure.

The associations used this power to impose sanctions on doctors who dared to sign lodge practice contracts. Doctors could be denied the use of hospital facilities or expelled from the association. The effort to destroy lodge practice even extended to denying emergency medical care to lodge members.

The AMA also made the requirements for getting a medical license much stricter, ostensibly to raise the quality of medical care. But the result was that the vast pool of physicians bidding for lodge practice contracts disappeared. This artificial restriction on the supply of medical care dramatically reduced competition, which resulted in higher prices. This hit the working-class lodge members especially hard.

The final blow to lodge practice was struck by the fraternal societies themselves. The National Fraternal Congress successfully lobbied government for laws setting a legal minimum on membership fees that fraternal societies could charge. Perhaps the congress did so hoping to benefit from cartel pricing, but thanks to the higher membership fees, the societies ended up losing even more members to industrial insurance firms and the welfare state, which eventually replaced them.

Collectively, government interventions destroyed the mutual aid health care system and with it, the availability of low-cost healthcare to the working poor. We can only guess at how lodge practice would have developed if it had been allowed to continue, and what innovations we’ve missed out on since competition in the medical world was hobbled.

One thing does seem clear: we have a crisis in health care costs today because government ‘solved’ the last one.

More Articles

View All
What Do You Miss the Most? - Q&A | Live Free or Die
[Music] I would say definitely the number one modern convenience that I really miss the most and that whenever I can take advantage of it I do is a shower. Some of the things I miss about living in society is a hot shower. I miss hot water. I miss showers…
The One Ring Explained
These books are all about this ring. How it’s found and [spoiler alert] how it’s destroyed. While Tolkien built the largest and most consistent fictional universe, he sure didn’t mind being vague at times. So, if you finished the story and then thought: w…
Don’t Buy A Home In 2023 (Sellers Panicking)
Americans are leaving California and New York in droves. People are getting fed up and moving to Arizona, Nevada, Texas, or Florida. The main reason why is money. What’s up, Graham? It’s guys here. So for the first time ever, the housing market is being c…
Announcing ThinkerCon! - A Celebration of Online Educational Content
Announcing ThinkerCon! Remember several years ago, five of us educational content creators got together, and we did this live event. It was really fun, but people came from like 40 states and 12 different nations for it. So, clearly, there’s a lot of dema…
Mr. Freeman, part 32
My every word waking within you a series of very thoughtful… You know how it seems? I say, “People, your bread is finished, need to buy bread.” You’re goggled, your eyes with open mouth, your eyes popping out with terror, and I hear your screams… BREAD!!!…
STRAPPED INTO A FALLING HELICOPTER - Smarter Every Day 154
Hey, it’s me, Destin. Welcome back to Smarter Every Day. One of the reasons I absolutely love helicopters is that you can get places that you can’t with any other device. So today, I’m with Bradley Friesen here in… where? Bradley: We’re, uh, right now in…