yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

The Simple Solution to Traffic


4m read
·Oct 28, 2024

Stuck at an intersection, you always watch unfold the Fundamental Problem of Traffic. On green, the first car accelerates, and then the next, and then the next, and then the next, and then you, only to catch the red. Had the cars accelerated simultaneously, you would have made it through. Coordination—not cars—is the problem, because we are monkey drivers with slow reaction times and short attention spans. Even if we tried getting everyone to press the pedal on "3-2-1-now," it would be challenging. This dis-coordination limits how many cars can get through an intersection, and when one backs up to the next, that's when city-sized gridlock cascades happen, taking forever to clear.

In general, more intersections equal more dis-coordination, which equals more traffic. This is the motive behind big highways: no intersections. Splits and merges, yes. Intersections, no. No stopping, no coordination problems, no traffic. Well, that's the theory anyway. Intersections outside of a highway will back up onto it. Again, because human reaction times limit how many cars can escape the off-ramp when the light changes. But, even without intersections, there would still be traffic on the highway. Traffic can just appear.

Take a one-lane highway with happy cars flowing until a chicken crosses the road. The driver who sees it brakes a little, the driver behind him doesn't notice immediately and brakes a little harder than necessary. The driver behind him does the same until someone comes to a complete stop, and, oh look, cars approaching at highway speeds must now stop as well. Though the chicken is long gone, it left a phantom intersection on the highway. This is what's happened when you're stuck in traffic for hours thinking, "There must be a deadly pile-up ahead," and then suddenly, the traffic's over with no wreckage in sight, to your relief if you're a good person and mild annoyance if you aren't.

You just pass through a phantom intersection, the cause of which is long gone. And this phantom intersection moves. It's really a traffic snake slithering down the road, eating oncoming cars at one end and pooping them out the other. On a ring road, a single car slowing down will start an Ouroboros of traffic that will last forever, even though there's no problem with the road. If the drivers could coordinate to accelerate and separate simultaneously, easy driving would return. But they can't, so traffic eternal.

On highways, traffic snakes grow if cars are eaten faster than excreted, and they shrink if excreted faster than eaten, dying when the last car accelerates away before the next car must stop. Now, in multi-lane highways, there needs be no chicken to start gridlock. A driver crossing lanes quickly with cars too close behind is enough to birth a traffic snake that lives for hours and leagues. It's this quick crossing that causes drivers behind to over-brake and begin a chain reaction.

But we can make traffic snakes less likely by changing the way we drive. Your goal as a driver is to stay the same distance from the car ahead as from the car behind at all times. Tailgating is trouble. Not just because it makes accidents more likely but because you as the tailgater can start a traffic snake if the driver ahead brakes. Always in the middle! This gives you the most time to prevent over-braking but also gives the driver behind you the most time as well. And when stuck in traffic, this rule would get all cars to pull apart the snake faster.

That's the simple solution to traffic: getting humans to change their behavior, perhaps by sharing this video to show how and why traffic happens, why tailgaters are trouble, and how we can work together to make the roads better for all. The End. Except, yeah... wishing upon a star that people are better than they are is a terrible solution. Every time. Instead, what works is a structurally systematized solution which is exactly what self-driving cars are.

Self-driving cars can just be programmed to stay in the middle and accelerate simultaneously. They'll just do it. The more self-driving cars at an intersection, the more efficient the intersection gets. A solid lane of self-driving cars vastly increases throughput. Hmm, actually! If you ban humans from the road (which we should totally do anyway), you can get rid of the intersection entirely. After all, a traffic light is just a tool for drivers on one road to communicate with drivers on another, poorly and coarsely. Red equals "Don't go now, we are coming through the intersection." Green equals "good to go."

But self-driving cars can talk to each other at the speed of light. With that kind of coordination, no traffic light necessary. Just as with the highway, the best intersection is no intersection. Humans will never drive this precisely. At the intersection, the fundamental problem with traffic that you watch unfold, as well as everything, is people. So the real simple solution to traffic is no more monkeys driving cars.

This video has been brought to you in part by Audible.com, with over 180,000 audiobooks and spoken audio products. Get a free trial today by going to audible.com/grey. If you like thinking about how the future can be better, why not read the Elon Musk biography: "Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic Future" by Ashlee Vance? It is available at Audible. Give it a listen with your free 30-day trial that you can get at audible.com/grey. Audible is the place I go to for all of my audiobooks, and you should too. It's a near endless universe of interesting things to listen to. Give them a try and thanks to Audible for supporting the channel.

More Articles

View All
The Seventh Amendment | US government and civics | Khan Academy
Hi, this is Kim from Khan Academy. Today, we’re learning more about the Seventh Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. The Seventh Amendment guarantees the right to juries in civil cases when the value in controversy is greater than twenty dollars. To learn…
This Thing is Crazy Fast - Kodak Part 3- Smarter Every Day 286
Hey, it’s me, Destin. Welcome back to Smarter Every Day. This… [KA-CHUNK, KA CHUNK] [JET ENGINE NOISES] [CHU-KUH, CHU-KUH] [KER-FLOP] [DING!] is at the Kodak Film Factory in Rochester, New York. The fact that we get to film in the plant is amazing. This i…
The Dark Side of Wealth: The High Price of Success
Pay attention all right because what we’re about to say might contradict your entire belief of the system. Tryhards who seek wealth and success without caring about anything else will eventually end up alone and depressed. There are multiple reasons why a…
Sweetening the Deal | Yukon River Run
Saw y’all come in and wondered what the deal was in a town this far down river. 11 tons of lumber will get people’s attention in a hurry. What do you plan to do with it? We were planning to sell this raft and cow tag for cash money, and that’s where we’r…
Tracking users on the Internet | Internet safety | Khan Academy
So there’s a bunch of reasons why a website might want to track you, and depending on your opinion, you might think some of these are reasonable and you might think some of them are unreasonable. Just to understand, imagine if you were to go to, say, Khan…
Dino Dig - Linked | Explorer
NARRATOR: Welcome to Moab, Utah, surrounded by thousands of square miles of Mars-like Red Rock landscape and the mighty Colorado River. Surprisingly, Utah has yielded fossils from more dinosaur species than any other state. And that fact alone makes for a…