yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Sunni and Shia Islam part 1 | World History | Khan Academy


5m read
·Nov 11, 2024

We're now going to talk about the main division that emerges in Islam shortly after the death of Muhammad, and that division is between Sunnis and Shias. This division even exists today, where roughly 90% of the world's 1.5 or 1.6 billion Muslims are Sunni, and roughly 10% are Shia. That 10% is concentrated mainly in places like Iran and Iraq, but they are spread throughout the Muslim world or the world in general.

Now, the word Sunni comes from the word Sunnah, which is referring to examples of Muhammad. The word Shia comes from Shiatu Ali, which means followers of Ali or party of Ali. We'll talk more about Ali in a little bit, but the general division is over who should succeed Muhammad after his death as the leader of the Muslim community. Shias believe it should be members of Muhammad's family, especially descendants of Muhammad, while the Sunnis believe that it doesn't necessarily have to be that. As we'll see, this division becomes stronger and stronger as there is more and more bloodshed between the two parties because so much of this revolves around the family of Muhammad.

Let's just review that first, and then we'll talk about the division over who should succeed Muhammad as caliph or successor to lead the Muslim community. So you see Muhammad right over here, born 570. We have his birth on our timeline as well, and just to read this timeline, it goes from light blue to dark blue when Muhammad, according to Islamic tradition, starts to have the revelations from God. The Muslim calendar starts at 622, at the time of the hijra, where the Muslim community, in order to escape persecution from the Quraish, migrates from Mecca to Medina.

Now we've talked about several of these figures in other videos. Right over here you have Muhammad's dad, Abdullah, who dies several months before Muhammad is born. You have Amina here, who is Muhammad's mother, and she dies when Muhammad is six years old. Then you have Abdul Muttalib, who is the head of Muhammad's, you could say, household, and he takes custody after the death of Amina until Muhammad is eight years old when Abdul Muttalib dies. Then Muhammad's uncle, Abu Talib, takes custody. It's under Abu Talib that Muhammad learns his trade as a merchant and as a trader.

Now later on, we talk about Khadijah, who is a wealthy widow in Mecca, and she employs Muhammad. According to Islamic tradition, she is impressed by him and proposes to him, and she is 15 years older than Muhammad. This is her third marriage, and Muhammad marries her. She is a significant figure in Islam not because she is Muhammad's first wife but also because she is the first Muslim.

As you can see, Muhammad and Khadijah have several children, and I list one of them here, Fatima, because Fatima ends up marrying Abu Talib's son, Ali. Ali is the Ali that we're talking about, where the word Shia (Shiatu Ali) comes from, party of Ali, because Ali is considered the second Muslim. He is one of the early followers of Muhammad; as you can see, he is Muhammad's cousin. He grows up in the same household with Muhammad with Abu Talib, and he is also Muhammad's son-in-law. He marries Fatima, and they have several children, two of which are Hassan and Hussein, who figure very prominently in the narrative I'm going to talk about in this video and the next.

Now, the other figures that you see here: you have Abu Bakr, who was a close companion of Muhammad, also one of the early Muslims. You can see he was a little bit younger than Muhammad, and they are connected through Aisha. Muhammad marries Aisha after the death of Khadijah, and Aisha is a significant figure in early Islam. She's considered to have a very strong personality; many of the hadith are narrated by her. The hadith are the Muslim traditions and accounts of Muhammad's life, and it's a significant part of the religion outside of the Quran. She is married to Muhammad at a very, very young age, and there's some debate about how young she actually was. But, as we'll see, she also figures prominently in this narrative and in the schism that develops between the Sunni and the Shia, and the Sunni and the Shia view her differently.

So let's go back to the timeline here. As Muhammad's life nears its end, in 632, in previous videos, we talk about his final pilgrimage to Mecca. Then on his way back to Medina, at a place like Ghadir Khum, he gives a sermon—a sermon that is especially very important to the Shia. According to that short sermon at Ghadir Khum, Ghadir literally means pond or small stream. So it's the sermon at the pond Khum.

There is one quotation that Shia consider to be very, very important where Muhammad says, "Of whomsoever I had been Mullah, Ali here is to be his Muwala." The word Muwala means protector or leader, or it could mean guardian or people that you are close to. The Shia view this as clear evidence that Muhammad intended Ali to be his successor. Many members of the Sunni tradition take a slightly different interpretation where they say Muwala doesn't necessarily have to mean protector or leader; it could mean companion or friend or member that is close to. So they don't view this as strong evidence, but in the Shia tradition, the event at Ghadir Khum is actually a significant event, and it is even a holiday.

So that's the evidence that Shia point to as why Ali should be the successor. But then Muhammad dies, and according to the tradition, while his funeral is being planned by his family, the close companions were meeting and discussing who should succeed Muhammad. The close companions decide that it should be Abu Bakr. So Abu Bakr becomes the first caliph, and he rules for two years. He is succeeded by Umar, sometimes pronounced as Omar, who then is assassinated. Umar is succeeded by Uthman, sometimes pronounced as Usman, who is then assassinated. Then Ali takes power.

According to Sunni tradition, these first four khalifs are considered the Rashidun caliphs or the rightly guided. Under their rule, you have the significant spread of what becomes this Islamic empire that we talk about in other videos. In Shia tradition, they consider these first three khalifs as usurpers. They believe that Ali should have been caliph from the beginning, right in 632 at the time of Muhammad's death. Once again, they cite the events at Ghadir Khum, which was observed according to the hadith by thousands of people, and there are many, many accounts of this.

Now, Ali is in power, but as we will see in the next video, this starts the first civil war—the first Muslim civil war, often referred to as the first Fitna—between Ali and the Umayyads, who are the family of Uthman, and we will cover that in the next video.

More Articles

View All
9 Japanese Philosophies to Become Self-Disciplined and Stop Procrastinating
Have you ever struggled with procrastination or finding the motivation to get things done, feeling like you’re not living up to your own expectations? I won’t lie. I struggle with procrastination a lot, and it’s a challenge, especially when I have importa…
HOW TO UNDERSTAND YOURSELF | MARCUS AURELIUS | STOICISM
The Stoic Greeks had the maxim, know thyself. How do we in this digital age come to know ourselves in terms of our personalities and, more importantly, our potential? In this video, you will learn eight transformative Stoic techniques to really know yours…
When to Rob a Bank, with Freakonomics’ Stephen J. Dubner | Big Think
So if your question is when to rob a bank, which plainly is our question – that’s what we titled the book, you think about a few things. You think about, you know, time of day, day of week, part of the year and so on. And this grew out of the fact that I’…
2002 Berkshire Hathaway Annual Meeting (Full Version)
Here but a seconder or anybody would like to speak that motion might now work their way over to the microphone in zone one. Could we have a spotlight on where there it is? And that way when we get to that point of the program, if anybody that would like t…
Underwater Snow Mobile | The Boonies
Any luck over there? Nope, no snowmobile yet. Maybe a rock and a log, 18 miles from the mainland, far outside the grid. Dan Burton is attempting to salvage a sunken snowmobile from the bottom of Lake Michigan. “I’m sure it’s here! I don’t see anybody bea…
Example identifying roles in a food web | Ecology | High school biology | Khan Academy
We are asked who is a secondary consumer in this diagram. So pause this video and see if you can figure that out. All right, now let’s work through this together. So let’s just make sure we understand this diagram. When we have an arrow from grasses to m…