The Contradiction In The U.S. Constitution

less than 1m read

·Nov 10, 2024

Did you know that one of the greatest mathematicians of the 20th century discovered a logical contradiction in the US Constitution that, if found, could be used to legally change America's democracy into a dictatorship?

Well, he did, but we no longer know what it was. It's been called one of the great unsolved problems of constitutional law, but it's also known as Girdle's Loophole. In 1947, Kurt Girdle discovered the contradiction while studying for the American citizenship test. He told his friend Oscar Morganstern, and then Morganstern told Albert Einstein.

Both of them agreed that it probably wouldn't be exploited. Now, no one ever wrote it down, so we don't know what he had in mind. Was it something about the Electoral College, presidential pardons, or gerrymandering?

Well, there's been a lot of speculation, but I think one of the best guesses is this: Girdle's problem may have been that Article 5 could be seen as self-referential. It circumscribes how the Constitution can and cannot be changed, and yet Article 5 is also part of the Constitution.

If the rules about how the rules can be changed can themselves be changed, well then anything is not only possible or easy but legal. But really, no one knows.

A Brief History of Grand Canyon National Park | National Geographic

How Surfing Lead One NatGeo Explorer to The Depths of The Ocean | National Geographic

View All

The elements of a poem | Reading | Khan Academy

Hello readers! Let’s talk about poems. Poetry is a special kind of writing. If ordinary writing is like talking, then poetry is like singing. Poetry is a way of making art with language. Poems can express huge ideas or feelings. They can be about the soun…

Worked examples: Calculating equilibrium constants | Equilibrium | AP Chemistry | Khan Academy

An equilibrium constant can be calculated from experimentally measured concentrations or partial pressures of reactants and products at equilibrium. As an example, let’s look at the reaction where N2O4 in the gaseous state turns into 2NO2, also in the gas…

The European Union Explained*

Where is the European Union? Obviously here somewhere, but much like the European continent itself, which has an unclear boundary, the European Union also has some fuzzy edges to it. To start, the official members of the European Union are, in decreasing…

Slow Motion of an AK-47 Underwater (Part 1) - Smarter Every Day 95

Hey it’s me Destin. This week on Smarter Every Day, I’m gonna trick you into learning science using a gun and a high speed camera. You remember the old pistols underwater video? Well this week I’m gonna do it with a better high speed camera, and a bigger …

Avni Patel Thompson at the Seattle Female Founders Conference

So the first speaker you’re gonna hear today is Omnipotent Thompson, the founder of Poppy. Poppy is a site that connects parents with great caregivers for their children. So Omni and her co-founder went through Y Combinator in Winter 2016. She’s also an i…

Less versus fewer | Frequently confused words | Usage | Grammar

Hello Garian, hello Rosie, hi David. Uh, so you’ve called me into the recording booth today? Yes, because uh, you have a bone to pick with me—just a little bit. Yeah, so I have always, in my usage, I always drawn a distinction between less and fewer. I w…

The Contradiction In The U.S. Constitution

More Articles