yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

The Contradiction In The U.S. Constitution


less than 1m read
·Nov 10, 2024

Did you know that one of the greatest mathematicians of the 20th century discovered a logical contradiction in the US Constitution that, if found, could be used to legally change America's democracy into a dictatorship?

Well, he did, but we no longer know what it was. It's been called one of the great unsolved problems of constitutional law, but it's also known as Girdle's Loophole. In 1947, Kurt Girdle discovered the contradiction while studying for the American citizenship test. He told his friend Oscar Morganstern, and then Morganstern told Albert Einstein.

Both of them agreed that it probably wouldn't be exploited. Now, no one ever wrote it down, so we don't know what he had in mind. Was it something about the Electoral College, presidential pardons, or gerrymandering?

Well, there's been a lot of speculation, but I think one of the best guesses is this: Girdle's problem may have been that Article 5 could be seen as self-referential. It circumscribes how the Constitution can and cannot be changed, and yet Article 5 is also part of the Constitution.

If the rules about how the rules can be changed can themselves be changed, well then anything is not only possible or easy but legal. But really, no one knows.

More Articles

View All
Lecture 12 - Building for the Enterprise (Aaron Levie)
Can we keep playing? Wait, okay, good. Can we turn it up a little bit, so it’s more pumped up? That’s loud. Okay, here we go. Okay. Okay, so we gotta find the beat and then we gotta clap to the beat. Okay. All right. Okay, that’s pretty good, guys. …
Happiness Without Material Comfort Is Playing on Hard Mode
Even though you can certainly achieve happiness and mental health without financial health, the truth is in modern society, most of us understand that financial wealth can give us freedom. It can give us time. It can give us peace. You’re not gonna buy yo…
Some Surprising Things
Hey, Vsauce. Michael here. What’s normal? Are you normal? Well, today let’s bathe our brains with those questions and scrub down with things that are surprising and counterintuitive. What does it mean to be normal in the first place? Well, maybe it just …
What Is The Scariest Thing?
[Michael breathing heavily] [laughing nervously] Everyone is scared of something. But is there something that everyone is scared of? What is the scariest thing possible? ♪ [Michael] So what is the scariest thing? - Is it thunder? - [thunder crackles] Shad…
Charlie Munger: “An idiot could diversify their portfolio"
And of course, I’m out performing everybody. I’m 95 years old and I frankly never have a transaction. The answer is I’m right and they’re wrong, and that’s why it’s worked for me and not for them. I always knew from the very first, I was a little boy, th…
Why Chasing Happiness is Pointless (The Hedonic Treadmill)
Centuries ago, Siddhartha Gautama was born a prince, with a prophecy declaring that he would become either a great king or a spiritual leader. His father didn’t like the idea of his son walking the spiritual path; he wanted him to become a powerful ruler,…