The Contradiction In The U.S. Constitution

less than 1m read

·Nov 10, 2024

Did you know that one of the greatest mathematicians of the 20th century discovered a logical contradiction in the US Constitution that, if found, could be used to legally change America's democracy into a dictatorship?

Well, he did, but we no longer know what it was. It's been called one of the great unsolved problems of constitutional law, but it's also known as Girdle's Loophole. In 1947, Kurt Girdle discovered the contradiction while studying for the American citizenship test. He told his friend Oscar Morganstern, and then Morganstern told Albert Einstein.

Both of them agreed that it probably wouldn't be exploited. Now, no one ever wrote it down, so we don't know what he had in mind. Was it something about the Electoral College, presidential pardons, or gerrymandering?

Well, there's been a lot of speculation, but I think one of the best guesses is this: Girdle's problem may have been that Article 5 could be seen as self-referential. It circumscribes how the Constitution can and cannot be changed, and yet Article 5 is also part of the Constitution.

If the rules about how the rules can be changed can themselves be changed, well then anything is not only possible or easy but legal. But really, no one knows.

Daylight Saving Time 101 | National Geographic

15 Skills You Need to Thrive in The Next 15 Years

View All

Prepositional phrases | The parts of speech | Grammar | Khan Academy

Hey Garans, let’s talk about prepositional phrases and what they are and how they’re used, their care and feeding. You know, so a prepositional phrase simply speaking is anything that follows a preposition. Frankly, so, uh, if we look at the sentence, “Da…

TIL: Life Could Exist on Mars Thanks to Methane | Today I Learned

[Music] Anywhere on Earth that we find liquid water and other sources of nutrients and energy, we find [Music] life. So, we’re studying bubbles of methane that are coming out of the Earth’s crust in the deep sea. This is a very interesting source of energ…

Constant of proportionality from tables | 7th grade | Khan Academy

We are asked which table has a constant of proportionality between y and x of 0.6. Pause this video and see if you can figure that out. All right, so just as a reminder, the constant of proportionality between y and x, one way to think about it is that y…

Short, medium and long term financial goals | Financial goals | Financial literacy | Khan Academy

So it’s very likely that you have different financial goals over different amounts of time. For example, you are likely, or maybe you should have, long-term financial goals. Long-term financial goals are like: I want to make sure I have enough money for r…

Stare decisis and precedent in the Supreme Court | US government and civics | Khan Academy

As we’ve talked about in many videos, the United States Supreme Court has a very different role than the executive or the legislative branches. The executive branch, of course, runs the government. The legislative branch, they make the laws and set the bu…

Evolution, Adaptive Beliefs and Tigers

Natural selection only cares about what’s adaptive. Both true and false beliefs can be adaptive as long as they increase an animal’s chance of survival. Why should we expect natural selection to favor true adaptive beliefs over false ones? Alvin Plantinga…

The Contradiction In The U.S. Constitution

More Articles