The Contradiction In The U.S. Constitution

less than 1m read

·Nov 10, 2024

Did you know that one of the greatest mathematicians of the 20th century discovered a logical contradiction in the US Constitution that, if found, could be used to legally change America's democracy into a dictatorship?

Well, he did, but we no longer know what it was. It's been called one of the great unsolved problems of constitutional law, but it's also known as Girdle's Loophole. In 1947, Kurt Girdle discovered the contradiction while studying for the American citizenship test. He told his friend Oscar Morganstern, and then Morganstern told Albert Einstein.

Both of them agreed that it probably wouldn't be exploited. Now, no one ever wrote it down, so we don't know what he had in mind. Was it something about the Electoral College, presidential pardons, or gerrymandering?

Well, there's been a lot of speculation, but I think one of the best guesses is this: Girdle's problem may have been that Article 5 could be seen as self-referential. It circumscribes how the Constitution can and cannot be changed, and yet Article 5 is also part of the Constitution.

If the rules about how the rules can be changed can themselves be changed, well then anything is not only possible or easy but legal. But really, no one knows.

The rise of industrial capitalism | AP US History | Khan Academy

The Nernst equation | Applications of thermodynamics | AP Chemistry | Khan Academy

View All

Why It Actually Might Be 'Survival of the Friendliest' | Nat Geo Explores

[Music] It’s a dog-eat-dog world: winner takes all, survival of the fittest. But is it really? If the biggest and baddest always win, how come there are so many more of them than them? Strength is helpful, but friendliness might actually be the key to evo…

Introduction to "Meet a chemistry professional"

Have you ever wondered what a chemist really does? In this series, we asked people with chemistry backgrounds to share their stories. We have people from all different fields and careers. For example, we have an interview of someone who works in forensics…

Changes in equilibrium price and quantity when supply and demand change | Khan Academy

What we’re going to do in this video is think about all of the different ways that a supply curve or demand curve can shift. That’s why we actually have eight versions of the exact same diagram. Each of them is showing where we are right now, let’s say in…

Nate Blecharczyk at Startup School 2013

[Applause] Wow, there are a lot of you! That’s awesome to see. You know, I got some emails over the last 24 hours from people saying how excited they were to come to this talk. I want you to know I’m humbled by that, and, uh, also a little intimidated. I …

Identifying Unknown Soldiers | Ghosts of Pearl Harbor

[music playing] NARRATOR: Of the 429 men who died on the battleship “USS Oklahoma,” only 35 were identified in the years immediately following the attack. The rest were buried in graves marked “Unknown.” But almost 75 years later, one of these unknown me…

Implicit differentiation, product and chain rules at once

Let’s say Y is equal to the natural log of x to the X power. What we want to do is we want to find the derivative of Y with respect to X. So I encourage you to pause this video and see if you could do it. So when you first try to tackle this, this is a l…

The Contradiction In The U.S. Constitution

More Articles