yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Spinning Disk Trick Solution


3m read
·Nov 10, 2024

[Applause] So, in the spinning disc trick we saw that an asymmetrically weighted disc, when spun, actually flips so that the lighter side goes towards the bottom. Now, this is a variation on something called the tippy top, a little spinning toy that spins upside down so that its heavy side actually lifts up.

Now, this toy was played with by far more accomplished physicists than me, people like Neil's Bohr and Wolfgang Pauli. So, I have a little confession to make: that when I made this spinning disc trick video, I didn't actually know how it worked. So when I said, "I don't want to give you the answer right away," what I actually meant was, "Can you guys help me out and figure out how this works?"

Now, in the comments, there were 25 comments pertaining to centripetal force and 56 comments related to centrifugal force. So clearly, I need to do a video about those things. I think most of the time you guys were thinking an explanation like this: rotational systems tend so that they moment of inertia increases.

So, I'm thinking that as this starts spinning like this and is wobbling around, you think about there's a difference in moment of inertia of this thing spinning around compared to at the bottom where there's more of the mass at the top. The intuition is that it takes effort for the ice skater to bring her arms in, whereas just relaxing tends to increase the moment of inertia.

Now, an additional 52 comments mentioned inertia, betting that that's my answer for everything. Unfortunately, I don't think any of these things explains really what's going on with the spinning disc. So, I had to set out and do my own investigations.

The first thing I did was I talked to the smartest physicists I know. "What do you think it's going to do if I spin it? It's going to spin around and it's going to turn upside down so that the mass is at the top." I filmed the disc in 100 frames per second and 300 frames per second slow motion, and we labeled some points along the disc so we could really see what was happening.

But even then, it was tricky to figure out. I took it out to the ice rink to see what role the surface played in terms of the spinning disc. So, what is my final explanation? It is that when the disc is spinning, the first thing we should notice is that the angular momentum remains constant the whole time.

So when I spin it clockwise from above, the angular momentum is pointing vertically downwards, and that remains the same even as the disc flips over. So, what is causing the disc to flip? Well, if the disc wobbles a little bit, it's off center, so its center of mass, about which it's spinning, is not located directly above the point of contact with the surface.

As the disc spins, there's some sliding friction which acts to create a torque on the disc. Now, that torque reduces the angular momentum in the three direction of the disc and increases it in the one-two direction of the disc, which causes the disc to turn over like this. And once the disc goes past that point, the frictional torque at the bottom continues to rotate the disc until it is vertical like that.

So, it's really friction that is responsible for flipping this disc over so the heavy part goes up. Now, there was an excellent video response made by Zog from Beetlejuice, so you should definitely check that out. "Why don't I have any hair in that?" Anyway, it is an amazing and hilarious response, which is actually very physically accurate, so check it out when you get a chance.

Now, I have my doubts that this explanation is really the whole answer because I noticed that if I spin it above the ground, the hole still seems to go towards the bottom. That's kind of odd! When I took it to the ice rink, well, sometimes the disc would behave as expected, and sometimes it just did strange things where the hole would go down and then up and then down and then up.

I think maybe it's a sign of precession or perhaps nutation, but those are things for another video. So, until next time, keep spinning those discs!

More Articles

View All
FTC Chair Lina Khan at Y Combinator
Thanks everybody for coming to White Combinator today. Uh, we’re so excited, uh, to host Cherina Khan of the Federal Trade Commission. Um, you know, uh, so I’m Luther LOM, the new head of public policy at White Combinator, and um, this is the first event …
Searching for Bullwinkle | Port Protection
Where are you going to go, Gary? Uh, we’re going to go and see if we can find Bow Winkle. You’ll probably hear them come through the brush or hear them walking in the muskeg before you see one, right? And call them in like a cowboy, you know. Really? Ye…
Science Fair – Trailer | National Geographic
The winner in the category of Medicine, making it ties—that’s like the big thing. You kind of had that status of being in, like, the group I would say that a lot of people are jealous of. On deadlines, I’m awful. I wait until the deadline to start workin…
Simplifying more involved radical expressions
We’re asked to simplify the expression by removing all factors that are perfect squares from inside the radicals and combining the terms. So, let’s see if we can do it. Pause the video and give it a go at it before we do it together. All right, so let’s …
Dua Lipa: 'Radical Optimism', Songwriting & Headlining Glastonbury | Apple Music
Finally, I’m at a place in my career where I feel really confident. It took me so long to get to this place. “Is that the book?” That’s the book! The very first page, it says “radical optimism.” “You kidding? That’s the first thing you wrote?” Yeah, l…
I Fed a Chameleon From My Mouth To Study Its Mouth ( In Slow Motion) | Smarter Every Day 180
Hey, it’s me Destin, welcome back to Smarter Every Day. I’ve been wanting to do this video forever. Chameleons’ tongues are very unique, and this is a very hungry chameleon right now, and I’m going to see if I can feed him by holding a cricket in my mouth…