yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Good Explanations Are Hard to Vary


2m read
·Nov 3, 2024

Brett, would you say that a scientific theory is a subset of a good explanation? Yes, they're the testable kinds of good explanations. Falsifiable theories are actually a dime a dozen. This doesn't tell you anything about the quality of the explanation you're being given.

The example that's used in "The Fabric of Reality" is the grass cure for the common cold. If someone comes along to you and says, "If you eat 1.0 kilograms of grass, it will cure your common cold," they have a testable theory. The problem is that no one should test it. Why? Because they haven't given you an explanation as to what the mechanism is that would enable grass to cure the common cold.

If you do eat the 1.0 kilograms of grass and it doesn't cure your cold, they can turn around and say, "1.1 kilograms might do it," right? Or you need a different kind of grass, or you need to always do it on a different day. It's always testable, but you're not getting anywhere; you're not making any progress.

So, I think the second piece of a good explanation is hard to vary. It has to be very precise, and there must be a good reason for the precision. The famous example he used in "The Beginning of Infinity" is, "Why do we have seasons on the Earth?" There was the old Greek explanation: "Well, it's driven by Persephone, the goddess of spring. That's when she can leave Hades," and there's this whole theory involving gods and goddesses. Not only was that not easily testable, it was very easy to vary. Persephone could have been Nike, and Hades could have been Jupiter or Zeus.

It's very easy to vary that explanation without the predictions changing. Whereas if you look at the axis tilt theory of saying "The Earth is angled at 23 degrees relative to the sun," and therefore would expect the sun to rise here in the winter and over there in the summer, the facts on that are very hard to vary. It makes risky and narrow predictions. They can predict the exact length of summer and winter at different latitudes, and you can test that very precisely.

So beyond it being a creative theory that is testable and falsifiable, it should be hard to vary the pieces of that theory without essentially destroying that theory. You certainly don't want to vary it after the fact, like your grass example: "Oh, it was one kilogram, now it's 1.1, now it's 1.2."

Finally, the predictions that it makes should be very narrow and precise, and they should be risky. For example, I believe in relativity; was it Eddington who did the experiment and showed that starlight gets bent around the eclipse? That was a prediction that Einstein had made in relativity, which turned out to be true. That was a risky prediction that took a long time to confirm.

More Articles

View All
Reading (and comparing) multiple books | Reading | Khan Academy
Hello readers! You know what’s better than reading a book? Reading two books! Reading a bunch of books! Reading a mountain of books! This may sound self-evident, but great readers read a lot of books. Good readers read widely. They read lots of different …
Building a Cabin in the Arctic | Life Below Zero
What doesn’t kill you just makes you stronger. Good practice. Get knocked down, get right back up again, and get back to work. [Music] Just got the dogs out for a good run. I’m about to start working on my cabin. It’s kind of been getting put off a long…
Introduction to powers of 10
In this video, I’m going to introduce you to a new type of mathematical notation that will seem fancy at first, but hopefully, you’ll appreciate is pretty useful and also pretty straightforward. So let’s just start with some things that we already know. …
Renting vs Buying a Home: What NOBODY Is Telling You
What’s up you guys? It’s Graham here. So the other day, one of my posts on LinkedIn went somewhat viral on Reddit where I said if you were to buy a million-dollar home, you would have to put $200,000 down, take on a mortgage of $5,600 a month, pay another…
Humanity's Fascination with Mars | MARS
Dreamers of space have always had their eyes there, their hopes, their aspirations on getting to Mars. It has to look at the sky, saw that thought, and wondered what’s on it. As soon as people understood what planets were, some of them said, “Wouldn’t it …
North Carolina's Nuclear Incident | The Strange Truth
[Music] Bomb number one was literally a Washington Monument right in the middle of a tobacco field, tail up in the air. The parachute that had deployed was strewn amongst the branches. We found that the weapon was in sufficiently safe condition to transpo…