yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

It’s Rare to Have Competing, Viable, Scientific Theories


2m read
·Nov 3, 2024

Edition that's similar to Bayesianism, isn't it? In both cases, they're assuming that you can enumerate all the possible theories, but you can't, because that's the creativity coming in. It's very rare in science to have more than one viable theory in physics. We mentioned Newtonian theory of gravity and there was general relativity. That's one of the rare occasions where you actually have these two competing theories.

It's almost unknown to have three competing theories. What confuses people is that induction and Bayesianism work really well for finite constrained spaces that are already known. They're not good for new explanations. Bayesianism is, "I got new information, I used to weight the previous probability predictions that I had, now I've changed my probability based on the new data." So, I believe that something different is going to happen.

For example, I don't know if you remember the Monty Hall show. Monty Hall calls you up and there's three doors. There's treasure behind one of them, and then two of them don't have anything. You pick which door it's going to be: door number one, two, or three. Then he opens one of the other two doors and shows you there's nothing behind it. Now, do you want to change your vote?

The understanding of knife probability says, "No, I wouldn't change my vote. Why should it matter that one of the ones he showed me doesn't have something? The probability should not have changed." But Bayesianism says, "You've got new information, you should revise your guess, and you should switch to the other door."

The easier way to say that is, imagine there were 100 doors, and then you picked one at random. Then he opens 98 of the remaining 99 and shows you there's nothing. Now, do you switch? Of course you'd want to switch, because what are the odds that you picked one of the 100 in the first place? Now your odds are one in two.

People discover this and say, "Of course! Now I'm a smart Bayesian; I can update my priors based on new information. That's what smart people do, and therefore I'm a Bayesian." But it in no way helps you discover new knowledge or new explanations.

That's the uncontroversial use of Bayesianism, which is a very powerful tool. It's used in medicine, trying to figure out which of these medicines might be more effective than others. So, there are whole areas of mathematics like Bayesianism that can be applied in science without controversy at all.

It's where we say that Bayesianism is the way in which we can generate new explanations or the way in which we can judge one explanation against another. In fact, the way in which we generate new explanations is creativity, and the way in which we judge one explanation against another is either experimental refutation or straightforward criticism of realizing that one of those explanations is just a bad explanation.

More Articles

View All
What I learned from President Obama - Smarter Every Day 151
Hey, it’s me, Destin. Welcome back to Smarter Every Day! I just interviewed the President of the United States of America, which is really strange because I’m not a journalist, I’m not a politician. I’m a rocket engineer. Which means I’m going to come at …
Gravitational forces | Forces at a distance | Middle school physics | Khan Academy
When you hear the word gravity, you probably just think of things falling, like an apple from a tree. But did you know it’s also the reason why your lamp is staying on the floor? That’s because gravity is so much more than things falling down. Gravitation…
First Fish of the Morning | Wicked Tuna: Outer Banks
I was dozing off. I was so comfortable last night. Oh yeah, the life foam down there, mother’s arm. Oh, it is. I know it is. When we stayed out here last night looking for a bite, now if we could get a bluefin tuna, we’d be closer to doing what we came do…
To the Moon and Not Back? | StarTalk
So if I don’t mean to get morbid on you, but if you had died on the moon, were we ready for that here in America, here on Earth? Every president has a speechwriter, a staff, and a staff writer. The president would of course prepare for the event if some d…
Homeopathy Explained – Gentle Healing or Reckless Fraud?
Homeopathy may be the most controversial but also the most popular alternative medicine. While some argue against it, others swear by its great power and effectiveness. How does homeopathy work? How did it become what it is today, and what can modern medi…
15 Reasons You Don't Like Your Job (& What To Do About It)
Can you believe there are people who wake up every morning excited about the work they get to do? They don’t mind putting in the extra hours. Their work feels like their hobby. They’re proud about what they do, and they have great colleagues. When you do …