yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

There Is No Settled Mathematics


3m read
·Nov 3, 2024

There are two other scientific thinkers that I like who are unrelated to David Deutsch but come to very similar conclusions. One is Nasim Taleb, who's popularized the idea of the black swan, which is that no number of white swans disproves the existence of a black swan. You can never conclusively say all swans are white; you can never establish final truth. All you can do is work with the best explanation you have today, which is still better than ignorance—far better. But at any time, a black swan can show up and disprove your theory, and then you have to go find a better one.

The other fellow who I find fascinating is Gregory Chaitin. He is a mathematician who is very much in the Kurt Gödel vein, where he tries to explore the limits and boundaries of what is possible in mathematics. One of the points that he makes is that Gödel's incompleteness theorem doesn't say that mathematics is junk; it's not a cause for despair. Gödel's incompleteness theorem says that no formal system, including mathematics, can be both complete and correct. Either there are statements that are true that cannot be proven true in the system, or there will be a contradiction somewhere inside the system.

This could be a cause of despair for mathematicians who view mathematics as this abstract, perfect, fully self-contained thing. But Chaitin makes the argument that actually it opens up for creativity in mathematics. It means that even in mathematics, you are always one step away from falsifying something and then finding a better explanation for it. It puts humans and their creativity and their ability to find good explanations back at the core of it.

At some deep level, mathematics is still an art. There are very useful things that come out of mathematics, and you're still building an edifice of knowledge. But there is no such thing as conclusive settled truth; there is no subtle science; there is no settled mathematics. There are good explanations that will be replaced over time with more good explanations that explain more of the world.

This is something that we inherit from our schooling more than anything else. It's part of our academic culture and breeds into the wider culture as well. People have this idea that mathematics is this pristine area of knowledge where what has proved to be true is certainly true. Then you have science, which doesn't give you certain truth, but you can be highly confident in what you discover. You can use experiments to confirm that what you're saying appears to be correct, but you might be wrong.

And then, of course, there's philosophy, which is a mere matter of opinion. This is the hierarchy that some people inherit from school: mathematics are certain, science is almost certain, and the rest of it is more or less a matter of opinion. This is what Deutsch calls the mathematician's misconception; that mathematicians have this intuitive way of realizing that their proof, their theorem, that they've reached by this method of proof is absolutely certainly true. In fact, it's a confusion between the subject matter and our knowledge of the subject matter.

More Articles

View All
Scaling perimeter and area example 1 | Transformational geometry | Grade 8 (TX) | Khan Academy
We’re told Pentagon A was dilated by a scale factor of three to create Pentagon B. Complete the missing measurements in the table below, so pause this video, have a go at this before we do this together. All right, now let’s work on this together. It’s r…
Suing Robinhood
What’s up, you guys? It’s Graham here. So as most of you know, I really like to keep this channel centered around personal finance and investing. But every now and then, something comes up that I think is worth talking about further, and today, it’s impor…
Indus Valley Civilization | Early Civilizations | World History | Khan Academy
As we’ve talked about in multiple videos, some of the earliest civilizations we have found have been around river valleys, and that is no coincidence. Because some of the first agriculture emerged around river valleys, and the agriculture supported higher…
Bobby Bones Descends a Slippery Cliff | Running Wild With Bear Grylls
[Wind rumbling] OK, so Bobby, where we’re heading is a 100 foot drop off that lip. We’re right on the edge of this, like, boulder, slab of rock that just curls away. And it’s one of these awkward ones because you can’t see over the lip. We’re going to go …
Index Fund Bubble in 2022? Michael Burry vs Warren Buffett
Index funds: A passive investor’s dream. Make one investment but own the whole market. There’s no doubt that index funds and ETFs are a very clever invention. It’s the easy way to be diversified across the whole market and back stocks as an asset class, a…
Detonation vs Deflagration - Smarter Every Day 1
Hey, it’s me, Destin. So, um… we don’t have really awesome accents and we don’t have a lot of money, but we do know our guns. And we are rocket scientists. So, we’re gonna start a new web series called Smarter Every Day. [Music] Uh, we’re gonna try to te…