yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Example of under coverage introducing bias | Study design | AP Statistics | Khan Academy


3m read
·Nov 11, 2024

A senator wanted to know about how people in her state felt about internet privacy issues. She conducted a poll by calling 100 people whose names were randomly sampled from the phone book. Note that mobile phones and unlisted numbers are not in phone books. The senator's office called those numbers until they got a response from all 100 people chosen. The polls showed that 42% of respondents were very concerned about internet privacy.

What is the most concerning source of bias in this scenario? We should also think about what kind of bias is likely introduced. Is this likely to be an overestimate or an underestimate of the number of respondents? Maybe there is no bias here, but our choices, and "no bias" is not one of the choices. So, you can imagine it's going to be one of these three.

I encourage you to pause this video and think about what we just said. We're a senator, we're trying to figure out what percentage of our constituents are very concerned about internet privacy, and we go to the phone book, we sample 100 people, we keep calling them until they answer, and we get that 42% are very concerned. So, what's the source of bias?

Now let's work through this together. Non-response would have been the case if we selected these hundred people and let's say only 50 people answered the phone, and we didn't keep calling them. Then we'd say, "Well, you know, 50 of the people who we sampled to answer our survey didn't even respond." There was a non-response there. What was there about those 50 people? Maybe there was something that would have skewed the survey. If we had gotten them, it would have maybe yielded better data.

But in this case, they tell us the senator's office called those numbers until they got a response from all 100 people chosen. So, the 100 people that they chose, they made sure they got a response. So, non-response is not going to be an issue here.

Next choice: undercoverage. Well, undercoverage is where you're not able to sample from part of the population. A part of the population that wasn't sampled might introduce bias. Let's think about what happened in this situation. We are a senator, we want to sample all of our constituents, but instead, we sample from the constituents who happen to be listed in the phone book.

So, these are the people who happen to be listed in the phone book. We're not sampling from people who are not in the phone book, who may have landlines and are unlisted. We're also not sampling from people who don't have landlines and only have mobile phones. You might say, "Well, why is that important?"

Well, think about it. People who decide not to list in the phone book or people who don't even have a landline; some of those people might be a little bit more concerned about privacy than everyone else. They explicitly chose not to be listed. So, undercoverage is definitely a very concerning source of bias here.

We are sampling from only a subset of our entire population that we care about. In particular, we're missing out on people who might care about privacy. I would say that because of undercoverage, 42% is likely to be an underestimate of the number of people concerned about internet privacy. There is probably a higher proportion of people out here who care about privacy because they're unlisted or they don't even have a landline.

So, undercoverage probably introduced bias and implies that 42% is an underestimate of the percentage of the senator's constituents who care about internet privacy.

Now, the last question: volunteer response sampling. This would be the case where you know the senator, I don't know, put a billboard out or told someone, maybe on her website, "Hey, vote for this," or "Give us your information on how much you care about internet privacy." That would have been the source of bias there.

Once again, if you did, "Hey, come to my website in Philadelphia," you're only getting information from a subset of your population who are choosing and volunteering. That is not the situation here. She didn't ask 100 people to volunteer; her team went out and got them from the phone book.

So, this was definitely a case of undercoverage.

More Articles

View All
Nothing Exists But You | The Philosophy of Solipsism
The ancient Taoist philosopher Zhuangzi once dreamt he was a butterfly. He felt free, flying from flower to flower, doing the things a butterfly does. He didn’t doubt he was a butterfly and had forgotten that he was Zhuangzi. When he woke up, he realized …
Cuteness Overload | Project for Awesome 2014
Hey, it’s me Destin, welcome back to Smarter Every Day. So I’m gonna share something with you that’s so sweet you might actually cry, because I did the first time I saw it. There’s this little girl in Ohio who saw the Project for Awesome video I made las…
Worked example: Predicting whether a precipitate forms by comparing Q and Kₛₚ | Khan Academy
[Instructor] For this problem, our goal is to figure out whether or not a precipitate will form if we mix 0.20 liters of a 4.0 times 10 to the negative third Molar solution of lead two nitrate with 0.80 liters of an 8.0 times 10 to the negative third Mola…
Direction Game | Brain Games
It’s time to look at one of the most important brain functions of all: memory. Of course, to get to our next location, we’ll need directions, so let’s play a direction game. Here’s a simple memory test. Pay attention to the directions we give you. Betwee…
Rocket Bonfire Bullet Time Experiment - Smarter Every Day 65
Okay, so wine asked me if he could have a fire at my house, and I said yes. They showed up with a truck with speakers or subs or something, and then there’s kids like chopping stuff up with an axe, and they’re throwing stuff in a fire. I don’t know, I don…
Worked example: Motion problems with derivatives | AP Calculus AB | Khan Academy
A particle moves along the x-axis. The function x of t gives the particle’s position at any time t is greater than or equal to zero, and they give us x of t right over here. What is the particle’s velocity v of t at t is equal to 2? So, pause this video,…