yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Even Adam Smith Didn’t Trust the Invisible Hand, with Thomas Piketty | Big Think


3m read
·Nov 4, 2024

A very optimistic view of how the market works, which sometimes is associated to Adam Smith, is the view that you have self-regulation of the market and that the natural forces, natural market forces can take care of everything, and in particular can ensure that inequality will never increase to such an extent that it becomes socially and economically and politically useless or even dangerous for that matter.

Now I think, in fact if you reread Adam Smith or if you try to look at the economic developments throughout history you see that you cannot expect everything from the market. You cannot just rely on natural forces to solve all problems. And I think one of the conclusions from the history of political economy and the history of economic growth and inequality is that you need strong public institutions in order to put this powerful market forces in the right direction.

Market forces can produce a lot of innovation, a lot of incentives for inventions and entrepreneurship and this is very positive. But it would be a mistake to rely and count on these natural forces to sort of self-regulate themselves. And if you look in particular at the period going up to the financial crisis of 2007/2008, you have a very large concentration of economic gains into a relatively small group of the population.

And I think everybody agrees today that this has contributed not only to the stagnation of median household income but also to the rise of household debt, which in turn put pressure on the financial system and probably did contribute to fragilize the financial system with the consequences that we know in terms of financial crisis, recession, unemployment, which we are now starting to get out of this, but there has been many years of lost growth and a lot of social suffering because of this.

So we need strong public institutions in order to regulate these market forces. And sometimes there's really excessive phase in these forces. There are cycles over history. Probably after the Great Depression, after World War II people realized that market forces need to be strongly regulated.

And then starting in the '70s and the '80s with Reagan and cultural revolution and even more so after the fall of the Soviet Union, we entered in the 1990s and 2000 in a new cycle of sometimes unlimited phase in the self-regulation of markets. And to a large extent we are still in this phase.

And I think there's a reaction, a policy reaction to the financial crisis of 2007/2008 has been too limited so far. And this could happen again. We've asked a lot to our central banks in the U.S. and in Europe.

And of course it's easy to print billions of dollars or billions of euros to avoid complete bankruptcy of a financial system, which is what happened in the 1930s and which ended up in a complete catastrophe. So it's better to avoid that. But at the same time printing money is not enough to solve the central problem that we need to solve.

So the good news is that we avoided a complete bankruptcy and complete depression, but the bad news is that we did not really solve the structural problems which might in the future create new crisis.

More Articles

View All
The reason why you can't focus: How to fix your concentration scientifically
Are you constantly feeling overwhelmed, unable to focus on work or studying, and finding yourself getting lost in the world of social media? But what if I told you that the key to improving your focus could be right in front of you — your room? In this …
The Housing Market Is About To Go Wild | DO THIS NOW
What’s up, Diamond Handers? It’s Correction here, and the markets have gone completely mad. Like, I’m sure we’ve all heard the saying, “If you can’t beat them, join them.” But have you ever heard the phrase, “If you can’t beat them, offer all cash over as…
Stop Caring About What Isn't Yours: Epictetus’ Lessons from My Novel
Stoic philosopher Epictetus didn’t sugarcoat anything. He was direct and told the listener exactly how it was – at least, from the Stoic perspective. His no-nonsense approach, which becomes apparent when reading what’s left of his lectures, is why I love …
Determining congruent triangles example
We have four triangles depicted here, and they’ve told us that the triangles are not drawn to scale. We are asked which two triangles must be congruent. So, pause this video and see if you can work this out on your own before we work through this together…
Mixed-Member Proportional Representation Explained
Queen Lion of the animal kingdom is looking to improve her democracy. She recently allowed citizens to elect representatives to the Jungle Council, which governs the kingdom. However, she recognizes that her citizens are not happy with the voting system. …
The 5 Forces Impacting the World Order
Your analysis of economic historical events is based on five forces, and I’d really like to start this conversation by getting you to just quickly summarize those five forces. Okay, uh, just to give you a little bit of background, I um, I’m a global macr…