yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Your brain doesn’t detect reality. It creates it. | Lisa Feldman Barrett


3m read
·Nov 3, 2024

Processing might take a few minutes. Refresh later.
  • Sometimes people wanna say, "No, we definitely don't experience reality the way that it actually is." And some people wanna say, "Yes, we do." Philosophers have been arguing about this for like as long as philosophy has existed: The question of does your experience match reality, or are you really experiencing reality in its stark, objective truth? And the answer is simply: "Not exactly."

Reality, for us, is what we can sense with our sensory surfaces, and what we can make sense of with the signals in our brain. The signals in our brain are as necessary for our experience of reality as the sensory signals that come from the world. So, I'm gonna use a metaphor to describe how the brain works. It goes something like this: Your brain, my brain, everybody's brain, is trapped in its own dark, silent box called your skull.

And the brain has no knowledge of what is going on around it in the world or in the body, right? Because it's in this skull, and it's receiving sensory signals from the sensory surfaces of your body. These signals are the outcomes of some changes in the world or in the body- but the brain doesn't know what the changes are, it's receiving the outcomes. And that is what philosophers and scientists call the 'Reverse inference problem.' You start with an outcome, and you have to guess at the cause.

For example, if you hear a loud bang, it could be a car backfiring, a door slamming, it could be a gunshot. Your brain doesn't know what the causes are, it only knows the effect, and so, it has to guess. And the guess is important, right? Because you would do different things if it's a gunshot versus if it's a windy day that slammed a door. And luckily, it has one other source of information, and that is your past experience.

The really cool thing about this- if that wasn't cool enough- is that it's actually doing it predictively. Sometimes scientists talk about this as the brain running a model of the world, but the brain is not running a model of the world; the brain is running a model of its body, and it's doing it in this really interesting way. In psychology, a group of instances which are similar is called a category.

In essence, what your brain is doing, when it's making a prediction, it's creating a category of instances from the past which are similar in some way to the present, in order to predict what's going to happen next, what the brain has to do next, and what your experience will be next. And so, when a human brain is creating a category, you have to ask, "What features of similarity is it using?" Is it these sensory and motor features? An apple is round. An apple is hard and crunchy.

Or is it these abstract features; abstract, multimodal summaries of patterns of features. I could take a bunch of apples and I could say, "Well, these are good for baking, and these are not good for baking." And these patterns, this summary, only exists in your brain. Because our brains are structured to construct categories based on the function of things rather than what they look like, or taste like, or smell like, humans can create something called 'Social reality,' which is where we collectively impose a function on objects that the objects don't have by virtue of their physical nature.

So, a really good example of this is money- little pieces of paper. We all agree that these little pieces of paper have a function of value. And it turns out that many things that we think of as being part of reality are actually like this. We can draw lines in the sand and create the borders of countries, which creates categories of people called immigrants and citizens.

We can create governments because we all agree that certain actions like making little tick marks has a meaning to elect someone into a position that has certain powers- it's a form of social reality. In our lab, we work on the hypothesis that many psychological categories are forms of social reality. We impose a meaning on a scowling face that it did not evolve to have, but because we all agree that it has that meaning or that function in a particular culture, then...

More Articles

View All
Why No One Has Measured The Speed Of Light
This video was sponsored by KiwiCo. More about KiwiCo at the end of the show. I know what you’re thinking. - Clickbait! - No one has measured the speed of light, that’s ridiculous. The speed of light is exactly 299,792,458 meters per second. We are so s…
Being Ethical Is Long-term Greedy
In one of your tweets, you listed out some of the things you should study, like programming, sales, reading, writing, and arithmetic. One of the items that ended up on the cutting room floor was that you should also study ethics. I was originally going to…
Simple Aspect | The parts of speech | Grammar | Khan Academy
Hello gramians. Now previously, we had spoken about just the basic idea of verb aspect, which is kind of like tenses for tenses. I know that’s a little “wheels within wheels,” ridiculous, um, but we’ll make sense of it. What aspect allows you to do is si…
The Problem With Romanticizing Mental Illness
If you’re watching this right now, chances are you spent many years of your life feeling misunderstood. Maybe you coped by spending hours online or listening to pop punk alone in your bedroom. You might have wished to run away or for a simple answer that …
Andy Bromberg - Startup Investor School Day 4
There was one note that someone had that I thought was a little interesting. He pointed out that, Karl, thank you, that we haven’t really talked about taxes. I can’t imagine why we haven’t talked about taxes. Well, taxes are an interesting issue when you…
Top 7 WoW Cataclysm Visual Changes -- Wackygamer
Hey guys, Jeff here from Wacky Gamer. I wanted to bring you the top 7 things I’ve seen in the latest World of Warcraft Cataclysm footage. They finally filled in Thunder Ridge outside of Orgrimmar. I don’t know what Blizzard was thinking, but it’s like, l…