yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Take This Perception Test to See How Visually Intelligent You Are | Amy Herman | Big Think


3m read
·Nov 4, 2024

Visual intelligence is the concept that we see more than we can process, and it's the idea of thinking about what we see, taking in the information, and what do we really need to live our lives more purposefully and do our jobs more effectively.

What I ask the people at The Art of Perception to do: one of them is looking down at a piece of paper, and the other is looking at the painting. They have one minute to describe what it is that they see to their partner, and the partner has to sketch what they hear. And it's not about the artwork; it's not about how well you draw. It's how well can you describe a new set of unfamiliar data, how well do you listen, and how well do you take that articulation and transfer it to your own language.

How many of you said there was a train coming out of a fireplace? And everyone raises his or her hands. And how many of you referenced smoke or steam in your discussion? Lots of hands go up. And then I ask the question: who articulated that there are no tracks under the train? A few astute people actually raised their hand and said, "I said there were no tracks under the train." And then I ask, "Who noticed and then articulated that there was no fire in the fireplace?" Hands go up. Not too many.

Then we talk about other aspects in the painting. How many people mentioned the wood grain on the floor? Most people noticed the wood grain on the floor. How many people mentioned wainscoting, that kind of paneling on the walls? And I always have some decorative arts aficionados who say, "Oh yes, I know about wainscoting." And then I say, "How many of you mentioned a mantle on the fireplace?" Lots of hands go up. Who mentioned candlesticks? Lots of hands go up.

And then I ask, "How many of you said there were no candles in the candlesticks?" And people say, "Oh no, never got there." And then I ask, "What really observant nerd said it's 12:42 or 8:05 on the clock? Who got to mention the time?" The reason I have that line of questioning is that this painting illustrates a very important concept that I transfer from emergency medicine to a much broader application.

And the idea is called the pertinent negative. It's saying what isn't there in addition to what is there to actually give a more accurate picture of what you're looking at. So when you say, "I see a train coming out of the fireplace," and by the way, there are no tracks under the train and there is no fire in the fireplace, why would you attempt to say what's not there? Because in my third-grade mind, if you told me to draw a fireplace, I would draw two sticks and a fire and smoke in the fireplace unless you told me not to. And if you told me to draw a pair of candlesticks, I'll draw candles with flames unless you tell me not to.

So the pertinent negative is this wonderful concept that gives us a broader way of looking at something. Instead of looking at something like this, you look at it like this. And here's an example of how you apply that in the real world. The pertinent negative in a medical situation is when someone comes into the emergency room and they have all the symptoms. It appears to the physician they have all the symptoms of pneumonia.

Pneumonia has three symptoms. Symptom one is present, symptom two is present, but if symptom three is absent, it's the pertinent negative. You have to say symptom three is not there; therefore, it's not pneumonia. So in the real world, outside of medicine, how can we use this? If we have an expectation of someone's behavior, you expect them to behave a certain way, and then they don't, you need to say it didn't happen.

You're evaluating someone on the job. Well, you did A, B, and C very well, but you didn't do D, E, and F. So it's looking at the affirmative and looking at the negative. And the pertinent negative is a wonderful tool. In missing persons' cases, you go to their homes—what's not there? The cell phone is not there. The keys are not there. The wallet is not there. You're going to have a very different search for that person if those things were present instead of absent.

So this Magritte painting gives us this great opportunity to talk about not just what we see but what we don't see to give the person who can't see what we see a much more accurate description of what they're looking at.

More Articles

View All
2017/08/08: James Damore and his Google Memo on Diversity
Hello, so some of you may have heard about the leaked Google memo that has been circulating virally around the internet for the last couple of days. That was written by James D’Amour, who was fired last night. He reached out to me and put us together, and…
The US Constitution | Period 3: 1754-1800 | AP US History | Khan Academy
In the last video, we discussed the Great Compromise made at the Constitutional Convention in 1787, where delegates who were trying to craft a new governmental system for the United States agreed on how the legislative branch of the government would be se…
Divergence intuition, part 2
Hey everyone! So, in the last video, I was talking about Divergence and kind of laying down the intuition that we need for it. You’re imagining a vector field as representing some kind of fluid flow where particles move according to the vector that they’r…
How to Operate with Keith Rabois (How to Start a Startup 2014: Lecture 14)
Um, so I’m going to talk about how to operate. I’ve watched some of the prior classes, and I’m going to assume that you’ve already sort of hired a bunch of relentlessly resourceful people, that you built a product at least some people love, that you prob…
Why self improvement is ruining your life
One of the best feelings in the entire world is the feeling of getting better at the things that you’re interested in. You know, if you’re starting to get into the gym, it feels really good to actually see yourself getting stronger, whether that’s visuall…
How psychedelics work, explained in under 6 minutes | Matthew Johnson
Every psychological experience has a biological correlate: these are two sides of the same coin. You see the color green; there’s something happening in your brain that’s coding that experience of the color green. So, with psychedelics, the biggest divide…