yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Senate confirmation as a check on the judicial branch | US government and civics | Khan Academy


3m read
·Nov 11, 2024

When we think about how the executive or the legislative branch have some form of check or power over the judicial branch, a key element of that is the executive's ability to appoint judges to federal courts, including the U.S. Supreme Court. But it's not just that the president can decide who gets to be a justice; they have to be confirmed by the Senate.

What you see over here, what I'm about to play, are the confirmation hearings from Justice Sonia Sotomayor in 2009. What I hope you get from it is it's not an easy process. This is going to be a question from Senator Chuck Grassley, who's a Republican from Iowa, and he's going to be asking about whether marriage is a state or a federal question.

"So do you agree that marriage is a question reserved for the states to decide based on Baker versus Nelson?"

"That also I thought it was a question that's pending and impending in many courts. As you know, the issue of marriage and what constitutes it is the subject of much public discussion, and there's a number of cases in state courts addressing the issue of who regulates it under what terms."

"Can I please interrupt you? I thought I was asking a very simple question based upon a precedent that Baker versus Nelson is based on the proposition that, yesterday in so many cases, whether it was Griswold, whether it's Roe v. Wade, whether it was Chevron, whether it's a whole bunch of other cases that you made reference to—the Casey case, the Gonzalez case, the League and Creative Leather Products case, the Kilo case—that you made that case to me. You said these are precedents. Now are you saying to me that Baker versus Nelson is not a precedent?"

"No sir, I just haven't reviewed Baker in a while, and so I actually don't know what the status is. If it is the court's precedent, as I've indicated in all of my answers, I will apply that precedent to the facts of any new situation that implicates it."

Always the first question.

"Well then tell me, tell me what sort of a process you might go through."

So anyway, you can see that this is not an easy process. In this situation, you have an appointment by a Democratic president and you have questions from a Republican senator. This is fairly typical. They're likely to ask more pointed questions and try to get the appointee to trip up.

If you were to see questions from a Democratic senator, they'd be more likely to ask questions that would make the nominee look a little bit better, and that tends to always be the case. If it's from the same party, they tend to try to smooth the process, while the opposition party tries to make it a little bit more difficult.

An interesting thing to think about is Justice Sotomayor eventually does get appointed to the Supreme Court, but what was the goal of Senator Grassley here in asking these questions, even if he knew that she was eventually going to be appointed?

There are other themes that we've talked about in government that he might be playing to. He might be asking these questions more for his constituents, or there might be an element of, even if a Supreme Court Justice is going to be appointed, at the end of the day, there's also the court of public opinion, so to speak.

These might be opportunities to sow some seeds of doubt or to make it a little bit more difficult for a Supreme Court Justice to, in the future, vote one way or another based on what they say during these hearings. Interesting things to talk about.

More Articles

View All
What is Breakthrough Starshot?
The closest star system to our own Sun is Alpha Centauri, and nearly 4.5 light-years away from the Sun, they consist of three stars: Alpha Centauri A and B, who happen to form a binary star system as they orbit around each other in a cosmic dance. In Alph…
Sine and Cosine come from circles
Now I’m going to clear off the screen here, and we’re going to talk about the shape of the sign function. Let’s do that. This is a plot of the sign function, where the angle Theta—this is the Theta axis in this plot—where Theta has been plotted out on a s…
I Secretly Pitched A Fake Business On Shark Tank
So do we have a deal? No, no, never. You need your head examined. That’s just terrible. Okay, so let’s back up for a second. This is Barbara Corcoran. She sold her real estate brokerage in 2001 for 66 million dollars. She’s a judge on the Emmy Award-winn…
The secrets to year-round homesteading | Farm Dreams
[Music] I realized from my time on the homestead that being a part of where you source your food is one of the greatest things you can do with your time. I had so much more respect for just a single tomato because I knew how much time, how much care, and …
Turning Roadkill Into Art | National Geographic
I think what I’m aiming for is this notion of, I guess, seduction and revulsion. Something that’s really beautiful, really lush, rubbing up against something that’s also perhaps repulsive. I’m an artist and roadkill resurrector. The first body of work th…
The Most Horrible Parasite: Brain Eating Amoeba
A war has been going on for billions of years that breeds well armed monsters, who struggle with other monsters for survival. Having no particular interest in us, most of them are relatively harmless, as our immune systems deal with their weapons easily. …