yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Social contract - schmotial contract


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

People who support the state often say that everyone who lives in the territory claimed by the state has implicitly agreed to abide by the state's rules; that by not leaving the territory, they've entered into a voluntary agreement. This agreement is often the basis for denying that taxation to fund a project not supported by the taxpayer is theft.

The implicit contract that statists say exists is known as a social contract. This contract has been compared to the implicit contract between a customer and a restaurant. I know about and agree with the terms of the implicit contract between a restaurant and myself. I understand that my ordering of food is the trigger that brings the agreement into effect, and that part of the agreement is that I will pay for the food I order.

But by contrast, I have no knowledge of the social contract that statists tell me exists. Since I have never had knowledge of this agreement, I cannot have given meaningful consent to it. Furthermore, even if I had known that there was a mysterious contract that I was being asked to agree to, I still wouldn't be able to give meaningful consent to it until I knew exactly what the terms were.

I don't believe that a social contract exists. If I'm right, then I can't have agreed to a non-existent contract. If I'm wrong, then I can't have agreed to a contract that I did not know was being offered for my acceptance, nor can I have agreed to a contract whose terms I have no knowledge of. Either way, I cannot have agreed to a social contract by living in a territory claimed by a state.

More Articles

View All
I read 100 Philosophical Books. Here's the best one.
I remember feeling completely aimless in high school. None of my classes felt particularly meaningful to me. I would sit in class, stare straight ahead, and my mind would often just wander. At home, I would try to avoid thinking too much by playing video …
15 Signs You Get Played By Others
Do you feel like you’re always the third wheel? The one who is easily taken advantage of, or the one whose opinions don’t matter? Well, in this video, we’ll explore why you always get played and what you can do to change that. From lacking presence and fa…
Worked example: Approximation with local linearity | AP Calculus AB | Khan Academy
We’re told the function ( f ) is twice differentiable with ( f(2) = 1 ), ( f’(2) = 4 ), and ( f”(2) = 3 ). What is the value of the approximation of ( f(1.9) ) using the line tangent to the graph of ( f ) at ( x = 2 )? So pause this video and see if you c…
Ides of March spark a civil war | World History | Khan Academy
We finished the last video with the assassination of Julius Caesar on the Ides of March, March 15, 44 BCE. You might remember it was done by factions opposed to Julius Caesar who thought that, one, he had gotten too much power, but even more, he was using…
Senate confirmation as a check on the judicial branch | US government and civics | Khan Academy
When we think about how the executive or the legislative branch have some form of check or power over the judicial branch, a key element of that is the executive’s ability to appoint judges to federal courts, including the U.S. Supreme Court. But it’s not…
Ordering rational numbers in context | Grade 8 (TX) | Khan Academy
During basketball practice, four students practiced their free throw shots. The table below shows the proportion of free throws they each make. Let’s see. Simone made 68 of their free throws. David made Z 68 H hundreds, I guess I could say, of his free t…