yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Social contract - schmotial contract


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

People who support the state often say that everyone who lives in the territory claimed by the state has implicitly agreed to abide by the state's rules; that by not leaving the territory, they've entered into a voluntary agreement. This agreement is often the basis for denying that taxation to fund a project not supported by the taxpayer is theft.

The implicit contract that statists say exists is known as a social contract. This contract has been compared to the implicit contract between a customer and a restaurant. I know about and agree with the terms of the implicit contract between a restaurant and myself. I understand that my ordering of food is the trigger that brings the agreement into effect, and that part of the agreement is that I will pay for the food I order.

But by contrast, I have no knowledge of the social contract that statists tell me exists. Since I have never had knowledge of this agreement, I cannot have given meaningful consent to it. Furthermore, even if I had known that there was a mysterious contract that I was being asked to agree to, I still wouldn't be able to give meaningful consent to it until I knew exactly what the terms were.

I don't believe that a social contract exists. If I'm right, then I can't have agreed to a non-existent contract. If I'm wrong, then I can't have agreed to a contract that I did not know was being offered for my acceptance, nor can I have agreed to a contract whose terms I have no knowledge of. Either way, I cannot have agreed to a social contract by living in a territory claimed by a state.

More Articles

View All
Safari Live - Day 32 | National Geographic
[Music] you [Music] [Music] this program features live coverage of an African safari and may include animal kills and carcasses. Viewer discretion is advised. It’s a cool breezy afternoon. There’s some cloud cover in the perfect conditions for a young ma…
Steve Jobs talk at the 1983 International Design Conference in Aspen
[Applause] Morning introductions are really funny. They paid me $60, so I wore a tie. Um, how many people—how many of you are 36 years older than 36 years old? Yeah, all you were born pre-computer. The computer’s uh, 36 years old and there’s something sor…
Answering Presuppositionalism: Extra Credit
Presupposition lists hold that a theistic worldview is the only one that can account for knowledge. In particular, they claim that atheists cannot justify their use of inductive reasoning, while God provides a firm epistemological basis; in other words, a…
What Hermes Taught MeQT
Hi, Kevin O’Leary, investor at large. I’ve just come back from a shopping trip and learned a very important lesson. You know I love Hermès fantastic ties. What I hate about them is the price. So, I like to shop for volume, see if I can get a discount. I…
Homeroom with Sal & Katy Knight - Tuesday, October 13
Hi everyone, Sal here from Khan Academy. Welcome to the Homeroom live stream! We had a little bit of a hiatus, but now we are back. I had a torn calf and other things, but I’m almost fully recuperated. But thanks for joining! We have a really exciting con…
Free energy of formation | Applications of thermodynamics | AP Chemistry | Khan Academy
[Instructor] Free energy is symbolized by G. And the change in free energy is delta G. When there’s a subscript of F, this is talking about the change in the free energy of formation, which refers to the change in the free energy for the formation of one …