yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Social contract - schmotial contract


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

People who support the state often say that everyone who lives in the territory claimed by the state has implicitly agreed to abide by the state's rules; that by not leaving the territory, they've entered into a voluntary agreement. This agreement is often the basis for denying that taxation to fund a project not supported by the taxpayer is theft.

The implicit contract that statists say exists is known as a social contract. This contract has been compared to the implicit contract between a customer and a restaurant. I know about and agree with the terms of the implicit contract between a restaurant and myself. I understand that my ordering of food is the trigger that brings the agreement into effect, and that part of the agreement is that I will pay for the food I order.

But by contrast, I have no knowledge of the social contract that statists tell me exists. Since I have never had knowledge of this agreement, I cannot have given meaningful consent to it. Furthermore, even if I had known that there was a mysterious contract that I was being asked to agree to, I still wouldn't be able to give meaningful consent to it until I knew exactly what the terms were.

I don't believe that a social contract exists. If I'm right, then I can't have agreed to a non-existent contract. If I'm wrong, then I can't have agreed to a contract that I did not know was being offered for my acceptance, nor can I have agreed to a contract whose terms I have no knowledge of. Either way, I cannot have agreed to a social contract by living in a territory claimed by a state.

More Articles

View All
“Let Them Scream Whatever They Want” | Marcus Aurelius on Panic
How should we act when people around us are panicking? And how can we avoid panicking ourselves? Panic gets us nowhere, as it is a state of emotional turmoil during which our rationality is thrown overboard. So when we’re faced with a wide variety of opin…
What happens when 2 Weedeaters Hit Each Other? (28,000 fps SLOW MOTION) - Smarter Every Day 255
Hey, it’s me, Destin. Welcome back to “Smarter Every Day.” We’re at that magical moment where you build something in the garage, a culmination of a week and a half of effort, and then you kind of all have your hands in your pockets. This is Jeremy filming…
Will future robots & AI take over? | How Sci-Fi Inspired Science
Let’s face it, one of the worst things about adulting is having to clean. If we can get out of it in any way, we’ll do it. And since machines are made to make our lives easier, it makes sense we want a machine made to clean. But in sci-fi, we want to go o…
Sue's New System (Deleted Scene) | Life Below Zero
[Music] So you, I mean, this has been quite the process. The tanks were delivered overland this winter, and now they’re in place, painted, hoses in the right area. Just did the electric pumps, put everything in. The whole thing is new, and it envelopes a …
Why I Dont Trust The Polls This Election #shorts
Kevin, what does your gut tell you about how tomorrow goes? A binary outcome is going to be decided by 3:00 or 4:00 in the morning. That’s my guess, like everybody else is guessing. I’m in the camp that says the swing states all go to one side or the oth…
Anti-Federalists and Brutus No. 1 | US government and civics | Khan Academy
You first learn about American history; it sometimes seems like it might have been a very easy or somewhat obvious transition from the Articles of Confederation to the Constitution, but it was not. It was a very vigorous debate. As we’ve talked about in p…