yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Re: Randyom Neuron (Reply to Everett)


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

Hey Randy,

Um, I'm having a bit of trouble trying to explain myself in the comments, as you've probably noticed. So, this is a short video. Um, Everett's requirement for free work for free will, or rather one of them, was that not only does the self have to be a cause of election X, but it has to be the first cause of that election.

I think the simplest answer that shows that this isn't the case is: first causes are not caused; the self is caused. I hope we can agree on that, and therefore the self is not a first cause of any particular outcome.

So, um, meanwhile what you've tried to do is to show that non-determinism in a neuron could be the first cause of certain elections. What I'm trying to say is that I think you're conflating a neuron with the entire self, while it's just a part of it.

Um, when I think of the self being the cause of something, I think of this cause in terms of something like a decision, in the way we use the word decision in normal language. Um, so I think decisions of the kind "John decided to go to the shop" can be properly considered to be caused by the self, because my intuition is that the self as a whole is involved in some way to get to that outcome.

Um, so if myself causes me to take an umbrella with me, that's the same thing as I decided to take my umbrella. So, myself caused cause of action X is the same as I made a decision in favor of cause of action X.

On the other hand, if a particular outcome can be traced solely to the non-deterministic action of a neuron, as you're suggesting might be the case, I'm not happy to say that the outcome has been caused by the self because the neuron isn't itself.

So, I hope that gives some idea of how I'm thinking about this at the moment. Thanks.

More Articles

View All
How Did OpenAI Go So Badly Wrong?
[Music] Major breaking news, uh, related to OpenAI. Yeah, Sam Altman is out as CEO of OpenAI. Why on Earth is OpenAI falling apart? Last week, we saw one of the world’s most promising companies fall into complete and utter chaos in the space of five days.…
Brave New Words - Ethan Mollick & Sal Khan
Hi everyone, it’s here from Khan Academy, and as some of you all know, I have released my second book, “Brave New Words,” about the future of AI in education and work. It’s available wherever you might buy your books. But as part of the research for that …
How These Lost Bombs Could Destroy Everything
On the 5th of February 1958, a Mark 15 thermonuclear bomb was loaded onto a B-47 aircraft stationed at Homestead Air Force Base in Southern Florida. The plane was to take part in an extended training mission meant to simulate an attack on the Soviet Union…
New Crew, Same Pissah | Wicked Tuna
Chum and they will come with Lance. Brad and I, we are gonna catch a ton of tuna fish this year. Drop you like a bad habit. I’ve known Paul for about two and a half years. He’s a great guy; he’s a great fisherman. The reason why I’m fishing is to provide …
Episode 1 Recap | MARS
Previously on Mars, we knew Mars wouldn’t welcome us with open arms. Warning system offline. Permission was switched from primary to backup. “Do it. Prepare for V’s propulsion.” We were ready to give everything to get there. Mission Control, us in datal…
Startup Experts Share Their Investor Horror Stories
Raising money is a game that you sort of have to figure out. Oftentimes, these meetings can go terribly awry. The worst sort of investor meeting is one that makes you question why you’re even doing a company anymore. Today, we’re talking about our worst i…