yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Re: Randyom Neuron (Reply to Everett)


2m read
·Nov 8, 2024

Hey Randy,

Um, I'm having a bit of trouble trying to explain myself in the comments, as you've probably noticed. So, this is a short video. Um, Everett's requirement for free work for free will, or rather one of them, was that not only does the self have to be a cause of election X, but it has to be the first cause of that election.

I think the simplest answer that shows that this isn't the case is: first causes are not caused; the self is caused. I hope we can agree on that, and therefore the self is not a first cause of any particular outcome.

So, um, meanwhile what you've tried to do is to show that non-determinism in a neuron could be the first cause of certain elections. What I'm trying to say is that I think you're conflating a neuron with the entire self, while it's just a part of it.

Um, when I think of the self being the cause of something, I think of this cause in terms of something like a decision, in the way we use the word decision in normal language. Um, so I think decisions of the kind "John decided to go to the shop" can be properly considered to be caused by the self, because my intuition is that the self as a whole is involved in some way to get to that outcome.

Um, so if myself causes me to take an umbrella with me, that's the same thing as I decided to take my umbrella. So, myself caused cause of action X is the same as I made a decision in favor of cause of action X.

On the other hand, if a particular outcome can be traced solely to the non-deterministic action of a neuron, as you're suggesting might be the case, I'm not happy to say that the outcome has been caused by the self because the neuron isn't itself.

So, I hope that gives some idea of how I'm thinking about this at the moment. Thanks.

More Articles

View All
TIL: Life Could Exist on Mars Thanks to Methane | Today I Learned
[Music] Anywhere on Earth that we find liquid water and other sources of nutrients and energy, we find [Music] life. So, we’re studying bubbles of methane that are coming out of the Earth’s crust in the deep sea. This is a very interesting source of energ…
See Why Sochi Is One of Russia's Best Vacation Spots | National Geographic
[Music] There have been a lot of problems coming out of Sochi. There’s con anxiety among, it’s still a ghost town. Stories such as these have dominated American media, but to me, the portrait seemed incomplete, and I wondered if there was another perspect…
Ionic bonds | Molecular and ionic compound structure and properties | AP Chemistry | Khan Academy
Most of what we’ve talked about so far has been atoms in isolation. We have thought about the number of electrons and protons and neutrons and the electron configuration of atoms. But atoms don’t just operate in isolation. If that were the case, the whole…
How a bill becomes a law | US government and civics | US government and civics | Khan Academy
In other videos, we have first started talking about the legislative branch of the United States federal government. We talk about how it has two houses: the Senate, which has 100 members (two per state, two times fifty), and the House of Representatives,…
How to Evict Your Raccoon Roommates | National Geographic
The main conflict between people and raccoons is when raccoons use human resources to meet their own needs and ends. Raccoons are the quintessential generalist; they really can live in a whole variety of habitats. In Washington, DC, they see urban areas a…
Factorization with substitution | Polynomial factorization | Algebra 2 | Khan Academy
We’re told that we want to factor the following expression that they have right here, and they say that we can factor the expression as ( u + v ) squared, where ( u ) and ( v ) are either constant integers or single variable expressions. What are ( u ) an…