Re: Randyom Neuron (Reply to Everett)

2m read

·Nov 8, 2024

Hey Randy,

Um, I'm having a bit of trouble trying to explain myself in the comments, as you've probably noticed. So, this is a short video. Um, Everett's requirement for free work for free will, or rather one of them, was that not only does the self have to be a cause of election X, but it has to be the first cause of that election.

I think the simplest answer that shows that this isn't the case is: first causes are not caused; the self is caused. I hope we can agree on that, and therefore the self is not a first cause of any particular outcome.

So, um, meanwhile what you've tried to do is to show that non-determinism in a neuron could be the first cause of certain elections. What I'm trying to say is that I think you're conflating a neuron with the entire self, while it's just a part of it.

Um, when I think of the self being the cause of something, I think of this cause in terms of something like a decision, in the way we use the word decision in normal language. Um, so I think decisions of the kind "John decided to go to the shop" can be properly considered to be caused by the self, because my intuition is that the self as a whole is involved in some way to get to that outcome.

Um, so if myself causes me to take an umbrella with me, that's the same thing as I decided to take my umbrella. So, myself caused cause of action X is the same as I made a decision in favor of cause of action X.

On the other hand, if a particular outcome can be traced solely to the non-deterministic action of a neuron, as you're suggesting might be the case, I'm not happy to say that the outcome has been caused by the self because the neuron isn't itself.

So, I hope that gives some idea of how I'm thinking about this at the moment. Thanks.

How much I spend on dating

We Shouldn't Celebrate This

View All

The Power of Transportation | Origins: The Journey of Humankind

[music playing] [motor revving] JASON SILVA: What does it take to power a global civilization to connect billions of people across continents? It takes the power of transportation. From the beginning, speed and strength were paramount in the hunt, on the…

There’s Still Oil on This Beach 26 Years After the Exxon Valdez Spill (Part 3) | National Geographic

So we pulled into this Bay and we’re waiting for the tide to drop. Down, the tide is dropping just before midnight, so we basically have to wait it out. We can look at one of these beaches where we’re told there’s oil, and swimming over the top of the bea…

Practice Makes Perfect | Live Free or Die

[Music] Taking Dly on our first hunt is a great way to balance this life—the wild and domestic. All right, Paul, you hit it! All right, your turn. I feel pretty excited about my first hunt. I’m a little bit nervous about taking a life and the challenge …

If You Were a Tree... - Fan Questions | StarTalk

I’d want to be planted in a wide-open meadow so that every one of my branches can receive all the sunlight at once. I don’t want to have to compete for the photons from the Sun, which is what goes on daily, hourly, in a forest, especially rainforests wher…

An Accidental Case of the Blues | Podcast | Overheard at National Geographic

So this is my first time back getting office in March, April, May, June, July, August—six months. Six months—like a lot of other places in the U.S. in the summer of 2020, our office was closed to help slow the spread of coronavirus. But in August, my prod…

Zero-order reactions | Kinetics | AP Chemistry | Khan Academy

Let’s say we have a hypothetical reaction where reactant A turns into products. Let’s say the reaction is zero order with respect to A. If it’s zero order with respect to A, we can write that the rate of the reaction is equal to the rate constant k times …

Re: Randyom Neuron (Reply to Everett)

More Articles