yego.me
💡 Stop wasting time. Read Youtube instead of watch. Download Chrome Extension

Innovation Requires Decentralization and a Frontier


3m read
·Nov 3, 2024

Innovation requires a couple of things. One of the things that it seems to require is decentralization. I don't think it's a coincidence that the Athenian city-states, the Italian city-states, or even the United States, when it was more free-form and involved less federal government control, were hotbeds of innovation. Because you had lots and lots of competition, people could switch from one state to another if their ideas weren't welcome, and there was a robust competition of ideas.

The real diversity that matters is diversity of ideas, not just diversity of skin color. You also need a frontier; you need something new to explore, either an intellectual frontier or a physical frontier. We've occupied California. If anything, now California is the institution, the establishment—no longer the front of the wild west. Maybe we need one in space. Maybe we need intellectual ones like we have in cryptocurrencies.

It's the nature of wild west's that they're always filled with scammers, they're always filled with crimes, they're always filled with very strange and odd things because they tend to attract a weird crowd. But at the same time, it is where a lot of the innovation is going on. I see a lot of lamenting from old school scientists and entrepreneurs, "Where are the new entrepreneurs?"

Welcome! I think Paul Graham tweeted this the other day. He's the Y Combinator founder, a brilliant guy. He said something along the lines of: Steve Jobs today wouldn't be able to get a job or wouldn't be able to survive at a Silicon Valley company; he'd be canceled by his own team. But Steve Jobs today would be in crypto. He'd be in crypto with all the scammers, all the criminals, and all the weirdos. But at least there he'd have a space to be weird; he'd have a place to be different. He'd have a place to try new things without having to constantly answer to someone.

There's a pendulum between centralization and decentralization. For example, if you look at the crypto world, centralized finance ends up very ossified. You have the government and the regulators telling you exactly what you can and can't do. You get regulatory capture, and next thing you know, Wall Street is sucking 20% of the profits out of the economy, and crypto can replace that. So, you get decentralization pressure where people can do it in a free-form programmatic way, but then you end up with a lot more scams, fraud, and losses.

In old times, you worried about brigands and robbers in the forest, so you appeal to the king. While the king builds a nice keep, the king mints the money. But next thing you know, the king is debasing the currency, and the king is throwing people in jail. Then some people run off into the forest; they become brigands again because they want their freedom. But now, of course, they're subject to attacks and harassment from their peers.

So, there's a natural pendulum swing that goes on in history between centralization and decentralization. I think the arc of technology actually swung us towards centralization in the last decade. I'm a big fan of Amazon, but it's a very centralized entity. There's a decentralization arc that is taking place even in that industry, with things like Shopify coming up, enabling small stores to compete.

Or even local delivery services like DoorDash. They're centralized services, but they're allowing a decentralized army of restaurants and local shops to compete against centralized services. So, we're going to see this arc going back and forth.

More Articles

View All
Ben Silbermann at Startup School 2012
Well, first thanks a lot for having me. Um, it’s really exciting for me to be here in front of like so many people that all want to build cool things. I was getting ready for the talk last night, and I was going back through old emails because sometimes …
Is Reality Real? The Simulation Argument
We humans are unable to experience the true nature of the universe, unfiltered. Our senses and brains can only process a fraction of the world. So we have to use concepts and tools to learn about the true nature of reality. Technological progress not only…
Fishing Tips: How to Modify Your Rig for Rough Seas | Wicked Tuna: Outer Banks
My name is Britton, shocking for non-accountants, and owner of The Doghouse. I’m gonna show you one of the things that we do when we’re trolling in rough weather. Here on the Outer Banks, it’s notorious for windy conditions. Patrolling is a big part of w…
When Watersports Become Dangerous | Science of Stupid: Ridiculous Fails
Some things just don’t go together– oil and water, gas and matches, tequila and fireworks. So you can imagine my concern when I heard about a combination of kayaking and surfing. Then I saw this and thought perhaps I’m worrying about nothing. And then I …
Inverse relationship between capital price and returns | Macroeconomics | Khan Academy
So much of Piketty’s book is about this idea of more, more, and more returns to capital. That the return to capital is going to grow faster than the growth of the economy. We see charts like this, where we have the value of private capital as a percentage…
Camp Khan Parent Webinar
Hi everyone, good afternoon or good evening, depending on where you’re joining us um in the country. My name is Roy, and I’m here to give you a quick overview of Camp Con, our new summer camp. Quick agenda here: we’re going to do intros real quickly, talk…